Readit News logoReadit News
periheli0n commented on Academia’s culture of overwork almost broke me, so I’m working to undo it   nature.com/articles/d4158... · Posted by u/bookofjoe
2devnull · 3 years ago
I think what we call academia isn’t really academia, but a system that’s subservient to the desires of the state. The dollars come from somewhere and there are always strings attached. Sure, a tenured professor has more freedom than the average federal employee, but only because the state hasn’t felt the need to tighten the screws. If policy interests ever diverged from interests of the universities, I think we’d quickly learn that academia of today is not at all what it presupposes itself to be. It’s more of less the Ministry of Truth, to extent required by those who hold the purse strings.
periheli0n · 3 years ago
I think it is easy to produce vague allegations of a lack of integrity, but I would really expect more substance to such a critique.

> ... desires of the state. The dollars come from somewhere and there are always strings attached.

Is this suggesting that the public funders influence the outcome of research? It is not something I have ever witnessed. They sometimes may seek to take influence on the direction of a research programme, especially when the performance is below expectations. but I have yet to see an example where a public funder has attempted to influence research results.

> I think we’d quickly learn that academia of today is not at all what it presupposes itself to be

What does it presuppose to be? Academia of today is 1) a place of teaching and knowledge dissemination, 2) a place of research and knowledge creation, 3) a multibillion dollar business that sells tickets to successful professional lives. The latter leads to overinflated self-marketing, and unfortunately this affects how research results are communicated.

Those who hold the "purse strings" have little interest in influencing research outcomes. Rather, they care about the reputation of their course (students), their own reputation (alumni), recruiting talent and/or outsourcing research (businesses), or actual research results (public funders).

This is at least the case in most institutions in the US and the UK, and most of western Europe.

periheli0n commented on Academia’s culture of overwork almost broke me, so I’m working to undo it   nature.com/articles/d4158... · Posted by u/bookofjoe
periheli0n · 3 years ago
The type of "career scientist" that the article portrays is part of the problem. In order to get ahead with a science career, one needs to pursue an extremely narrow specialisation. Otherwise it is impossible to build a stellar reputation. And reputation is the key determinant for being offered a permanent position at a high-ranking institution.

However, many interesting and relevant problems live at the interface of several disciplines. Unfortunately, those working between disciplines will have a hard time getting a permanent job at top universities: Whatever faculty they apply to, there will always be other applicants who are super-specialised and therefore appeal more to the super-specialised faculty members in the hiring committee. That is why true interdisciplinary research still doesn't happen very much, even though it has been praised and encouraged for more than two decades now.

Coming back to the article, in my opinion the solution to overwork is to cut back on elitism. Less famous universities tend to be more relaxed in their recruitment and tenure criteria. Less pressure means more mental flexibility, which can help maintain a wider network of researchers across disciplines. And the wider the network is, the better the chances of being invited to collaborative projects, especially when one has a record of successful interdisciplinary collaboration.

The price to pay is that one will not be able to impress with the name of one's university when doing small talk. But one will be a much more interesting conversation partner — and have free time to meet people outside work with whom to talk.

periheli0n commented on Breakfast at Bäckerei Frank (2014)   travelhungry.co/blog/2014... · Posted by u/Tomte
casual-dev · 3 years ago
My first time in the UK shook my world: Where is the bread? This is it? That is not bread! After that visit I realized that Germany has a rich baking culture. And yes, we do love a hard crust once in while. So please, leave the Knäusele for me, if you don't like it.
periheli0n · 3 years ago
First thing we did after moving to the UK was to buy a bread baking machine. Not quite bakery-level bread, but good enough for daily consumption, and it leaves a nice smell in the house.
periheli0n commented on Converting my PhD thesis into HTML (2021)   desfontain.es/privacy/lat... · Posted by u/distcs
auggierose · 3 years ago
Thank you for the example! Yes, that definitely looks good, but is still just a webpage. Also, it has pictures with bad resolution, and a latex table that has been rendered as an image for some strange reason. So as usual, it is not consistent in its quality, which is usually the problem.

To compare, open the accompanying PDF, which is also provided along with the webpage. It is of MUCH higher quality, which is partially due to the fact that layout is static.

Furthermore, the webpage doesn't support pagination. The problem is turning it into a book, and there doesn't seem to be a good standard that supports HTML+KATEX/MATHJAX properly. In theory there is no reason they shouldn't, as epub support javascript, but in practice it just doesn't work properly.

periheli0n · 3 years ago
> but is still just a web page

> doesn’t support pagination

Isn’t that exactly the point? Please, no pagination on a screen. A web page will do just fine. In fact, that was what the www was conceived for: publishing science.

> open the accompanying PDF, […] of much higher quality.

The only thing that is higher quality in the PDF is the justified alignment and pagination. The figures have the same (poor) resolution.

The bottom line is: * it is perfectly possible to publish technical papers in a format that is accessible on a phone. * non-paginated, free flowing output also works better on larger screens (e.g) I can resize the window and have my note-taking app open next to the paper. * PDFs are still great for annotating and printing, if required.

periheli0n commented on AI breakthrough ChatGPT raises alarm over student cheating   ft.com/content/2e97b7ce-8... · Posted by u/mfiguiere
periheli0n · 3 years ago
Computer science, and academia in general, has always adapted to technical progress, although slowly.

In the case of ChatGPT and similar LLMs, these should become part of the toolbox that students are being taught. I.e., how does it work, what can it do, what are its limits, how can it be used to help solve a problem or complete a task.

An exam question could then be e.g. to ask ChatGPT for an essay on a topic, critically discuss its shortcomings, and improve the essay e.g. by adding references and deeper discussion, which will be graded.

