Readit News logoReadit News

Dead Comment

pentel-0_5 commented on How America traded systematic improvement for quick wins–and lost both   population.fyi/p/process-... · Posted by u/klooney
krapp · 10 months ago
But sortition appoints people to political positions through random lottery. By definition it doesn't consider qualifications to be meaningful.
pentel-0_5 · 10 months ago
Except you made the failure of assumption that it would be of random people exactly like jury duty. I contend that it would be better to pick from a pool of professionals who, as part of their entrance into a professional society, agree also to lend their talents to civic duty for the benefit of all.

Dead Comment

Dead Comment

pentel-0_5 commented on How America traded systematic improvement for quick wins–and lost both   population.fyi/p/process-... · Posted by u/klooney
c6400sc · 10 months ago
I was a mid-level government manager. What most people outside don't understand is that our modern US bureaucracy isn't set up to deal with problems at scale.

This article gives an alternative from history in juxtaposition that would address a lot of problems I saw:

> 1. Systematic Training: The Bureau developed clear, teachable methods that managers of average competence could master.

> 2. Ground-Level Focus: They equipped front-line supervisors with analytical tools rather than targeting top leadership.

> 3. Practical Application: Training wasn't complete until managers had successfully improved an actual process in their unit.

> 4. Long-term Perspective: The program aimed to build sustained analytical capability rather than achieve quick wins.

edit: formatting

pentel-0_5 · 10 months ago
Yup. Big org problems, but specifically big govt org problems. Perhaps also:

5. Systems thinking - To cut though and optimize across organizations requires government "consultants" who can apply systems thinking. They become temporary experts in an area by listening to and gathering feedback from those inside and their stakeholders/customers. It would require a massive org of consultants to address the gigantic US government that is necessary by the scale and scope of America's needs.

6. A panel of wise, benevolent (rather than spiteful/malicious/ignorant) dictators who can make organizational changes the organization itself cannot. This, rather than than politically, keeps the focus on mission and effectiveness rather than political fashions.

7. No more political appointees when it comes to public administration.

8. Perhaps some sort of performance review including an anonymous vote of confidence/no confidence in leadership that has sway in hire/fire decision and keeps managers accountable to deliver for the org. (I'm inherently suspicious of layers upon layers of management unless there is a clear organizational need based on the scale and division of labor involved.)

And, for bonus points, perhaps the US should transition to a method of choosing public administrators including the chief executive by sortition every 2 or 4 years.

pentel-0_5 commented on How America traded systematic improvement for quick wins–and lost both   population.fyi/p/process-... · Posted by u/klooney
pentel-0_5 · 10 months ago
America needs to throw out the entire political system and replace it with sortition because unqualified political appointees are counterproductive by definition. The only way to fix government is slow, thoughtful, and deliberate consultation and reformation rather than arbitrary, agro destruction.

Dead Comment

Dead Comment

pentel-0_5 commented on CFPB's 1,700 employees told to "not perform any work"   nypost.com/2025/02/10/us-... · Posted by u/dataflow
pentel-0_5 · 10 months ago
Because they have more sensible actors, stronger regulators, and less room for corruption that America.

Maybe before you determine, without evidence, that an agency is "useless", you should be honest and dive into the details before making such a foolish statement.

pentel-0_5 commented on Trump says he has directed Treasury to stop minting new pennies   apnews.com/article/trump-... · Posted by u/caminanteblanco
frosted-flakes · 10 months ago
The point is that it doesn't matter, it all evens out in the end.
pentel-0_5 · 10 months ago
I'm not sure what you mean by that platitude.

u/pentel-0_5

KarmaCake day50February 6, 2025View Original