Readit News logoReadit News
Posted by u/grumple 3 years ago
Tell HN: Google search partial outage while rolling out new search?
Currently performing searches. Sometimes doesn't work at all. Searches now seem to display cards when it works properly instead of urls with text.
Fatnino · 3 years ago
I searched for a specific string I copied out of a log file.

Google returned only one result and under it where it usually says what parts of your query it ignored to allow this result through it just had my entire query in full.

So basically I said "find me this" and Google went "I can't find that, here's something completely random from the internet that has nothing to do with anything"

retrocryptid · 3 years ago
But that's what Google does when it's "working."
reitanqild · 3 years ago
Yup. For the last 12 or so years :-/

I naively like to think they chucked a bunch of tests cases at some level when they introduced Google+ (when they threw out the old plus operator to reuse + for Google+ searches) and never recovered after that.

moi2388 · 3 years ago
No, if it’s working it’s more like “I can't find that, here's some completely random Advertisement from the internet that has nothing to do with anything"
matheusmoreira · 3 years ago
It has everything to do with finding more opportunities to spam you with ads.
Fatnino · 3 years ago
Normally I would agree, but this result was to a .gov site run by the state of Nevada.

I'm not in Nevada.

SeanAnderson · 3 years ago
I was literally in the process of searching for comparisons about MSFT vs Google search dominance as it relates to GPT when this happened. I thought I was using specific queries that were giving me intentionally worse results. Wow! I have never seen a Google outage prior to this. It better be one hell of an update or the writing on the wall is becoming clear.
retrocryptid · 3 years ago
You are very clearly the reason Google went down. BAD DEVELOPER! NO BEER PONG!

(This is a joke offered in the spirit of humor and is in no way a criticism.)

exolymph · 3 years ago
> This is a joke offered in the spirit of humor

Hacker News moment lol

retrocryptid · 3 years ago
It's working for me, but there are no web site results (just images, videos and nonsensical Bard responses) so I think it's working as designed. I think the problem is you're expecting Google to return useful results, which is clearly not Alphabet's objective.

[One example of the content on Google search... I searched for "dingo" and one of the responses was "When did dingoes go extinct?" with a paragraph about how dingoes went extinct in Australia 2000 years ago. What color is the sky in your world, Bard?]

vaishnavsm · 3 years ago
Just searched for Docker Swarm, and got [0] one "People also ask" card, one section for images, some related searched, and a button that says "More Results" that doesn't work. Moreover, the formatting of the CSS in the footer also looks weird. Seems like there's definitely been some issue with the deployment.

Edit: using brave and chrome on an Intel Mac, same results for both.

[0] https://imgur.com/a/CA5IB77

valine · 3 years ago
I find it hilarious that if you ask google if google is down, it simply states “No”, despite showing no results.

https://imgur.com/a/AUgMwe2

brookst · 3 years ago
Well I mean it's not down, it's just... broken.

Kind of like when your're nodding off and someone asks if you're asleep. "No," you say, and have no memory of it the next day.

Dead Comment

sdrinf · 3 years ago
A/B test: "but what happens if we show _only_ ads and products"? /s
nerdponx · 3 years ago
When I saw the broken results, I legitimately had to stop and consider if this was what they were trying to do.
retrocryptid · 3 years ago
Well... I've already switched to DDG and Bing, so it probably doesn't affect me at all.
1vuio0pswjnm7 · 3 years ago
Yesterday I tried "I'm feeling lucky" and each time the server returned /doodles, the Doodles page listing all the Google Doodles. I no longer felt lucky.
quaintdev · 3 years ago
Is it far fetched to say that OpenAI is behind this panic at Google?

Well Google has been really good for better part of its time but they have been slacking for few years. I think it's good that OpenAI rocked their boat.

eastbound · 3 years ago
Funny how flimsy dominance is. In a few years, search quality has gone from top to average, then all of a sudden, it’s going into the “irrelevant” field.

Funny how good Microsoft is. Bitbucket is shit, GitLab is barely acceptable, we’ll subscribe to GitHub because it is the best in class. Google’s support is so bad that we’ll subscribe to O365. Now Bing and OpenAI.

Suddenly Microsoft is the main actor on the internet again.

Deleted Comment

PetahNZ · 3 years ago
But isn't the point of "I'm feeling lucky" to take you to the first search result instead of the list? Not just take you somewhere random.
1vuio0pswjnm7 · 3 years ago
It seems that retirning the /doodles page is the intended function of the "I'm feeling lucky button" when the search string is empty.^1

Thank you for the correction. I learned something about that button I never knew.

What did the button do in the years before /doodles existed. The button has existed since the early days, but not /doodles.

1.

https://fossbytes.com/what-does-the-im-feeling-lucky-button-...

https://www.pcworld.com/article/460864/google_changes_im_fee...

robby1066 · 3 years ago
Down for me. Googling "is google down?" hilariously just returns "No."
valine · 3 years ago
Screenshot for posterity https://imgur.com/a/AUgMwe2
ChatGTP · 3 years ago
Those LLMs are such jokers…
ubj · 3 years ago
I was just about to ask the same question. I'm in the Northeastern United States. No web pages are returned when I search. Videos, Images, and news kind of work, but nothing else.

This is the first time in recent memory I can remember Google being broken like this.

sigbottle · 3 years ago
First time in my life I recall Google being down tbh
1letterunixname · 3 years ago
Mid USA here. Wonder if EMEA people can chime in.
wrycoder · 3 years ago
Even YouTube had a problem for me.
quaintdev · 3 years ago
No issues here in India