Alternatively, use ChatGPT to iteratively discuss and improve the essay. The whole chat transcript should be included and will be graded.

periheli0n commented on AI breakthrough ChatGPT raises alarm over student cheating   ft.com/content/2e97b7ce-8... · Posted by u/mfiguiere
localhost · 3 years ago
After reading your reply here, I did the same with a question that I've calibrated over 100s of in-person interviews with college candidates at Microsoft. This is for both intern and full-time candidates. The goal of the question was to probe for technical competence (my role in the loop). The assumption was that anyone who can remember their data structures and algorithms class can make it through maybe 50% of the question. The question got progressively more challenging so that I could see what happens when the candidate reaches the edges of their knowledge.

It starts very fizz-buzzy and if the candidate makes it to the end, there's a deeper discussion of caching impacts on performance and optimizing algorithms. ChatGPT nailed it. Even when I said things like:

"can you optimize this program further to maximize the utilization of L2 caches in modern CPUs?"

And it did it in <10 minutes. The best candidate I ever saw took 25 minutes and the rest of the candidates took the full allotment of time 45 minutes and none of them got to the discussion of L2 cache optimization. These are candidates from the best schools in the country.

This was really impressive.

periheli0n · 3 years ago
The bottom line being, you don't need to hire engineers anymore, just ChatGPT operators?
periheli0n commented on Converting my PhD thesis into HTML (2021)   desfontain.es/privacy/lat... · Posted by u/distcs
dan-robertson · 3 years ago
I think you give latex more credit than it deserves. It gives little straightforward control over layout and the only reason documents are manageable is that pages are fixed size and layout changes are mostly local.

It’s paragraph breaking was state of the art when it was new but other systems break paragraphs now and potentially better. I also think ragged margins aren’t really a problem.

I think if layout mattered as much as you imply, scientists would have to use a tool that offers more control like indesign.

None of this is to say that getting good layout in HTML is easy, of course.

periheli0n · 3 years ago
> I think if layout mattered as much as you imply, scientists would have to use a too that offers more control like indesign.

Yes, precisely that. As a scientist I don't even want to have to deal with layout. That's what publishers are paid extremely well for. When I self-publish content I want the process to be as simple as possible. If this means ragged margins, browser-default styles for headings etc., default colors and fonts — so be it.

(but to be fair, optimising the layout is an excellent way to procrastinate on doing hard research)

periheli0n commented on Converting my PhD thesis into HTML (2021)   desfontain.es/privacy/lat... · Posted by u/distcs
gnull · 3 years ago
If your equations are in MathML, the browsers should be able to screen read them at some point.

> Even slight differences in layout can make a complex set of equations difficult to parse.

Such set of equations should normally be represented by a single block, I can't imagine a reason why layout should change inside that block.

The layout of pdf is unnecessarily rigid. When I'm reading it on my screen, there's no reason the text should be split into A4 pages with very specific margin values. Latex also often moves your figures a few pages ahead because they didn't fit on the specific page. There's absolutely no reason for that when you have access to the big continuous canvas of an html page. This works for equations too; if you have a long equation block that happens to be right between two pages, you either have to let one page have a gap, or reorder/rewrite your paragraphs to make the equations fit. None of this has a good excuse when it's read on a screen.

I don't think we need a website, but a js-free webpage with hyperlinks would be a lot better than pdf. Pdfs I find imperfect but ok.

periheli0n · 3 years ago
> I don't think we need a website, but a js-free webpage with hyperlinks

Wasn't this precisely the use case for HTML and the WWW as originally conceived by Berners-Lee and his fellow internet pioneers?

periheli0n commented on Converting my PhD thesis into HTML (2021)   desfontain.es/privacy/lat... · Posted by u/distcs
analog31 · 3 years ago
It must depend on the field. A close relative of mine is a PhD advisor in a science field. He's hands-off about it, but is also aware of what his students are doing. If asked, he recommends MS Word, which is also what he uses for his manuscripts.

My own experience was as a physics student, 30 years ago. Students paid a heavy price for being able to print and submit the entire thesis with no manual intervention. The students who chose LaTeX took the longest at it. I didn't have access to a Unix terminal anyway, and banged out my thesis on an MS-DOS machine. Whatever my word processor couldn't support, I added by hand. The readers were OK with this.

My solution to all typographic problems was "take care of it after defense." I spent a few days after my defense getting my copy to be ready for duplication, including sticking all of the page numbers on with glue because I couldn't make inline figures work.

periheli0n · 3 years ago
Sure, one can write a thesis in MS Word. It has come a long way with support for large documents. But I still find its referencing clumsy, opaque and unstable.

For example, automatic updates of figure numbers in captions and references: Countless times it failed on me and I had to manually recreate the fields, bookmarks, cross-references, and whatnot is needed.

Bibliographies are hardly doable without an external tool that comes with its own headaches.

Typography in MS word is quite decent these days, though. Anyway, the content of a PhD thesis shouldn't be judged by its typography (as long it maintains a readable standard).

periheli0n commented on Converting my PhD thesis into HTML (2021)   desfontain.es/privacy/lat... · Posted by u/distcs
V1ndaar · 3 years ago
Going by the documentation it does it by... drumroll... converting to LaTeX!

(edit: generating PDFs that is)

periheli0n · 3 years ago
To be fair, there is no better free tool than LaTeX to typeset PDFs. But it fails at non-paginated, free-flowing content.

u/periheli0n

KarmaCake day822February 8, 2021
About
Programmer, Machine Learning guy, Neuroscience graduate, guitar player.
View Original