Readit News logoReadit News
tapan_k commented on To Make the World Better, Think Small   nytimes.com/2016/12/30/op... · Posted by u/dnetesn
danso · 9 years ago
I'm sure there are essays and writeups about this that I don't have off the top of my head. I do have a lot of examples.

In journalism, this insight becomes quite obvious after you've been on a beat for a few years and see how things really work, that is, how things are mostly mundane, and corruption or injustice isn't obvious because if they were, they would've been snuffed out (or obfuscated). So the devil is always in the details.

One of my favorite Pulitzer-winning stories is an investigation from the Sun-Sentinel (Florida) newspaper that majorly busted cops for speeding. Ostensibly, the big picture idea here is "who polices the police?"...but that by definition is an incredibly tricky thing to identify. After all, it's the police who create and record the data related to law breaking. So how did the Sun-Sentinel do it?

It started off with this widely-shared viral video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hk44_bIhmGY

But the Sun-Sentinel reporters weren't content with the status quo -- i.e. shrugging and thinking oh everyone knows that cops speed all the time. They wanted to prove it. And their method was quite ingenious and so mathematically airtight that cops were being disciplined even before the story came out: http://www.ire.org/blog/ire-news/2013/04/15/how-sun-sentinel...

Here's the entry in the Pulitzer Awards for 2013: http://www.pulitzer.org/winners/sun-sentinel

If you go through the Pulitzer winning entries, many of them include the cover letters for the award submission. Those letters will often describe how a small detail or curiosity grew into a big investigation.

The tech scene is full of examples. Is there a single successful unicorn that, whatever their lofty motto is today, didn't start with fulfilling a very basic need? Facebook's mission today is to connect the world, but its early prototype was a faster way to lookup co-eds. Likewise, Google's mission to organize the world's information began with the implementation of the almost too-obvious (but genius) PageRank/Backrub algorithm.

https://web.archive.org/web/20090126204112/http://ilpubs.sta...

And of course, there's always Dr. Feynman's recounting of how he came up with the idea that would eventually lead to his Nobel Prize: https://www.physics.ohio-state.edu/~kilcup/262/feynman.html

tapan_k · 9 years ago
Thank you!
tapan_k commented on To Make the World Better, Think Small   nytimes.com/2016/12/30/op... · Posted by u/dnetesn
danso · 9 years ago
I agree with the headline, even if the content of the op-ed is kind of a mess. Reminds me of Etsy's Code as Craft Speaker Series. My favorite talks by far were the ones that focused on pretty minute issues, such as how to do A/B testing at scale, or how to manage multiple CDNs. Not because those are issues I've ever had to deal with professionally, but because how the details are dealt with are not only interesting from a technical standpoint, but they provide concrete info about a company's values and expectations. In the talk about multiple CDNs, for example, I found it interesting that Etsy had built a substantial amount of infrastructure to auto-detect the failure of a CDN, but it was always up to the engineer on-duty to wake up and push the button to switch CDNs.

In contrast, sometimes the Etsy talks would have grander topics, such as how to be a better entrepreneur, which were often filled with platitudes that offered no real insight or actionable advice.

As a teacher, I tell students that the best way to make an impact is to focus on the details. Because if you even know the details of an important problem like world hunger or injustice, it at least means you've done some research. More importantly, students need to realize that if something is indeed a big, "important" problem, it means that many, many people have been working on it. If these problems could be solved simply by people thinking, "I want to end world hunger!", then they wouldn't be big, complex problems.

tapan_k · 9 years ago
> I tell students that the best way to make an impact is to focus on the details

Thank you for the insight in your last paragraph. Do you have references that will help me explore this even more?

tapan_k commented on Ask HN: Switching from developer to project manager. What to keep in mind?    · Posted by u/alaaf
heisenbit · 9 years ago
Some PMs wear at times the peer hat. However I believe it is not a good idea to consider yourself a peer. Confusion about roles can lead to conflicts. By design the PM has to have to last word in most critical decisions, especially with outside contacts and that makes one stand out. An important part of the PM role is to say "NO" to all sides - while a peer may say only "no" - and this requires power. How to achieve a power position and how to maintain (wrt. to team but also other parties) it is also part of the PMs work.

Particularly at the beginning I would think carefully - possibly with the help of an experienced peer aka senior project manager - how to divide responsibility in the project. I found RACI (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Responsibility_assignment_matr...) often a robust and quick way to get started navigating a new project setup.

tapan_k · 9 years ago
> Confusion about roles can lead to conflicts.

Agree. Accountability is the key here (this is not about authority). If things do not pan out as expected, the PM must be answerable, and to be in that position, [s]he must have the ability to make the final call in most situations.

tapan_k commented on Ask HN: Advise on CV, etc?    · Posted by u/kryptonic
kryptonic · 9 years ago
Thanks, I really appreciate it =)

What's the best way to contact you?

tapan_k · 9 years ago
My email is in my profile. :) tapan (AT) karecha (DOT) com
tapan_k commented on Ask HN: Advise on CV, etc?    · Posted by u/kryptonic
tapan_k · 9 years ago
I can take take a look. (Thanks for the $10 offer, but no thanks).
tapan_k commented on Finding Wisdom in the Letters of Aging Writers   theatlantic.com/entertain... · Posted by u/diodorus
tapan_k · 9 years ago
> This year saw the publication of the fourth and final volume of Samuel Beckett’s letters, The Letters of Samuel Beckett: 1966-1989, representing his correspondence from the age of 60 to his death at the age of 83.

History has many examples of beautiful revelations from letters written by famous people. I have to wonder what is a modern equivalent of this phenomenon. People seldom write letters these days, leave alone keep a copy for posterity. Emails are private, and are unlikely to be opened up for the general public after the owner is gone. The closest something else gets to this is bloging. However, the author is cognizant of the fact that she is writing for public, while a letter is intended to be read by the recipient alone, thereby influencing the tone accordingly. Is there a way for the future generations to ever learn from the personal message exchanges of today's greats?

u/tapan_k

KarmaCake day134November 16, 2014View Original