Readit News logoReadit News
pegas1 commented on Cognitive load is what matters   minds.md/zakirullin/cogni... · Posted by u/zdw
tugu77 · a year ago
Re: complex conditionals

I contributed some code to a FOSS project recently which is written in C. In my 10 lines of contributions, 3 were a complex conditional. I'd have loved to do what the article suggests, with some intermediate booleans. But that C version would have required me to define those variables at the beginning of the function, a hundred lines earlier instead of just right there. No way that's going to fly, so now they will need to live with a complex conditional. It's one of those "modern language" features which C fanatics generally frown upon but which makes code much easier to read.

pegas1 · a year ago
Yes, I remember those times, trying to do structured programming in the unstructured environment. So, we both know that even very complex conditionals can be made readable by CRLFs, TABs, and inline comments. It is not about the language, it is about the person.
pegas1 commented on We Can Terraform the American West   caseyhandmer.wordpress.co... · Posted by u/jasondavies
doug_durham · a year ago
That's fantasy. If you don't live in the West it's difficult to appreciate that there simply is no water. No amount of of "swales" or rock dams change the fact that water doesn't fall from the sky in sufficient amounts to create a "lush green forest". Also every drop of water that hits the ground has been accounted for long ago and is part of some water pact. If you create a dam upstream you are guaranteed to get a visit from the water rights holders.
pegas1 · a year ago
Actually, most of these regions have rain. (The Atacama does not!) And you do not need lush green forests right away, prairie grasses are a good start. Well-applied rain retention measures do work.

Deleted Comment

pegas1 commented on We Can Terraform the American West   caseyhandmer.wordpress.co... · Posted by u/jasondavies
pegas1 · a year ago
Before we try to bring water to a desert, we should stop turning livable places into deserts. If you take a ride on the I-20 or I-30, you will see a lot of harmful engineering and inconsiderate land use, both causing regions will lose the rain. You see, the annual average total rain is not given, it can change with the land use and rain handling. Gorchkov and Makarieva put it in good math and named one of these processes a biotic pump. Generally, we need to stop treating the rainwater as an obnoxious waste and we need to stop greedy water management practices and start sharing the water with nature.

BTW: just in case you need to know, I am not a dreamer, but I do have a good education in Hydrology. Currently, I am doing an experiment that will revive a couple of springs with very cheap and simple measures. Everything is measured and documented.

pegas1 commented on Indian academics throw weight behind Sci-Hub and LibGen in landmark case   trtworld.com/magazine/ind... · Posted by u/ofou
einpoklum · 4 years ago
Another opportunity to state the obvious, which is: We should not let governments restrict the dissemination and copying of information - even if they codify it in law and threaten people with jail and fines.

Copyrights (other than the right of attribution and such) are essentially a conspiracy of publishers' cartels, going back to 17th century British law:

"An Act for preventing the frequent Abuses in printing seditious treasonable and unlicensed Books and Pamphlets and for regulating of Printing and Printing Presses". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Licensing_of_the_Press_Act_166...

followed by the statute of Anne etc.

pegas1 · 4 years ago
The copyright -- as long as it serves the author, not to be stolen by the publisher -- is the only source of income to authors outside of the academic world. So, that part has to be preserved. And generally, authors should have a say about the use of their work. Only misuse of the copyright (actually a forceful possession) should be restricted.
pegas1 commented on Indian academics throw weight behind Sci-Hub and LibGen in landmark case   trtworld.com/magazine/ind... · Posted by u/ofou
pegas1 · 4 years ago
The copyright laws need an update so authors are not kept hostage to journals. The amount of work and (almost no) money corporations put into running scientific journals is not proportionate to the power they get.

Also the Antitrust Division of DOJ and the Bureau of Competition of the FTC should look into this. These companies do misuse the monopoly position and even collude and synchronise their actions.

Authors have to publish in current journals, do not get paid and then are not allowed or limited in sharing their work.

pegas1 commented on The Death of Behavioral Economics   thebehavioralscientist.co... · Posted by u/soneca
chongli · 5 years ago
There's no date on this post. I think a far more concerning issue for behavioural economics is that its public champion and most active researcher Dan Ariely is facing serious allegations of academic fraud [1]. If these allegations are proven true then it throws much of the findings of the field into question due to Ariely's prominence.

[1] https://www.dukechronicle.com/article/2021/08/duke-universit...

pegas1 · 5 years ago
not really. So far, the issue is exaggerated. He obviously obraied made up or modified data from some insurance, used them without deep suspicion. Once it was obviousl that there experiments could not be replicated, he did publish the original data. And as soon as he saw indications of inappropriatenes, he withdraw the original paper.

So, so far, one lousy, or lazy and rushed up paper publication.

pegas1 commented on The Death of Behavioral Economics   thebehavioralscientist.co... · Posted by u/soneca
huitzitziltzin · 5 years ago
Actual economist here. Not a behavioral economist but some of my good friends are!

- Priming is social psychology, not behavioral economics. Most behavioralists I know are openly scornful of priming studies, which as the author correctly notes often do not replicate. (Leading example of the kind of thing behavioralists think is BS: “prime people with words like ‘Florida’ or ‘retired’ and they will walk more slowly.”). That kind of study rarely if ever published in Econ journals.

- For his other claim that “Most behavioral interventions don’t replicate,” I would say that most behavioral economists don’t study or design interventions! Much of their work is experimental in nature and focuses on developing more realistic decision-theoretic mathematical models of choice which can be applied in economic modeling outside the lab.

What the author actually has in mind is not contemporary behavioral economics, but rather a subset of social psychology.

Those results used to receive reasonably wide media coverage and were taught to MBAs (generally not by the economists!), but starting around 2010 a bunch of very serious critiques of their statistical methods were raised which undermined confidence in the entire enterprise.

pegas1 · 5 years ago
Thank you, this is a big clarification for me. Isn't the rush to apply prime discoveries in practice the main core of the problem?
pegas1 commented on List of apps people pay for but have low rating   ideasfilter.com/... · Posted by u/visox
ehsankia · 5 years ago
> He was selling this list

Can someone explain the value of such a list, am I missing something? Don't get me wrong, your project is neat and I enjoyed looking through it, but I don't understand how anyone would try to sell this or pay money for this.

pegas1 · 5 years ago
Learn marketing from these guys who can sell mediocre product.

Also, some might sell because their App resembles something popular so some users buy by mistake. Then make sure, it does not parasitise on your app!

u/pegas1

KarmaCake day31December 23, 2013View Original