Readit News logoReadit News

Dead Comment

retrocryptid commented on Electric Propulsion's Dirty Secret: Why Lithium Can't Fly (Or Float) Profitably   kumarletter.com/posts/ele... · Posted by u/kumarski
baq · a year ago
You don’t need to rant when it’s enough to show that a few dozen airliners consume a day’s worth of a nuclear reactor power production (for some size of an airplane and a nuclear reactor; we should be accurate within an order of magnitude). Imagine every single airport needing its own huge ass power plant and you get your point across in an HN comment.

Not sure what’s the point in attacking physicists, either. They should be the first ones pointing this out and I can’t imagine one not nodding in agreement.

retrocryptid · a year ago
but the metric the OP was using was power density. nuke fuels are MUCH more energy dense than hydrocarbon fuels. but putting a reactor on each plane would probably have negative externalities.

but mixing your comment with a few others, maybe a nuke plant on the ground that cracks the co2 in the atmosphere to make carbon neutral hydrocarbon fuel.

retrocryptid commented on Electric Propulsion's Dirty Secret: Why Lithium Can't Fly (Or Float) Profitably   kumarletter.com/posts/ele... · Posted by u/kumarski
buckle8017 · a year ago
Economics.

The solar panels would be more expensive than bunker fuel.

Sails would be cheaper.

retrocryptid · a year ago
it might be fun to try to make a modern wooden sailing ship cargo fleet.

maybe with an emergency diesel engine in the back.

retrocryptid commented on Electric Propulsion's Dirty Secret: Why Lithium Can't Fly (Or Float) Profitably   kumarletter.com/posts/ele... · Posted by u/kumarski
PicassoCTs · a year ago
Would make more sense to produce chemical from solar energy harvested on the water fuels, collect the fuel and then use this with ships
retrocryptid · a year ago
i wish there was more talk about this. it seems i heard a lot about making hydrocarbons from co2 in the air + solar or algae a couple years ago. if your hydrocarbons are made this way it seems they would be carbon neutral.

i'm guessing there's more research to make it feasable since i haven't seen "carbon neutral gas alternative" at the local Chevron.

retrocryptid commented on Electric Propulsion's Dirty Secret: Why Lithium Can't Fly (Or Float) Profitably   kumarletter.com/posts/ele... · Posted by u/kumarski
retrocryptid · a year ago
i would have given this guy credit if he compared cost of production for petro fuels when talking about energy debt.

also conflates power with energy, but fine.

if you talk about cost (dollar or kilowatt hour) per joule delivered to a vehicle and then compared the total cost of electric vs. the total cost of petro, i would listen. but he ignored the fact that petro fuels cost money, energy and water to produce.

and there some things electric motors can do that ice can't. an electric ekranoplan isn't too infeasible, but we know from soviet studies you can't keep salt water out of an aspirated motor when you're that close to the water's surface. turns out electric motors can be sealed against water.

and dissing physicists? wtf? makes me think he failed out of an engineering physics degree cause he didn't understand math. as we used to say, the limit of a bs or be as gpa approaches zero is bba.

retrocryptid commented on Googler... ex-Googler   nerdy.dev/ex-googler... · Posted by u/namuorg
retrocryptid · a year ago
Back in the day Convex Computer Corporation was laying off a large fraction of its staff.

The plan was to come into the warroom and just hang out. Your manager would come and get you and take you into a private conference room to discuss your package with an HR specialist. The packages were pretty decent, at least.

In gallows humor I drew some stick figures on a white board for each of my team with their unix logins below them. As people were RIFfed, I would go over and put a universal red circle and slash "no" symbol around the figures who were laid off.

My time came and I marked myself as a "no" and handed the red marker to a co-worker.

I remember being a little ticked off at my manager, but when I came back to say goodbye to everyone I noticed his figure / login name had been exed out. The last thing he did before metaphorically being shot in the head was to metaphorically strangle half his children.

"What was deluxe became debris, I never questioned loyalty. But this dead end demolishes the dream of an open highway."

retrocryptid commented on Systems Correctness Practices at AWS: Leveraging Formal and Semi-Formal Methods   queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?... · Posted by u/yarapavan
nextos · a year ago
> The average Amazon engineer is not expected to have awareness of CS fundamentals that go beyond LeetCode-y challenges

I find this a bit unsettling. There are dozens of great CS schools in the US. Even non-elite BSc programs in EU sometimes teach formal methods.

There are also some good introductory books now, e.g. [1]. Perhaps its time to interview more on concepts and less on algorithmic tricks favored by LeetCode?

I doubt current undergrads can't go beyond LeetCode-like challenges.

[1] Formal Methods, An Appetizer. https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-030-05156-3

retrocryptid · a year ago
Modern CS programs teach to what they perceive to be the interview their students will encounter after graduation: what is a tree data structure, how to craft a SQL query and how to calculate a CRC with a python library. More advanced CS/CE departments still teach discrete math and compilers/parsing for students intending to go to grad schools.

My experience with recent CS grads is it's easier to hire Art and Political Science grads and take the time to teach them programming and all it's fundamentals. At least they won't argue with you when you tell them not to use regexes to parse HTML.

retrocryptid commented on     · Posted by u/rabidonrails
retrocryptid · a year ago
Maybe we'll see a boost in worker productivity.
retrocryptid commented on Quintrophy1x – A Quantum-Proof Cipher That Leaves AES-256-GCM in the Dust   quintessentropy.unlimited... · Posted by u/uws
retrocryptid · a year ago
I couldn't find reference to quintrophy or quintrophy1x in the IACR eprint archive (or on a google search.) And I think you forgot the references to external review.
retrocryptid commented on The XB-70 (2019)   codex99.com/photography/t... · Posted by u/rbanffy
ferguess_k · a year ago
The Cold War era was the dream of engineers of all participant countries, I figured. Are we close to another one? Just wanna make sure it doesn't turn into a hot one.
retrocryptid · a year ago
yup, there was just so much money flowing around. it was like the dot com era for aeronautical engineers and machinists.

u/retrocryptid

KarmaCake day1637March 11, 2018
About
meh. banned again for saying apple is not the most innovative company in the world and there are numerous copyright issues with MSFT hovering up content from the web and github repos.
View Original