Readit News logoReadit News
slg commented on AI tooling must be disclosed for contributions   github.com/ghostty-org/gh... · Posted by u/freetonik
ineedasername · 3 days ago
Courts (at least in the US) have already ruled that use of ingested data for training is transformative. There’s lots of details to figure, but the genie is out of the bottle.

Sure it’s a big hill to climb in rethinking IP laws to align with a societal desire that generating IP continue to be a viable economic work product, but that is what’s necessary.

slg · 3 days ago
>societal desire that generating IP continue to be a viable economic work product

It is strange that you think the law is settled when I don't think even this "societal desire" is completely settled just yet.

slg commented on Porn censorship is going to destroy the internet   mashable.com/article/age-... · Posted by u/Teever
Jigsy · 5 days ago
This was never about "protecting children." It never is. It's always about censorship and control.

The only time politicians ever see children is when they can use them as a soapbox to push an agenda.

slg · 5 days ago
>This was never about "protecting children."

I feel like this narrative is counterproductive. Sure, it is true that some people advocating for this are doing it out of ulterior motives, but it certainly isn't true for all of them. Telling the people with legitimate concerns that they don't actually care about children is going to push them into the camp of the people who want to take advantage of their concern. In order to actually prevent the kind of damage that these censorship systems can inflict, there probably needs to be an actual discussion about the problem these systems are ostensibly designed to address.

People have to remember this is a political issue and politics is about coalition building. Insulting large swaths of the general population as being nefarious liars isn't a great way to build coalitions.

Deleted Comment

slg commented on Pirate library operator arrested, study canceled for 330k members   torrentfreak.com/pirate-l... · Posted by u/speckx
gosub100 · 8 days ago
"It's not copyright infringement! I'm just using it to train my neural networks with the information!"
slg · 8 days ago
This quote is perfectly constructed to underline the hypocrisy considering this case is about pirating educational material. If pirating information is allowed when that neural network you are training is some LLM, why shouldn't it be allowed when that neural network is a human brain?

Deleted Comment

slg commented on How to rig elections [video]   media.ccc.de/v/why2025-21... · Posted by u/todsacerdoti
krapp · 10 days ago
The funny thing is after Trump cried wolf so hard about the 2020 election even if that were true no one would take any Democratic attempt at an investigation seriously.

And Trump has even made statements which can easily be interpreted as admission[0].

But it doesn't matter.

[0]https://www.c-span.org/clip/white-house-event/user-clip-trum...

slg · 10 days ago
I'm incredibly skeptical of the idea that Trump stole the election, especially when stuff like that video is used as evidence. Trump is clearly referring to the 2020 election. He is saying that if that election wasn't "rigged", his second term would be over by now, but since it was (in his opinion) "rigged", he will still be president during the World Cup.

All that said, one thing I can't get out of my mind is perhaps the most consistent trait of Trump's political career is him projecting his weaknesses and crimes on others as a preemptive defense for when those same criticisms are made about him. So any time he accuses his opponents of something, it should probably raise red flags for his own behavior.

slg commented on That viral video of a 'deactivated' Tesla Cybertruck is a fake   theverge.com/tesla/757594... · Posted by u/nosrepa
FreakLegion · 10 days ago
Your analogy contains a category mistake, but no doubt you'll 'examine your prior mistakes so you know what not to repeat'.
slg · 10 days ago
>Your analogy contains a category mistake

Yes, that was exactly the point of my question. I was subtly accusing you of the same thing you are now overtly accusing me of doing. I was showing that we shouldn't look at everything through the lens of a probabilistic model.

The authenticity of the video was not a coin flip in which the results would be random within some sort of probabilistic distribution. We were not predicting a future event. We were observing and analyzing a past event. AlotOfReading didn't just come to the wrong conclusion. Their analysis of the evidence was flawed from the start and that is why I disagreed with them in that original thread before either of us knew the truth.

slg commented on Meta appoints anti-LGBTQ+ conspiracy theorist Robby Starbuck as AI bias advisor   thepinknews.com/2025/08/1... · Posted by u/pentacent_hq
slg · 10 days ago
I understand this topic brings out the worst in some users, but the governing of AI bias is an important issue that is on topic for HN. I don't know what the purpose of this site is if topics like this always get flagged killed within minutes.
slg commented on That viral video of a 'deactivated' Tesla Cybertruck is a fake   theverge.com/tesla/757594... · Posted by u/nosrepa
FreakLegion · 11 days ago
It's the opposite of the point you want to make. This is obvious if you simplify the example to something like flipping a biased coin. If the coin will come up heads 50-eps% of the time, and tails 50+eps% of the time, then the correct prediction is tails. Tails will often be the wrong prediction, but is still the correct prediction to make.

The outcome of this one event simply doesn't imply anything about the correctness of AlotOfReading's model. The model might actually be mistaken, but that's not an argument you've made.

slg · 10 days ago
>The outcome of this one event simply doesn't imply anything about the correctness of AlotOfReading's model.

How many times would you have to burn your hand on a hot stove before you can conclude that touching it will result in a burn?

slg commented on That viral video of a 'deactivated' Tesla Cybertruck is a fake   theverge.com/tesla/757594... · Posted by u/nosrepa
FreakLegion · 12 days ago
Being wrong and making a mistake are very different things. A weather forecaster, for example, can be wrong about the weather without making a mistake in forecasting it.
slg · 12 days ago
Yes, that was the point being made. Immediately believing the authenticity of this video was not just wrong, but also a mistake. Anyone who believed it initially should take this as a lesson to learn to recalibrate their levels of naïveté/skepticism when it comes to random social media posts.

u/slg

KarmaCake day33265March 19, 2013View Original