Readit News logoReadit News
xela79 commented on The Hater's Guide to the AI Bubble   wheresyoured.at/the-hater... · Posted by u/lukebennett
zild3d · a month ago
> What do you expect from an unregulated capitalistic system.

Competition, fortunately

xela79 · a month ago
> Competition, fortunately

so there's no competition when there are no rules and regulations... ? interesting.

all those sports without rules or regulations, like american football where anything goes.

xela79 commented on The Hater's Guide to the AI Bubble   wheresyoured.at/the-hater... · Posted by u/lukebennett
xela79 · a month ago
make a technology very affordable, get people hooked. Then when LLM have basically destroyed the open web, charge more for accessing and searching that wealth of human created knowledge. Profit $$$

Ethical approach? hell no. What do you expect from an unregulated capitalistic system.

xela79 commented on Netflix uses generative AI in one of its shows for first time   theguardian.com/media/202... · Posted by u/jmsflknr
kldg · a month ago
It makes sense for short shots, I guess; think a kind of "slideshow of videos"; maybe scene-setting landscape pans, but then you need your production to conform to whatever the AI generates, because it won't conform to what you had in mind. I haven't seen a good example yet of passable scene-to-scene character coherency, so don't imagine we'll be seeing a whole-AI show for a fairly long while. That plastic man short that went viral ~2-3 months ago was not near required "conformity" (that is, the character changed too much between scenes; had too many errors). Would be pleased to see examples of it if it exists, though.
xela79 commented on Cloudflare to introduce pay-per-crawl for AI bots   blog.cloudflare.com/intro... · Posted by u/scotchmi_st
JimDabell · 2 months ago
> it's their ability to provide more up to date information, ingest specific sources, so it is definitely a competitive advantage to have up to date information

My point is that you wouldn’t expect any one of them to be so much better than the others at crawling that it would give them an advantage. It’s just overhead. They all have to do it, but it doesn’t put any of them ahead.

> for a website owner there is zero value of having their content indexed by AI bots. Zilch.

Earning money is not the only reason to have a website. Some people just want to distribute information.

xela79 · 2 months ago
> Earning money is not the only reason to have a website. Some people just want to distribute information.

yes, I just want my hosting costs covered, and that is all. Otherwise you are paying for people to steal the info you "just want to share", the info the others make a profit on... that business model is absurd.

xela79 commented on Stop Killing Games   stopkillinggames.com/... · Posted by u/MYEUHD
VonGuard · 2 months ago
Happens ALL the time. Players even figure out how to emulate MMO servers by sniffing network traffic. When people want to play the game, they will find a way.
xela79 · 2 months ago
I'm not saying it does not "happen ALL the time", but this proposed EU law would make that job easier for the third party solutions, instead of "hoping" for one.
xela79 commented on Stop Killing Games   stopkillinggames.com/... · Posted by u/MYEUHD
VonGuard · 2 months ago
This is one of the few places where the USA has a sensible solution. In 2015, my org (Themade.org) worked with Archive.org, MIT, the EFF, and Harvard Law to obtain a DMCA 1201 exemption for legal DRM circumvention for the case of single player games where online validation servers have ceased operations.

Thanks to the hard work of these organizations, the US market, at least, allows for those who purchased these games to continue to play them with a third party patch to their client. See below:

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/11/new-dmca-ss1201-exempt...

xela79 · 2 months ago
> continue to play them with a third party patch to their client

so hoping that a third party patch can fix the issue. hoping it does. sounds like a very hopeless "legal" workaround

xela79 commented on Ask HN: Is your company forcing use of AI?    · Posted by u/ciwolex
Traubenfuchs · 2 months ago
We recently got Claude Code and there is a very strong push to use it.

I recently did for the first time. Spent 15 minutes writing a long prompt to implement a ticket. A repeated pattern of code, 5 classes + config per topic that deeply interact with each other and it did the job perfectly.

It convinced me that the current code monkey jobs, which are >90%, >95%? of software engineering jobs, will disappear within 10 years.

We‘ll only need senior/staff/architect level code reviewers and prompt engineers.

When the last generation that manually wrote code dies out, all people will do is prompting.

Just like assembler became a niche, just like C became a niche, high level languages will become a niche.

If you still don‘t believe, you haven‘t tried the advanced tools that can modify a whole project, are too incompetent to properly prompt or indeed work in one of the rare, arcane frontier- state-of-the-art niches where AI can‘t help.

xela79 · 2 months ago
> We‘ll only need senior/staff/architect level code reviewers

the problem with that is that if there are no juniors left...

xela79 commented on Ask HN: Is your company forcing use of AI?    · Posted by u/ciwolex
boxed · 2 months ago
Using AI as a search engine seems like the worst of the worst. "You can't lick a badger twice" is a thing...
xela79 · 2 months ago
there's a reason LLM + internet search is quickly becoming the most efficient way to find information, it ingests text content, strips all fluff, customizes it to your specific query. Some offer quick source links too if you want to validate, but nobody is anything of that.

Google-Fu is being replaced with Prompting-Fu

not being allowed or choosing not to spend time learning the limits, benefits and drawback of different LLM models is basically handicapping yourself.

xela79 commented on Cloudflare to introduce pay-per-crawl for AI bots   blog.cloudflare.com/intro... · Posted by u/scotchmi_st
JimDabell · 2 months ago
This seems like it’s going about things in entirely the wrong way. What this does is say “okay, you still do all the work of crawling, you just pay more now”. There’s no attempt by Cloudflare to offer value for this extra cost.

Crawling the web is not a competitive advantage for any of these AI companies, nor challenger search engines. It’s a cost and a massive distraction. They should collaborate on shared infrastructure.

Instead of all the different companies hitting sites independently, there should be a single crawler they all contribute to. They set up their filters and everybody whose filters match a URL contributes proportionately. They set up their transformations (e.g. HTML to Markdown; text to embeddings), and everybody who shares a transformation contributes proportionately.

This, in turn, would reduce the load on websites massively. Instead of everybody hitting the sites, just one crawler would. And instead of hoping that all the different crawlers obey robots.txt correctly, this can be enforced at a technical and contractual level. The clients just don’t get the blocked content delivered to them – and if they want to get it anyway, the cost of that is to implement and maintain their own crawler instead of using the shared resources of everybody else – something that is a lot more unattractive than just proxying through residential IPs.

And if you want to add payments on, sure, I guess. But I don’t think that’s going to get many people paid at all. Who is going to set up automated payments for content that hasn’t been seen yet? You’ll just be paying for loads of junk pages generated automatically.

There’s a solution here that makes it easier and cheaper to crawl for the AI companies and search engines, while reducing load on the websites and making blocking more effective. But instead, Cloudflare just went “nah, just pay up”. It’s pretty unimaginative and not the least bit compelling.

xela79 · 2 months ago
>Crawling the web is not a competitive advantage for any of these AI companies,

?? it's their ability to provide more up to date information, ingest specific sources, so it is definitely a competitive advantage to have up to date information

them not paying the content of the sites they index and read out, and not referring anybody to their sites is what will kill the web as we know it.

for a website owner there is zero value of having their content indexed by AI bots. Zilch.

xela79 commented on !Camera   notbor.ing/product/camera... · Posted by u/ChrisArchitect
xela79 · 3 months ago
this is just an advertisement for an app https://notbor.ing/plans avoid.

build in camera apps are already superior...

u/xela79

KarmaCake day90June 1, 2023View Original