Readit News logoReadit News
xvector commented on John Giannandrea to retire from Apple   apple.com/newsroom/2025/1... · Posted by u/robbiet480
consumer451 · 14 days ago
> From the outside looking in it really feels like Apple focused so much on privacy and now has no strategy of how to make that work with AI right now.

Are you referring to https://security.apple.com/com/blog/private-cloud-compute/?

The only way that AI will ever be able to replace each of us, is if it gathers our entire audio, text, etc history. PCC seemed like the only viable option for a pro-AI, yet pro-privacy person such as myself. I thought PCC was one of the most thoughtful things I had every seen a FAANG create. Seriously, whoever pushed that should get some kind of medal.

Are you saying that there is no technical solution for privacy and AI to coexist? Not only that, but that was the blocker?

I am genuinely interested if anyone can provide a technical answer.

xvector · 14 days ago
They are solving for privacy before solving for the UX.

They should actually make something useful first, and then work backwards to making it private before releasing it.

xvector commented on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws   theverge.com/news/823750/... · Posted by u/ksec
BeetleB · a month ago
> The very premise that Meta didn't face meaningful competition from TikTok was a farce.

The original claim was centered around the timeline of purchasing Instagram and Whatsapp. TikTok came much, much later.

xvector · 25 days ago
If this is true, the case then becomes "Meta was a monopoly from start_date-tiktok_date" which isn't a very meaningful claim since they are not arguing it is a monopoly to be broken up.

Anyways, I disagree - this is not the case. If you read the filings and their slides, the FTC argues Meta is a monopoly in the personal networking space.

They essentially carve a market out of thin air to selectively exclude Snapchat, TikTok, and Shorts. The judge has understandably called this for what it is.

It was a phenomenally poorly litigated case, most experts at the time doubted it would succeed, but it did wonders for Lina Khan's popularity. Seems to have served her well with NYC and all.

xvector commented on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws   theverge.com/news/823750/... · Posted by u/ksec
jeffhwang · a month ago
Just to be clear, when you Khan "killed our remaining low cost airline carrier", are you referring to when the DOJ blocked the JetBlue-Spirit Airlines merger? Not arguing, I just want to understand.
xvector · 25 days ago
Correct, yeah.
xvector commented on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws   theverge.com/news/823750/... · Posted by u/ksec
bitpush · a month ago
https://www.theverge.com/news/823191/meta-ftc-antitrust-tria...

It is actually a monumental case ruling, and for some reason it wasnt reported or discussed here. Lina Khan's FTC has lost both their marquee cases now (Google, Meta)

> Meta won a landmark antitrust battle with the Federal Trade Commission on Tuesday after a federal judge ruled it has not monopolized the social media market at the center of the case.

xvector · a month ago
Wasn't the case here really weak to begin with? I remember reading the FTC's initial filings and they just sounded absurd. The very premise that Meta didn't face meaningful competition from TikTok was a farce.

I'm not very happy with Lina Khan after she killed our only remaining low cost airline carrier. And killed iRobot to let Roborock, a a Chinese company, take over.

She "stood up" to big tech, failed, and her remaining legacy is destroying American businesses that people actually relied on. Literally no value was added, but a bunch was subtracted. I never understood the hype for her.

xvector commented on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws   theverge.com/news/823750/... · Posted by u/ksec
zrn900 · a month ago
While they are at it, the EU should also correct another sh*tty law: The Digital 'Resilience' Act (or whatever it was) that holds the Open Source developers responsible for unlimited fines for security issues in their projects.

The Open Source community fought it, and thought that it won a concession, but it really was not a concession: The Eu commission will 'interpret' the law. So it will be interpreted politically - or worse, lobby-driven - with every other Eu commission that takes office.

The law does not allow you to make any kind of income from your open source project in ANY way, and basically forces you to be free labor for megacorps. Charging for support? Responsible for fines that can go up to millions of Euros. Charging for 'downloads'. Same. Licenses? Same.

It looks like this was another law pushed by Eu big software lobbies: Cripple any small player that may be a competitor by building a moat against small players and those pesky Open Source startups that may challenge your online service, but still keep Open Source developers as the free labor for your company's infrastructure.

The tech legislation landscape in the Eu has been co-opted by Eu megacorps. Like I said in another comment, we arent in the early days of the Pirate Party anymore. Now career politicians and sold-out lobbyists make laws to protect megacorps. Therefore Im against any new tech legislation from the Eu, despite having been an early Pirate Party advocate back when even using the word 'pirate' put you in legal trouble.

xvector · a month ago
Big players don't want this either, we rely on open source software and frequently contribute back

This is just another dumb EU reg that hurts everyone

xvector commented on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws   theverge.com/news/823750/... · Posted by u/ksec
Manfred · a month ago
The GDPR is about protecting personal data, what personal data could you possibly need to train an AI model?
xvector · a month ago
Let's turn that around. What personal data wouldn't help train an AI model?
xvector commented on Europe is scaling back GDPR and relaxing AI laws   theverge.com/news/823750/... · Posted by u/ksec
bitpush · a month ago
Didnt the judge rule literally yesterday that this wasnt illegal. This was one of Lina Khan's signature lawsuits, and judge didnt agree even a single one of FTC's arguments.
xvector · a month ago
Where can I read more about this? Quick search turns up nothing for me

Deleted Comment

xvector commented on Checkout.com hacked, refuses ransom payment, donates to security labs   checkout.com/blog/protect... · Posted by u/StrangeSound
miohtama · a month ago
Not everyone gets hacked. Companies not hacked include e.g.

- Google

- Amazon

- Meta

xvector · a month ago
They also have plenty of domestic and foreign intelligence agents literally working with sensitive systems at the company.
xvector commented on Startups are pushing the boundaries of reproductive genetics   wsj.com/tech/biotech/gene... · Posted by u/nradov
bondarchuk · a month ago
Note that kids can't choose for themselves, only their parents. How parents define "improvement" might not always be in line with what the kids would want for themselves either.
xvector · a month ago
Total non-issue. Parenting has never been about what the child wants, only what is best for them.

u/xvector

KarmaCake day7460July 23, 2018View Original