Readit News logoReadit News
surgical_fire commented on Why isn't online age verification just like showing your ID in person?   eff.org/deeplinks/2025/12... · Posted by u/hn_acker
miguelbemartin · 6 days ago
In my opinion, access to internet should always be behind a device controlled by an adult. And it should be this adult's responsibility to set appropriate restrictions for minors.
surgical_fire · 6 days ago
This is something I am conflicted about as a parent.

My daughter is still a baby, so the problem is still a few years away. But I don't know how to best handle it.

In some ways, I see social media as more poisonous to the brain than alcohol or tobacco. So, forbidding - or heavily limiting - internet access sounds like a plan.

On the other hand, part of me being a parent is teaching her how to navigate the world. And part of that, wether I like or not, is using the internet. Having contact with the communication tools that exist.

The world is full of sons of bitches. If I don't teach her how to deal with that, I would be raising an idiot.

Still, a problem for the future me to ponder over.

surgical_fire commented on EU hits X with €120M fine for breaching the Digital Services Act   dw.com/en/eu-imposes-120-... · Posted by u/vincvinc
briandw · 12 days ago
Twitter created that definition and now the EU has the divine right to not let them change it? Verified can and does mean many things.
surgical_fire · 12 days ago
Governments actually have the legal right to enact regulations on how companies operate within their jurisdiction.

If the company does not want to comply they can simply stop operating there.

surgical_fire commented on Accepting US car standards would risk European lives   etsc.eu/accepting-us-car-... · Posted by u/saubeidl
jeroenhd · 15 days ago
> Every EU politician who tries to subvert car safety should be dismissed and tried for endangering public safety.

The problem is coming from the other side, the Americans are threatening to start a new trade war if the EU doesn't permit their murdermobiles on the European roads.

IMO pedestrian safety should still come above all else, but this is not an initiative coming from some EU representatives who want to own a Cybertruck. Blocking these cars can have impact on the war against Ukraine and the prices of fuel and other import products on the short term.

surgical_fire · 15 days ago
So let the trade war begin.

Any EU politician that bend over to those threats should never be elected to anything again.

surgical_fire commented on Anthropic taps IPO lawyers as it races OpenAI to go public   ft.com/content/3254fa30-5... · Posted by u/GeorgeWoff25
rvz · 15 days ago
> In a statement, an Anthropic spokesperson said: “We have not made any decisions about when, or even whether, to go public.”

They are going public.

surgical_fire · 15 days ago
Well, they have to. Every grift needs bagholders.

If they get to be a memestock, they might even keep the grift going for a good while. See Tesla as a good example of this.

surgical_fire commented on Atlas Shrugged (2024)   david-jasso.com/2024/04/1... · Posted by u/mnky9800n
tt24 · 17 days ago
1. I’m not an objectivist. 2. Looks like the comment I replied to is heavily downvoted and soon to be flagged. Seems like I’m not the only one that agrees that it doesn’t contribute. I expect a similar thing to happen to yours shortly as well.
surgical_fire · 17 days ago
My comments may be upvoted, downvoted, or ignored.

Either outcome is meaningless. I'll worry about it when the bank accepts internet points as mortgage repayments.

surgical_fire commented on Atlas Shrugged (2024)   david-jasso.com/2024/04/1... · Posted by u/mnky9800n
tt24 · 17 days ago
This doesn’t contribute very much to the discussion. Dang could we take a look at this one as well? Thank you!
surgical_fire · 17 days ago
I disagree. I think it does contribute plenty.

You are probably just butthurt at this ridiculous ideology being exposed for what it is.

surgical_fire commented on Atlas Shrugged (2024)   david-jasso.com/2024/04/1... · Posted by u/mnky9800n
tt24 · 18 days ago
> Keep in mind "Ayn Rand" ended up in the public safety net for care.

There’s no hypocrisy there. She paid into the system. Why shouldn’t she get as much value out of it as possible?

surgical_fire · 18 days ago
Perhaps at that point she realized that her ideas were shit, and a system where you contribute to a public safety net is not a bad idea, it's what society is for.

Or perhaps she was still a dense prick to the end of her days. Who knows?

surgical_fire commented on     · Posted by u/anonymous_ibex
smitty1e · 18 days ago
> 3. Ethics matter. I don't believe there's any life after this one

Serious, non-troll question: why bother?

If there isn't any scope outside of the current perceived existence, and we're all so much "smart dirt", then the difference between kindness and malevolence seems moot.

Note: I do subscribe to an explicit meaning to life, so this is posed more to express bewilderment at the alternative than reveal any anxiety on my end.

surgical_fire · 18 days ago
The universe is meaningless and the world is cursed. Sentient beings are the ones ascribing meaning to the meaningless, uncaring universe. You have only a short amount of time while you can do this. Once life is finished, you just become inert matter.

Curiously enough, I don't think this invites nihilism. The opposite, really. The difference between kindness and malevolence exists because we perceive a difference, and give meaning to actions - they are either kind or malevolent.

If we can give meaning to things, it is imperative that we do so, and act accordingly. It is out little defiance to the great enveloping cosmic nothing.

surgical_fire commented on     · Posted by u/anonymous_ibex
venturecruelty · 18 days ago
>In 2015, I had a lot of interaction with a startup incubator you know well, and ended up sitting in the discussions and planning around banning and erasing a young programmer we considered a threat to our financial interests, due to his concerns about authoritarianism in technology. In retrospect, he was harmless, but an example had to be made. The decision was made to ban him here, try to get him fired though I don't know if we succeeded, and attack him with sockpuppets on Reddit, and it seems to have worked because you don't hear his name much.

Jesus Christ, dude. I'm going to be honest with you. While I feel bad for you in your current state, this is a pretty disgusting thing to have done. Have you tried to make any of it better? I mean, you could name this programmer (assuming that wouldn't make it worse), and you could definitely name the incubator and everyone involved in this decision. I'm guessing this kind of thing is quite common.

If you just want someone to tell you that it's okay, I'm not going to be the one to do that. Be as sorry as you want, but what have you done to make it better for him? Even part of this post reads a bit patronizing ("In retrospect, he was harmless..."). Not "this was intrinsically wrong and we shouldn't have done this", just "he wasn't even a threat to take down". My God, dude.

I wish you well because there are vanishingly few humans I wish to see truly suffer. If you make it, I hope you work towards righting the wrongs you've done.

surgical_fire · 18 days ago
Sociopaths also get sick.

Just because someone might be dying, it doesn't make them nice people.

surgical_fire commented on Stopping bad guys from using my open source project (feedback wanted)   evanhahn.com/stopping-bad... · Posted by u/emschwartz
MagicMoonlight · 18 days ago
Of course it is, that’s literally contract law. You’re agreeing a contract to licence them access with specific terms.

The reason they invented the standard licences is to avoid this cost and effort. Do you really want to write a 200 page legal contract for every user for software you’re giving away for free?

surgical_fire · 18 days ago
Is that the implication? I thought that the legal contract you mentioned was a standard document, basically the same for everyone that was licensed. But I am not s lawyer, and I don't pretend to be one.

It would be neat to have this licese codified (Like we have MIT, GPL, etc), with the proper incentives to "ask for open source access, if I lile you, you might get it". And, of course, a "contract" that gave licensees the open source benefits.

u/surgical_fire

KarmaCake day4146March 16, 2023View Original