Readit News logoReadit News
1f97 · 6 years ago
hobofan · 6 years ago
This is a slightly different tool. I'd hope that we won't have one of those every day now though.
dang · 6 years ago
It seems much too close to the original Show HN to have a second one two days later. The rules (https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html) say: "New features and upgrades ("Foo 1.3.1 is out") generally aren't substantive enough to be Show HNs. A major overhaul is probably ok."

This may not technically be a new feature but slight variations on the same thing are very much in the bucket that that rule is meant to address.

This is a special case of a more general issue: follow-up posts [1] are not great for HN because they are repetitive, and curiosity withers under repetition. The test we apply is whether a post contains significant new information [2].

[1] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

[2] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

anewlanguage · 6 years ago
It's very interesting to view the results for e.g. "coronavirus". A lone post back in November got no attention: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22019407 It wasn't until January that discussion started when the virus hit the US: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22110873 I wish there was an easy way to zoom in on a date range.
iso1631 · 6 years ago
> A lone post back in November

That would be amazing, but that story was Jan 10th. The next one was Jan 21st.

Also not the oldest, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22000761 is a day earlier, and refers to a BBC report dated Jan 9th

anewlanguage · 6 years ago
I see the problem: I read the date in American format (mm/dd/yyyy) and it's dd/mm/yyyy. That's a very confusing date format, yyyy/mm/dd is better as an international format.
swyx · 6 years ago
is it the mid-month effect or are submissions for coronavirus lower now than they were in Feb? is this a rolling number?
sixhobbits · 6 years ago
This is useful! I was hoping for something based on topic modelling [0] though. Keywords are useful, but often are out of context. e.g. I looked for "writing", and many of the matches have nothing to do with writing as topic, but simply mention it in the headline.

Conversely, there are often topics in the post that are not in the headline.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topic_model

21stio · 6 years ago
I'm happy, that you like it! Yeah, you are right and thanks for the read. I'll have a look into it
captn3m0 · 6 years ago
21stio · 6 years ago
yeah agreed, we will add it. Thanks for pointing it out! :)
EE84M3i · 6 years ago
Unfortunately their API doesn't seem to support the one feature I've wanted from any hackernews API: writing a query that only shows posts that got removed from the front page for being flagged.
mistermann · 6 years ago
That would be a very interesting thing to know, I've noticed that certain topics seem to be considered (by some) to be not appropriate for discussion. It's quite interesting if you think about it, because the ability to notice any trends is affected by the very phenomenon itself.
verylittlemeat · 6 years ago
Tracking flagged/removed comments would be very interesting. I have a hunch that there might be some interesting patterns there beyond obvious trolls or bigotry.
saagarjha · 6 years ago
Right, because certain things are off-topic and metadiscussion on the is also off topic.
victorthehuman · 6 years ago
This looks like something I had in mind a few months ago, but my idea morphed into an HN iOS app client with some extra bells and whistles, not published yet, needs a few more tweaks to pass the app store review.

Anyways this is great, thinking if I could integrate some features into the app.

blader_johny · 6 years ago
This domain is currently on the MetaMask domain warning list. This means that based on information available to us, MetaMask believes this domain could currently compromise your security and, as an added safety feature, MetaMask has restricted access to the site. To override this, please read the rest of this warning for instructions on how to continue at your own risk.
21stio · 6 years ago
Thanks for pointing this out. No idea, why it appeared on the list. There's already a github issue https://github.com/MetaMask/eth-phishing-detect/issues/3835
jpopesculian · 6 years ago
I like it other than the fact that you stole the grin logo: https://grin.mw/
tmikaeld · 6 years ago
Ouch, yeah, it's basically and exact ripoff