Readit News logoReadit News
davedx · 6 years ago
1) The original NASA article had a more in-depth explanation - maybe we could change the story URL to use that? [1]

2) Yes, we've known for a while now that Mars has water ice. This is new science because they've built up a comprehensive map with the goal of identifying good landing sites for future missions to Mars, in particular missions focused on in-situ resource utilization of Martian water ice. The data is derived from current Mars probes, the Mars Reconnaisance Orbiter and Mars Odyssey Orbiter.

[1] https://www.nasa.gov/feature/jpl/nasas-treasure-map-for-wate...

auiya · 6 years ago
Also, although we know there is water ice at the poles, it's locked under a cap of frozen CO2 between 1 and 8 meters thick. This sub-surface water ice between the polar regions is comparatively much more accessible, only 2.5cm below the surface in some cases.
jcims · 6 years ago
I can't wait to see the Mars helicopter scout on the 2020 rover mission. It's kind of useless on its own but if the design works it would really open up exploration opportunities to validate large scale maps like this. Add some kind of tool bay that it can fly around and 'do science', returning to the rover to grab a new tool.
isolli · 6 years ago
Wow, I would have honestly thought that the Martian atmosphere was too thin for a helicopter to fly!

https://spaceflightnow.com/2018/05/14/helicopter-to-accompan...

> She said the size of the rotors was restricted to 1.2 meters by the space available on the Mars 2020 rover’s belly pan. In turn, the 1.2-meter rotor diameter limits the mass of the helicopter to 4 pounds — 1.8 kilograms — based on the rarefied density of the Martian atmosphere.

> “The biggest thing is the atmospheric density at Mars is very thin,” Aung said in an interview Friday. “It’s 1 percent of that at Earth. It’s equivalent to about 100,000 feet in altitude here on Earth. The other difference is the gravity at Mars is lower. It’s about 40 percent. That plays into how much we can lift.”

> The rotors on the Mars Helicopter will spin between 2,400 and 2,900 rpm, about 10 times faster than a helicopter flying in Earth’s atmosphere.

davedx · 6 years ago
It's really cool but I wonder what kind of range it could feasibly achieve. Personally I like the idea of high altitude helium balloons. You can't control the direction but they could stay up for much longer than something that used powered flight.
dang · 6 years ago
wazoox · 6 years ago
Hum, this is a new kind of dark pattern, here's what's happening when I click this link:

uBlock₀ has prevented the following page from loading :

   https://guce.advertising.com/collectIdentifiers?sessionId=3_cc-session_5136ebd9-e4e2-493e-82eb-6d42aeb5c582
I managed by using wget instead...

juancampa · 6 years ago
I was wondering the same thing. What's exactly happening here? Is uBlock origin blocking this page after it gets loaded? I don't see guce.advertising.com ever been requested in the network tab either.
the8472 · 6 years ago
engadget does a HTTP 307 temporary redirect to the site. ublock inserting its warning page leads to a security context switch to an extension page which triggers a dev tools reload which in turn removes the request history. You can view the requests in the global browser console instead.

Presumably the ad would direct you back to engadget once you click or something and add a parameter to prevent an infinite redirect loop.

dylz · 6 years ago
engadget is owned by advertising.com or the same company; they redirect you through it for first party cookie drops for better user tagging.
mangatmodi · 6 years ago
Title is highly misguided. "Nasa identified highly probable zone for mining water ice"
nkrisc · 6 years ago
Tangential, is "ice" ever used in chemistry or other fields to refer to solids other than water? Other than "dry ice," colloquially. Would you ever call solid oxygen, "oxygen ice"?
onion2k · 6 years ago
It's a term used in planetary science too.

Planetary scientists often classify volatiles with exceptionally low melting points, such as hydrogen and helium, as gases (as in gas giant), whereas those volatiles with melting points above about 100 K (–173 °C, –280 °F) are referred to as ices. The terms "gas" and "ice" in this context can apply to compounds that may be solids, liquids or gases. Thus, Jupiter and Saturn are gas giants, and Uranus and Neptune are ice giants, even though the vast majority of the "gas" and "ice" in their interiors is a hot, highly dense fluid that gets denser as the center of the planet is approached.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volatiles

goodcanadian · 6 years ago
I would say, yes, in astronomy, anyway. Titan has methane ice on the surface (as well as liquid and gaseous methane). The polar caps on Mars contain carbon dioxide ice as well as water ice.
SEJeff · 6 years ago
This is super important for SpaceX's idea of ISRU for producing Metholox (fuel for the Starship) on Mars.

https://medium.com/spaceinmylifetime/how-spacex-will-refuel-...

izzydata · 6 years ago
How many times have they found this? I feel like I see this headline once a month.
goodcanadian · 6 years ago
Yes, there are subtleties here that are missed by the headline. Water ice on Mars is not new, particularly in the polar ice caps. What is new is that they have produced a map of (very) near surface water ice at lower latitudes (within a few centimetres of the surface). This isn't exactly a surprise, but it also hasn't really been shown before. It shows that the water is there and widely available.
izzydata · 6 years ago
I'd like to see someone gather up all of the articles relating to water on mars and place them on a timeline with brief summaries of the actual progress being done. To most people it looks like water on mars over and over.
mturmon · 6 years ago
From the abstract of the article in GRL, here's a sentence on the novelty of this particular work:

> While several investigations have already predicted, identified, and characterized some properties of near‐surface ice on Mars, our results constitute a significant advance in the context of the upcoming crewed exploration because 1) they focus on very shallow depths accessible with limited equipment, 2) they provide continuous regional coverage including the mid‐latitudes, and 3) they yield moderate spatial resolution maps (3 ppd [= pixels per degree of lat/lon, I believe]) relevant to landing site selection studies.

The basic measurement used is surface thermal emission vs. time, which is inverted using a thermal model with a rock/ice depth boundary, thermal emission from the surface, albedo, solar insolation angle, conduction by a faint atmosphere, etc.

The paper also mentions that one of the co-authors passed away unexpectedly while the paper was being written. RIP.

hmd_imputer · 6 years ago
That is exactly what I wanted to say as well. It seems every other month, I see the exact the same title. At some point, it loses it becomes just another useless news
8bitsrule · 6 years ago
"You wouldn't need a backhoe to dig up this ice. You could use a shovel"

People in clumsy, restrictive spacesuits, in low gravity, using shovels to crack through the frozen surface? Then using picks to break up the water ice? then carrying tons of said ice to the electrolysis => H2 => CH4 get-me-outta-here fuel machine?

That can't be right. I need to see the full plan here.

lowdose · 6 years ago
For anybody interested more in landing on the moon someday instead of Mars I have good news. It seems that the first person to bring his/her bike to the moon is going to be able to rent their apparatus to successive travelers without running in to the risk of property theft.