Readit News logoReadit News
ronameles commented on Donating the Model Context Protocol and establishing the Agentic AI Foundation   anthropic.com/news/donati... · Posted by u/meetpateltech
mac-attack · 3 months ago
Leaving aside the mediocre reputation of the Linux Foundation, is it true that everyone moving away from MCP and towards Claude Skills at this point?
ronameles · 3 months ago
I think we need to separate what we do in development vs. what happens in production environments. In development using skills makes a lot of sense. It's fast and efficient, and I'm already in a sandbox. In production (in my case a factory floor) allowing an agent to write and execute code to access data from a 3rd party system is a security nightmare.
ronameles commented on The Agent2Agent Protocol (A2A)   developers.googleblog.com... · Posted by u/meetpateltech
zellyn · a year ago
It’s frustratingly difficult to see what these (A2A and MCP) protocols actually look like. All I want is a simple example conversation that includes the actual LLM outputs used to trigger a call and the JSON that goes over the wire… maybe I’ll take some time and make a cheat-sheet.

I have to say, the endorsements at the end somehow made this seem worse…

ronameles · a year ago
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5_WE6cZeDG8 - I work at an industrial software company. You can kind of think of us as an API layer to factory data, that is generally a mess. This video shows you what MCP can do for us in terms of connecting factory data to LLMS. Maybe it will help. A2A is new to me, and I need to dig in.

Basically if we expose our API over MCP, agents can "figure it out". But MCP isn't secure enough today, so hoping that gets enhanced.

u/ronameles

KarmaCake day7April 9, 2025View Original