Readit News logoReadit News
puzzydunlop commented on A New Wave of Underwater Comms Is Coming   spectrum.ieee.org/underwa... · Posted by u/Brajeshwar
abraae · a year ago
I'd like to know more about this process. But ultimately, it can only be detrimental to sealife to emit noise into the marine environment.

Imagine someone set up a radio or a noisy machine somewhere in your own vicinity and you had no choice but to listen to it (even at a low volume) all day and night, perhaps for the rest of your life. Tests might or might not show that you were stressed, but you most certainly would be.

Perhaps I am biased from regular snorkelling and enjoying being immersed n a different natural world, and for sure I do have tree-hugger tendencies. But I find it extremely arrogant that our species thinks it's acceptable to inject noise pollution into an environment inhabitated by thousands of other species.

puzzydunlop · a year ago
Not to get too deep in the underwater weeds here but sound propagation underwater is not omnidirectional like how sound propagates above water. And I’m not sure how true that is either

All that to say, I certainly understand the concern. But I would personally have to see evidence of harm

puzzydunlop commented on A New Wave of Underwater Comms Is Coming   spectrum.ieee.org/underwa... · Posted by u/Brajeshwar
yesfitz · a year ago
I didn't find anything about the potential effects on marine life. I'm not in the market for this, so maybe it's obvious to those who are, but it would be nice to address it somewhere for the uninitiated.

But their modem[1] uses NATO's JANUS standard[2], which communicates at 11.5 kHz, which is just audible to humans, but well within range of marine mammals[3].

1: https://www.subseapulse.com/products/ 2: https://spectrum.ieee.org/nato-develops-first-standardized-a... 3: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hearing_range#/media/File:Anim...

puzzydunlop · a year ago
For underwater acoustic systems there is a well understood and effective marine mammal mitigation process that’s followed. Basically, slowly stepping up in power. Not sure if they’re employing that here but if it involves NATO, I would expect that’s being employed
puzzydunlop commented on Show HN: Anki/Duolingo-like app using educational YouTube videos   platoedu.org... · Posted by u/kirill5pol
puzzydunlop · 2 years ago
This is very cool! I'm trying to do something technically similar by using LLMs to summarize the meeting transcript from youtube (https://parths-newsletter-78dbcb.beehiiv.com/).

Right now I'm doing this manually by copy/pasting into ChatGPT but I want to automate this aspect. I'm not very technical so any guidance you could provide would be helpful :)

puzzydunlop commented on Launch HN: Roundtable (YC S23) – Using AI to Simulate Surveys    · Posted by u/timshell
puzzydunlop · 2 years ago
Very cool idea and I think there’s a thread worth pulling here.

The CEO of Unlearn AI on this podcast (https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/whats-your-problem/id1...) talked about using AI to simulate a larger sample size for clinical trials which is similar to what you are doing here

Looking forward to seeing where this goes :)

puzzydunlop · 2 years ago
Another interesting point about this is that he talks about how it’s mathematically probable that the clinical trial has the power of the larger sample size
puzzydunlop commented on Launch HN: Roundtable (YC S23) – Using AI to Simulate Surveys    · Posted by u/timshell
puzzydunlop · 2 years ago
Very cool idea and I think there’s a thread worth pulling here.

The CEO of Unlearn AI on this podcast (https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/whats-your-problem/id1...) talked about using AI to simulate a larger sample size for clinical trials which is similar to what you are doing here

Looking forward to seeing where this goes :)

u/puzzydunlop

KarmaCake day3July 25, 2023View Original