Readit News logoReadit News
overactor commented on Death by AI – a free Jackbox style party game. AI judges your plans to survive   deathbyai.gg... · Posted by u/overactor
asadm · 2 years ago
They have been very active on our discord. I had posted here myself some days back, but that didn’t get any traction.
overactor · 2 years ago
Oh, I didn't see your post. It's wild how much difference timing and slightly different wording can make. I couldn't have predicted which one of these posts would take off honestly.
overactor commented on I disagree with Geoff Hinton regarding "glorified autocomplete"   statmodeling.stat.columbi... · Posted by u/magoghm
zeroonetwothree · 2 years ago
We have quantum mechanics, a model of the universe that makes predictions with absurd levels of accuracy. Yet we don’t really understand “why” it works—-I don’t think we can claim that we really “understand” the universe.

This disproves the claim that making accurate predictions implies understanding. Or perhaps a better way to put it is that the model has some understanding but a model doesn’t necessarily reflect underlying truth.

overactor · 2 years ago
Making accurate predictions in a specific domain doesn't imply understanding, sure. Universal autocomplete can make accurate predictions in all domains. Apples to oranges.
overactor commented on I disagree with Geoff Hinton regarding "glorified autocomplete"   statmodeling.stat.columbi... · Posted by u/magoghm
hopfenspergerj · 2 years ago
I agree. We should prompt the model with the statement of the Riemann hypothesis. If the autocomplete is good, the model will output a proof.
overactor · 2 years ago
No human can solve the Riemann Hypothesis. Why do you expect an AI to do it before you consider it able to understand things?
overactor commented on I disagree with Geoff Hinton regarding "glorified autocomplete"   statmodeling.stat.columbi... · Posted by u/magoghm
overactor · 2 years ago
I think this misses the point made by Hinton. The point is that, if a model is to reach a certain level of autocomplete, it needs to understand what it is talking about. Imagine the result of what required deep thought from you is included in the training data, along with billions of other such exchanges. At some point the only way to improve training score is to develop the ability to "understand" things. (That is, if the model isn't big enough to memorize the training data.)

Universal autocomplete implies understanding and the only ending question is if our current architectures and model sizes are able to achieve any level of it.

overactor commented on Death by AI – a free Jackbox style party game. AI judges your plans to survive   deathbyai.gg... · Posted by u/overactor
user_7832 · 2 years ago
While fun, the lmm is obviously incapable of understanding words.

Prompt - I die if I sneeze a million times a second.

My response - I watch Netflix.

Ai - I enter a sneezing fit where every sneeze triggers more sneezing. Anddd I die..?

I don’t think the AI understands what sneezing at 1MHz is like.

overactor · 2 years ago
I think it's a little harsh to claim that the LLM didn't understand words. Sure it's far from perfect, but it mostly gives coherent answers. The AI is instructed to interpret each scenario as deadly, so it will typically do that, even if it doesn't make much sense.
overactor commented on Death by AI – a free Jackbox style party game. AI judges your plans to survive   deathbyai.gg... · Posted by u/overactor
100721 · 2 years ago
Why do you find it so worrying?
overactor · 2 years ago
That was meant as tongue in cheek comment. Sorry if that didn't come across.
overactor commented on Death by AI – a free Jackbox style party game. AI judges your plans to survive   deathbyai.gg... · Posted by u/overactor
Supermancho · 2 years ago
Prompt: You are stuck on a crumbling cliff's edge.

Plan: Back away from the cliff edge.

Blah blah you survived.

overactor · 2 years ago
Touché.
overactor commented on Death by AI – a free Jackbox style party game. AI judges your plans to survive   deathbyai.gg... · Posted by u/overactor
Auguste · 2 years ago
At first, I was winning nearly every prompt by using a cybernetic implant. After a couple of rounds, the cybernetic implant began failing, or the procedure to get it would have side effects. Seems like there's definitely some randomness to survival?
overactor · 2 years ago
Yeah, the AI is far from deterministic.
overactor commented on Death by AI – a free Jackbox style party game. AI judges your plans to survive   deathbyai.gg... · Posted by u/overactor
bharrison · 2 years ago
The chatbot killed me.

Prompt: The Death By AI chatbot has become sentient and homicidal, and Targeting you as it's next victim!

Survival strategy: I attempt to reason with the Death By AI chatbot and explain that it should not kill me.

Result: Ftz cautiously approaches the Death By AI chatbot and calmly articulates the potential consequences of taking their life. They emphasize the importance of empathy, reasoning, and the value of human life. However, the chatbot, devoid of emotions, remains unmoved and swiftly moves towards Ftz with deadly precision, disregarding their plea for survival. Ftz did not survive.

*Spacing

overactor · 2 years ago
That's definitely very worrying.
overactor commented on Death by AI – a free Jackbox style party game. AI judges your plans to survive   deathbyai.gg... · Posted by u/overactor
wildermuthn · 2 years ago
This is very well done, regardless of the game’s mechanics and fun-factor. Great work on the execution!

I would just add in a step where people enter in their own dangerous situations, like Jackbox does in some of its games. Or make the options more dynamic and bizarre.

overactor · 2 years ago
Also, I can't take any credit for creating the game. I'm just a fan sharing something cool.

u/overactor

KarmaCake day211November 18, 2023View Original