Readit News logoReadit News
vunderba · a year ago
I remember when Adobe demoed this idea of being able to edit waveforms by the recognized text back in 2016 and it was pretty mind blowing for the time.

https://youtu.be/I3l4XLZ59iw

EDIT: I could also definitely see Audapolis being useful if you could integrate it into a podcast's post processing flow (volume normalization, de-essing) by recognizing certain verbal tics and automatically removing them from the audio such as "ummmm...", etc.

suchire · a year ago
This workflow is exactly what Descript does. Transcript-based editing, filler word removal, noise reduction, volume normalization, Overdub spoken word correction using the speaker’s voice, eye gaze correction for video, etc.

Disclaimer: I work at Descript

Philip-J-Fry · a year ago
What ever happened to that Adobe demo? Was that a real product at any point? It's quite amazing how ahead of its time it was. Now that we have AI making people say whatever we want, it felt like Adobe was on the cusp of that then.
codetrotter · a year ago
I remember people saying at the time that “this is the point at which voice recordings can not be trusted any longer”. And then, like you said nothing happened kind of for a few years until the current AI/ML tech got to where it is currently at.
lofaszvanitt · a year ago
Were they strongarmed or self censored themselves? Would be interesting to know the backstory.
bluelightning2k · a year ago
A genuinely free alternative to Descript sounds very useful.

I've always liked the idea of Descript and was considering building something similar before it came out. The problem is my use case is a couple of videos a year so doesn't fit with an expensive monthly subscription

skeskinen · a year ago
I don't know if perpetual free trial fits for your definition of genuinely free, but I'm trying to build a competition for Descript at https://smartmediacutter.com/
hammeiam · a year ago
I've spent some of my free time over the past couple of months working on something similar. It's in a decent state but I need help from somebody who understands the .fcpxml format so you can export your edits to Davinci and FCP.

Take a look at https://matcha.video

skeskinen · a year ago
Hi, matcha.video looks very cool! I'm working on https://smartmediacutter.com which has some overlap in functionality. I'd love to have a chat about matcha and if you have any plans for commercialization, etc.
alok-g · a year ago
Looks useful. Does it export as a video file itself (e.g., mp4)? Thanks.
hammeiam · a year ago
Right now it exports a .fcpxml file which you would import into you editor (davinici, final cut etc) which includes all of the cuts you made. And from there you could move things around, add effects, do color grading, whatever you need to do to get to a final product.
petarb · a year ago
This is awesome to see as an open source project.

This functionality is some of my favorite when editing videos in Descript. It’s so much easier than chopping up waveforms in Audacity

corn13read2 · a year ago
This is pretty dated and doesn't support whisper which is the de-facto speech recognition model currently
alok-g · a year ago
Does it allow using Whisper separately and importing? Sounds like not.
Machado117 · a year ago
The other day I was using the voice memos app on iOS 18 and was surprised to find that it also supports editing the recording by transcript
mavsman · a year ago
I just upgrade to iOS 18 to try this and couldn't find it. How do you actually do it?
Machado117 · a year ago
I think it generates the transcript automatically for new recordings but you can also edit a old one and then generate the transcript from there
alsetmusic · a year ago
One of the hosts of a podcast that I listen to has had positive things to say about DeScript.[0] Just mentioning it because he's been talking about it for a few years so I expect its had a good amount of feature development over time.

[0] descript.com/

mavsman · a year ago
I love Descript. Their "convert to studio quality" feature is better than Adobe's and ElevenLabs, in my experience.

I wondered if this particular feature was really worth paying for so I was happy that I found Audapolis.

pimlottc · a year ago
What does that feature do?