Readit News logoReadit News
writeslowly commented on Human coders are still better than LLMs   antirez.com/news/153... · Posted by u/longwave
decasia · 3 months ago
We aren't expecting LLMs to come up with incredibly creative software designs right now, we are expecting them to execute conventional best practices based on common patterns. So it makes sense to me that it would not excel at the task that it was given here.

The whole thing seems like a pretty good example of collaboration between human and LLM tools.

writeslowly · 3 months ago
I haven't actually had that much luck with having them output a boring API boilerplate in large Java projects. Like "I need to create a new BarOperation that has to go in a different set of classes and files and API prefixes than all the FooOperations and I don't feel like copy pasting all the yaml and Java classes" but the AI has problems following this. Maybe they work better in small projects.

I actually like LLMs better for creative thinking because they work like a very powerful search engine that can combine unrelated results and pull in adjacent material I would never personally think of.

writeslowly commented on AI coding mandates are driving developers to the brink   leaddev.com/culture/ai-co... · Posted by u/bluefirebrand
writeslowly · 5 months ago
One thing I suspect is that leadership at tech companies that would have previously been working off of direct experience with technical processes, even if they no longer work directly on their own codebases, is pretty clueless about AI coding because it's so new. All they have to go with is what they read, or sales pitches, or their experience dabbling with Cursor to build simple python utilities (which AI tools work pretty well for most of the time), and they don't see what it can and can't do on a real codebase.
writeslowly commented on Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scientist   research.google/blog/acce... · Posted by u/Jimmc414
writeslowly · 6 months ago
I recently ran across this toaster-in-dishwasher article [1] again and was disappointed that the LLMs I have access to could replicate the "hairdryer-in-aquarium" breakthrough (or the toaster-in-dishwasher scenario, although I haven't explored it as much), which has made me a bit skeptical of the ability of LLMs to do novel research. Maybe the new OpenAI research AI is smart enough to figure it out?

[1] https://jdstillwater.blogspot.com/2012/05/i-put-toaster-in-d...

writeslowly commented on OpenAI O3-Mini   openai.com/index/openai-o... · Posted by u/johnneville
og_kalu · 7 months ago
I mean, do you think this is awful ?

https://pastebin.com/Ja14mt6L

writeslowly · 7 months ago
This looks like my experiments to get R1 to write fiction and I think it’s worse than what you get from openai. For instance, it’s using very colorful language to describe a place that’s both a remote fishing village on the edge of a cliff hours before dawn, and a bustling wharf with chattering laborers and large ships anchored in the distance. It also starts by saying the protagonist wakes up with his mouth tasting like blood, that he was screaming, and that his throat is hoarse from holding back from screaming. It’s very colorful but it’s very confusing to read.

I suspect you can update the prompt to make the setting more consistent, but it will still throw in a lot of inappropriate detail. I’m only nitpicking because my initial reaction was that it’s very vivid but feels difficult to understand and I wanted to explain why.

writeslowly commented on Did Sandia use a thermonuclear secondary in a product logo?   blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2... · Posted by u/terryf
bee_rider · a year ago
> This is the kind of thing that I think people assume the government labs might do, but in my experience, is pretty unusual and pretty unlikely. In general, you have to remember that the national laboratories are pretty, well, boring, when it comes to classified information. They want to be boring in this respect. They are not doing cloak-and-dagger stuff on the regular. They’re scientists and engineers for the most part. These are not James Bond-wannabes.

The Sandia folks may be extra special, it is a pretty famous place. But engineers are people first of course, so lots of variation. And also, some are super serious of course, but there are hacker tendencies, playful tendencies. I bet if some intelligence agency folks wanted to, they could find some engineers out there who’d be receptive to this sort of thing.

If it is a fake, known-stupid design, including it would be a funny prank that wastes the time of people that might want to nuke us, right?

writeslowly · a year ago
Somebody (probably a programmer or engineer) took the time to create all of that rad 3D word art, multicolored pie-chart, and the mountain logo, it's not hard to imagine they'd also throw in an eye-catching fake nuclear warhead for fun.
writeslowly commented on Panasonic Toughbook 40   connect.na.panasonic.com/... · Posted by u/fidotron
writeslowly · a year ago
What are the use cases for the advertised barcode reader accessory that appears to shoot the laser out the side of your laptop?

https://connect.na.panasonic.com/toughbook/accessories/fz-vb...

writeslowly commented on Does Astrology Work?   clearerthinking.org/post/... · Posted by u/pmzy
mihaic · a year ago
There's a famous study that found that hockey players are statistically more likely to be born in certain months, due to them being the biggest in their year-groups, which created a self-fulfilling cycles of attention from coaches.

Reinterpreted, if you're an Aquarius, you're 50% more likely than an Aries to get into the NHL[1]. So, I guess I do sometimes believe in astrology, it's just very rarely better than random.

[1] https://www.quanthockey.com/nhl/birth-month-totals/nhl-playe...

writeslowly · a year ago
This study tested sun-sign (which is basically birth month I think) against personality tests for predicting life outcomes and found that sun sign did very poorly compared to the personality tests. I'd have thought there would be a small chance of birth month predicting some things, and then adding in other astrological facts (the position of Jupiter or whatever) would make things worse, but both methods appear to be equally bad.
writeslowly commented on A eulogy for Dark Sky, a data visualization masterpiece (2023)   nightingaledvs.com/dark-s... · Posted by u/skadamat
chatmasta · a year ago
Have you used the latest Weather app? Which DarkSky features is it missing?
writeslowly · a year ago
If I wanted to see the heat index at 3PM in Dark Sky, I could just tap the "feels like" button under the hourly forecast (pictured further down in the linked blog post) and look at what it says at 3PM.

I just tried in Apple Weather, and the process was:

1. Tap on the hourly forecast, or the day, to go into the graph screen

2. Tap on the dropdown icon

3. Tap "feels like"

4. Either drag your finger along the graph until the time indicator at the top indicates you're close to 3PM, then read the temperature, or you can try to read it directly off the graph, but the axes aren't labeled clearly enough to make this feasible

writeslowly commented on Automakers Sold Driver Data for Pennies, Senators Say   nytimes.com/2024/07/26/te... · Posted by u/strict9
TheBozzCL · a year ago
A long time ago, I read an article about a journalist that did just that: bought a pack of “anonymized” location data set, then promptly tracked and interviewed one of the people in said data set.

It kills me that I can’t remember where the article was exactly, because it’s one of mu favorite examples of why fighting indiscriminate tracking is important. I remember it being from a Scandinavian newspaper, maybe Dannish?

writeslowly · a year ago
One of the worst (best?) examples I remember was the Web of Trust extension in 2016. The company claimed it was selling anonymized user data but it was actually leaking information through recorded URLs about all sorts of private things like account names, addresses, ongoing legal investigations, etc

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WOT_Services#Sale_of_user-rela...

u/writeslowly

KarmaCake day538May 12, 2016View Original