Readit News logoReadit News
whatsthatabout commented on ChatGPT can be used as default Safari search engine with new extension   macrumors.com/2025/02/24/... · Posted by u/TimLeland
lapcat · 6 months ago
> Maybe you could also test the Qwant extension?

I did: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43175181

There's really no magic or mystery here. The extension is simply using this API: <https://developer.apple.com/documentation/safariservices/sfs...>

whatsthatabout · 6 months ago
I don't know why it's different for you and me then. I tested Qwant once again and saw not one call to duckduckgo (my default search engine) - now I'm over 100 searches while analysing with proxyman without one leak. The kagi extension on the other hand leaked all my first 3 searches. Something must be different.
whatsthatabout commented on ChatGPT can be used as default Safari search engine with new extension   macrumors.com/2025/02/24/... · Posted by u/TimLeland
lapcat · 6 months ago
I have Proxyman and Wireshark. IIRC I used Proxyman also when writing my blog post.

In any case, Little Snitch is not lying and inventing packets. I don't know why you aren't seeing anything, but as I said, it's a race condition, so that can happen, and in any case, I would say that it's a better way to analyze this by adding Little Snitch to your setup.

whatsthatabout · 6 months ago
I quickly downloaded the kagi extension for testing and there I can see the leaking - the Qwant extension still does not leak. Maybe you could also test the Qwant extension?
whatsthatabout commented on ChatGPT can be used as default Safari search engine with new extension   macrumors.com/2025/02/24/... · Posted by u/TimLeland
lapcat · 6 months ago
I just tested with Little Snitch and saw leakage to Google.

It's a race condition, so you might not always see it.

whatsthatabout · 6 months ago
I don't know your setup but in my opinion something like proxyman / mitmproxy or even Wireshark would be the better way to analyse this. I tested quite often and never saw the leak with Qwant.
whatsthatabout commented on ChatGPT can be used as default Safari search engine with new extension   macrumors.com/2025/02/24/... · Posted by u/TimLeland
lapcat · 6 months ago
All the Safari search engine extensions work the same: https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/2025/2/2.html
whatsthatabout · 6 months ago
Interesting, something must have changed then - the qwant search extension definitely does not leak the search to the default search engine - I checked myself with Proxyman.
whatsthatabout commented on ChatGPT can be used as default Safari search engine with new extension   macrumors.com/2025/02/24/... · Posted by u/TimLeland
daft_pink · 6 months ago
Will this still send your information to Google because the redirect sometimes happens after the search has already been sent? I’m curious because I use a similar Kagi extension and I feel like it’s definitely sending my information to DuckDuckGo which sucks. I wish apple would allow more search options.
whatsthatabout · 6 months ago
Depends on how the extension works probably. Had the issue with some extension but the Qwant extension for example doesn't leak - you can check yourself when capturing the http(s) traffic with something like proxyman.
whatsthatabout commented on Show HN: I made a app that uses NFC as a physical switch to block distractions   foqos.app... · Posted by u/awaseem
whatsthatabout · 7 months ago
Cool idea, wanted to try it out but it's not available in my country. Any reason for this? :)
whatsthatabout commented on Reverse Engineering Bambu Connect   wiki.rossmanngroup.com/wi... · Posted by u/pabs3
dlgeek · 7 months ago
What I don't get...BambuSlicer is open source. And, not only is it open source, it's a fork of PrussaSlicer, so Bambu doesn't have the ability to re-license it.

It's licensed under the Affero GPL which is very strict about the licensing of derived works. That license requires Bambu to include the source code to any additions they make, including all of the logic, keys, etc. that they're baking into any binary distributions. If they don't, they're violating the copyright rights of Prussa and many others.

So, either Bambu has to open source all of this, which defeats the purpose (given that it's already leaked, that's gonna happen anyway) or they have to route everything through a separate program for their own slicer.

whatsthatabout · 7 months ago
BambuConnect is not part of BambuStudio - That's intentional, so BambuLab does not need to share/open-source it.

The current implementation (the Bambu network plugin thingy) isn't a part of it either, it's downloaded by the client when BambuStudio is opened.

whatsthatabout commented on Wuppertal's suspended monorail proved its doubters wrong [video]   youtube.com/watch?v=sI5De... · Posted by u/ohjeez
whatsthatabout · 8 months ago
Seeing Wuppertal on the start-page of hackernews wasn't something on my bingo card lol
whatsthatabout commented on Show HN: AutoPiP – Safari extension for automatic Picture-in-Picture mode   github.com/vordenken/Auto... · Posted by u/whatsthatabout
ko3us · 9 months ago
Why do you need to have a lot of permissions for the extension?

This extension would be able to read and alter web pages and see your browsing history on this website. This could include sensitive information, including passwords, phone numbers and credit cards.

You can change this later in the Websites section of Safari Settings.

whatsthatabout · 9 months ago
Hi, I added a part to the GitHub repo explaining this, basically its this:

- The extension requires permission to "Access all websites" solely to detect video players and enable Picture-in-Picture functionality across different websites

- No data is collected, stored, or shared with third parties

- All functionality operates locally on your device

u/whatsthatabout

KarmaCake day158April 26, 2020View Original