Readit News logoReadit News
throwaw4ybio commented on Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture   browndailyherald.com/2021... · Posted by u/andyxor
andyxor · 5 years ago
Cancel Steven Pinker now?
throwaw4ybio · 5 years ago
Think of it more as short-selling Steven Pinker's work in the marketplace of ideas.

edit: I like this analogy the more I think about it. If I tell my friends I strongly disagree with Steven Pinker today and his "valuation" continues to fall, I can gain social credit. There is a risk involved in this, however, because sometime in the future science may gather strong confirmatory evidence that Steven Pinker was right all along, and I'll have to trade in an even greater amount of social capital (e.g. because I'm forced to admit I was wrong or go all defensive kook).

Sorry, following the increasingly bizarre news with cryptocurrency and GME is something I've been doing too much of lately.

throwaw4ybio commented on Steven Pinker Wants to Repair Campus Culture   browndailyherald.com/2021... · Posted by u/andyxor
throwaw4ybio · 5 years ago
>Pinker traces the origins of this dynamic all the way back to 1975 and the publication of E.O. Wilson’s “Sociobiology,” when Wilson and other biologists “would get shouted down” for expressing the view that genetic and other evolutionary considerations determine, in part, social organization.

Two things that might serve as food for thought:

1) I guarantee that know-it-all, newly-minted young adults getting mad at professors didn't start in 1975, though simultaneous social shifts (e.g. things like the anti-Vietnam-War movement) might have made it more socially acceptable for the youngins to speak up in those places.

2) People complaining about being oppressed on campus because of their ideas frequently seem to have the same weird idea. Whereas, no one goes and yells at Lee Smolin when he bags on string theory.

Deleted Comment

throwaw4ybio commented on Nuclear technology’s role in the world’s energy supply is shrinking   nature.com/articles/d4158... · Posted by u/hacksilver
paganel · 5 years ago
> Lower the cost of reinforced concrete.

Is this doable? What's keeping it up? Is it anything artificial, like a business cartel or something similar? If not, lowering the price would practically mean subsidies.

throwaw4ybio · 5 years ago
Cost of materials (e.g. sand) are going up, plus the "nuclear grade" upcharge. Add a 2x to 4x multiplier for "accidents" that require demolition and rework. :)
throwaw4ybio commented on Nuclear technology’s role in the world’s energy supply is shrinking   nature.com/articles/d4158... · Posted by u/hacksilver
rgbrenner · 5 years ago
People who decide to build new plants make their decision not from concerns about climate change, but economics. Building a new nuclear plant would be like building a new coal plant, but worse because by the time it's complete the economics will be even poorer in comparison. Nuclear just doesn't make economic sense on any measure: cost per GW, time to complete, up front cost, regulatory difficulty, etc.

So as much a nuclear advocates wish more nuclear plants would be built, unless they want to provide significant subsidies, it's just not going to happen. For the same reason you don't shop around by finding the highest price you can... no one is looking to throw away money. Energy is energy.. no one cares about the type of plant it came from.

throwaw4ybio · 5 years ago
If you want nuclear to happen:

1) Disrupt the nuclear construction contracting process. Until fleet contractors like Bechtel et al are stopped from parasitizing the industry, it's going nowhete due to spiralling costs.

2) Lower the cost of reinforced concrete.

3) Close the fuel cycle.

3 is technically feasible, 2 isn't very sexy, but possible. 1 seems insurmountable.

throwaw4ybio commented on On Being Blacklisted   aaronkunin.medium.com/on-... · Posted by u/blueyes
walrus01 · 5 years ago
Nobody owes you a free publishing platform. He expects that by calling the publishers of some journal "craven" and "scared", that he's going to elicit a reversal of their decision, and positive response from them, something to the effect of "oh, how dare we deny your article, woe unto us, we were so dreadfully wrong"... Really?

The biggest takeaway that I got from his December essay, and this one? A sense of self righteous entitlement, that whatever he writes must be of such great import and merit that of course publishers should be falling all over themselves to print it. Has he taken the time to sit back and consider that maybe he's not as critically important to the English language literature scene as he believes himself to be?

In general, insulting your potential publishing platform only serves to burn bridges. So, good luck with that, guy.

throwaw4ybio · 5 years ago
If his goal is to change the publisher's mind, calling them "craven" is a terrible rhetorical tactic.
throwaw4ybio commented on Game Theory (2007)   oyc.yale.edu/economics/ec... · Posted by u/bezelbuttons
blablabla123 · 5 years ago
> That tit-for-tat is the optimal strategy in iterated prisoner's dilemmata matches intuition about human cooperation.

It certainly doesn't match my intuition because it's a quite mechanistic view of things. But speaking in mathematical terms, I have the suspicion that it's a solution for a very specific situation that generalizes with negative side-effects to social life. In any case, I've read that governments use this strategy when it comes to foreign affairs.

throwaw4ybio · 5 years ago
I agree, there are plenty of social scenarios that aren't congruent to iterated prisoner's dilemma.

E.g. if you implement tit-for-tat in your marriage, you're gonna have a bad time.

Deleted Comment

Deleted Comment

throwaw4ybio commented on Frustrated with Parler deplatforming, I am building a service no one can silence   1b677b8f8bb20100.github.i... · Posted by u/anon20190221
DanBC · 5 years ago
Why not install INN and then slrn or similar and do it via Usenet?

The free.* hierarchicy is available.

throwaw4ybio · 5 years ago
Would love to see a legit reply to this point. Usenet is there.

u/throwaw4ybio

KarmaCake day49January 21, 2021View Original