Readit News logoReadit News
sharemywin commented on GPT-5   openai.com/gpt-5/... · Posted by u/rd
gaptoothclan · 19 days ago
I remember reading that llm’s have consumed the internet text data, I seem to remember there is an open data set for that too. Potential other sources of data would be images (probably already consumed) videos, YouTube must have such a large set of data to consume, perhaps Facebook or Instagram private content

But even with these it does not feel like AGI, that seems like the fusion reactor 20 years away argument, but instead this is coming in 2 years, but they have not even got the core technology of how to build AGI

sharemywin · 19 days ago
the big step was having it reason through math problems that weren't in the training data. even now with web search it doesn't need every article in the training data to do useful things with it.
sharemywin commented on GPT-5   openai.com/gpt-5/... · Posted by u/rd
anon7000 · 19 days ago
True. At a minimum, as long as LLMs don't include some kind of more strict representation of the world, they will fail in a lot of tasks. Hallucinations -- responding with a prediction that doesn't make any sense in the context of the response -- are still a big problem. Because LLMs never really develop rules about the world.

For example, while you can get it to predict good chess moves if you train it on enough chess games, it can't really constrain itself to the rules of chess. (https://garymarcus.substack.com/p/generative-ais-crippling-a...)

sharemywin · 19 days ago
but you could easily build a verifier and if it's not valid have it create a new move until it finds one.
sharemywin commented on GPT-5   openai.com/gpt-5/... · Posted by u/rd
originalcopy · 19 days ago
It always surprises me when someone predicts that keyboards will go away. People love typing. Or I do love typing. No way I am going to talk to my phone, especially if someone else can hear it (which is always basically).
sharemywin · 19 days ago
I talk all the time to the AI on my phone. I was using ChatGPT's voice interface then it failed probably because my phone is too old. Now I use Gemini. I don't usually do alot with it but when I go on walks I talk with it about different things I want to learn. to me it's a great way to learn about something at a high level. or talk through ideas.
sharemywin commented on An LLM does not need to understand MCP   hackteam.io/blog/your-llm... · Posted by u/gethackteam
sharemywin · 19 days ago
LLMs shouldn't really care what format your tool call is in.

so it seems kind of pointless. I would imagine it could ingest soap or a module definition or swagger just as easily and still make calls.

sharemywin commented on The Mythical Machine-Month Paradox – How much could AI change programming?   tucson-josh.com/posts/myt... · Posted by u/tucson-josh
sharemywin · a month ago
I wondered recently how many saas systems could get replaced by a database with a chat front end. is saas going to go the way of cli which was enter by a mouse and gui which was eaten by the web/saas?

if so how much do we need to maintain to keep that kind of system up an running.

sharemywin commented on The Mythical Machine-Month Paradox – How much could AI change programming?   tucson-josh.com/posts/myt... · Posted by u/tucson-josh
sharemywin · a month ago
What if the large tech companies systems are actually just old and we don't need that many people to maintain them and change them. that way they don't have to admit the technology companies are a mature industry and their profits about about to get competed away.
sharemywin commented on Build and Host AI-Powered Apps with Claude – No Deployment Needed   anthropic.com/news/claude... · Posted by u/davidbarker
WXLCKNO · 2 months ago
The tiniest step towards a future where AI eats all apps.

No persistent storage and other limitations make it just a toy for now but we can imagine how people will just create their own Todo apps, gym logging apps and whatever other simple thing.

no external API access currently but when that's available or app users can communicate with other app users, some virality is possible for people who make the best tiny apps.

sharemywin · 2 months ago
I've used the interface in chatgpt to click on a button and talk back and forth with an AI and I could see this being pretty good interface for alot of "apps"

weather, todo list, shopping list, research tasks, email someone, summarize email, get latest customized news, RSS feed summary, track health stats, etc.

sharemywin commented on How renewables are saving Texans billions   theclimatebrink.com/p/how... · Posted by u/adrianN
padjo · 2 months ago
We’re still a long way from figuring out storage for renewables. Here in Ireland in winter we get weeks long periods of calm, cold, overcast weather where renewables generate almost nothing. There’s no known energy storage mechanism that can handle this, so we still have to burn fossil fuels. I don’t doubt we’ll figure it out, but I think skeptics still have a valid point on storage.
sharemywin · 2 months ago
to me this is all % based. 15% natural gas is way better than 90% coal or something like that.
sharemywin commented on The Darwin Gödel Machine: AI that improves itself by rewriting its own code   sakana.ai/dgm/... · Posted by u/birriel
jerpint · 3 months ago
I have a feeling LLMs could probably self improve up to a point with current capacity, then hit some kind of wall where current research is also bottle necked. I don’t think they can yet self improve exponentially without human intuition yet , and the results of this paper seem to support this conclusion as well.

Just like an LLM can vibe code a great toy app, I don’t think an LLM can come to close to producing and maintaining production ready code anytime soon. I think the same is true for iterating on thinking machines

sharemywin · 3 months ago
an LLM can't learn without adding new data and a training run. so it's impossible for it to "self improve" by itself.

I'm not sure how much an agent could do though given the right tools. access to a task mgt system, test tracker. robust requirements/use cases.

sharemywin commented on AI is not our future   procreate.com/ai... · Posted by u/alexharri
sharemywin · 3 months ago
Not what I thought that site was going to be about.

u/sharemywin

KarmaCake day5565February 21, 2011
About
follow me on twitter.com

https://twitter.com/Bob19046541

View Original