Readit News logoReadit News
labanimalster · 6 months ago
And this is the oldest opened wine: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carmona_wine_urn
af78 · 6 months ago
My first thought was: what does it taste like? But:

> The vessel contained five liters of wine mixed with the cremains of the deceased and a gold ring at the bottom.

Interesting that someone wished to spend the afterlife in wine.

abdulhaq · 6 months ago
Then again, plenty of people pickle themselves while alive
latchkey · 6 months ago
Who says they wished it?
chrismorgan · 6 months ago
I grew up without liquor around, but with Asterix books. I read of fine vintages like 62 BC. I forgot the stories are set in 55 BC. I assumed good wine was aged for hundreds or thousands of years.
jcla1 · 6 months ago
Even today it is exceedingly rare to find a still-well-conditioned bottle of wine that has the capability to have aged for 117 years or so. Most often sweet wines are capable of this.
LeftHandPath · 6 months ago
If the books are set in 55 BC, how would the characters know it was 55 BC?
_9ptr · 6 months ago
Well, Caesar was born in 100 BC and they knew how old he was. Simple calculation, really.
dfxm12 · 6 months ago
Likely for the same reason they speak modern French.
Amorymeltzer · 6 months ago
A fun read is Benjamin Wallace's The Billionaire's Vinegar. Ostensibly it's about the then-most expensive bottle of wine sold, a bottle supposedly owned by Benjamin Franklin, but it's a good tour through expensive wines and old wines. It's from 2008 so I imagine most of the superlatives are outdated and some of the detecting tech might be improved, but a fine enough read.

Some good lines, perhaps most relevantly: "A truism about mature wines is that there are no great wines, only great bottles."

owenversteeg · 6 months ago
Old wine is a beautiful thing. I've mentioned this on HN before, but wine is a lot hardier than most people think and it is quite possible to age many wines for a century at home. There are many factors that influence whether a wine can be reliably aged - too many to list in a comment - but if you buy a bottle of Vintage Port, Madeira, or Sauternes, it will be enjoyable for decades at the very least.

If anyone here is curious about old wine and wants to drink some together - my email is in my profile.

rwmj · 6 months ago
There's got to be some sort of remote sensing way to tell what it's made of. Mass spectroscopy maybe? Or X-ray scintillation?
TylerE · 6 months ago
Kinda feel like you just keep digging at that site until you find the second oldest bottle of wine, and then just open and analyze that one.

(Tongue in cheek, but only partially)

ginko · 6 months ago
I feel like they could also probably take a miniscule sample (like a cubic mm) without upsetting things. That should be enough to do all kinds of analysis.
margalabargala · 6 months ago
The means by which the wine would be removed would introduce contaminants.

These contaminants might ruin the wine for whatever purpose they are saving it for.

j1elo · 6 months ago
Funny that we can know what's the center of the Sun made of, but who knows what is inside that bottle! :)
jibal · 6 months ago
Unlike a bottle of wine, the sun is an electromagnetic energy source. Without accessing the wine its chemical composition is unknown. Consider medical diagnostics like MRIs and CT scans ... they detect density and shape, but for a biopsy you need tissue.
_9ptr · 6 months ago
Are we even sure the sun isn't filled with a "mix of various herbs"?
jibal · 6 months ago
The best wine I ever tasted was from a bottle of Montrachet fetched from the cellar of friends of a new girlfriend, saved for a special occasion which apparently was them meeting me, which added a nice glow to it.
TylerE · 6 months ago
I wonder what the oldest unopened bottle is that at least appears to be drinkable is. (i.e. uncorked and at least without olbvious sediment)
n1b0m · 6 months ago
The oldest reliably drinkable wine is a white wine from 1472, stored in a 450-liter barrel in the cellars of the Hospices de Strasbourg in France. The wine has only been tasted three times throughout its history:

1576: To celebrate a Swiss alliance.

1718: After a hospital fire.

1944: To commemorate the city's liberation from Nazi occupation.

albumen · 6 months ago
The 1576 event was perhaps the earliest example of deliveroo. As part of a major shooting tournament, a delegation from Zurich travelled by boat to deliver a cauldron of hot millet porridge to the city, to prove they could reach Strasbourg swiftly (in just 18 hours) and still keep the porridge warm. This was a diplomatic performance reinforcing the Protestant alliance and mutual support between Strasbourg and Zurich during the Reformation.
owenversteeg · 6 months ago
It has actually been drank at least once more, by two French oenologists in 1994:

>La verdeur du vieillard En 1994, une analyse du vin de 1472 a été réalisée par deux oenologues, MM. Lobre et Windholtz, prouvant « que c’est encore du vin » et non pas « une mixture bonne à assaisonner » une batavia. Le nez a été jugé « puissant, très fin et d’une grande complexité ». En bouche, ils ont relevé des notes de vanille, de miel, de cire, de camphre et de noisette. Alors qu’un « vin normal » possède 20 g d’extraits secs, celui des hospices strasbourgeois dépasse les 45 g ! Conclusion : « Ce vieillard a conservé une étonnante verdeur », 538 ans après sa naissance.

from https://web.archive.org/web/20131103183014/https://www.lalsa...

deadbabe · 6 months ago
It seems the next time it will be tasted should be sometime in 2130.
Merrill · 6 months ago
An old, unopened bottle of wine is like Schrödinger's cat - it may be alive; it may be dead.