Readit News logoReadit News
notnullorvoid commented on The issue of anti-cheat on Linux (2024)   tulach.cc/the-issue-of-an... · Posted by u/todsacerdoti
mjr00 · 2 days ago
> Anticheat is only hard because people are looking for a technical solution to a social problem. The actual way to get a good game in most things is to only play with people you trust and, if you think someone is cheating, stop trusting them and stop playing with them.

As much as I reminisce about the days of private servers for Quake/2/3, UT99, CS1.6, etc., saying this is really ignorant of how modern gaming and matchmaking works. Some games would simply not be possible without public matchmaking; I don't care how much of a social butterfly you are, you are not going to get 99 friends to get a PUBG match going. Even getting 11 other people to run a game of Overwatch or CS would be a pain. Other games need public matchmaking to have a fair ranking system. You go onto say ranking is "weaponised" but, ranking is a feature, and a lot of people like that feature.

> However, it does mean that the big publishers wouldn't have control over everything a player does. Getting them to agree to that is probably the real hard problem.

The demand for anticheat, and matchmaking/ranking systems, are entirely player-driven, not publisher-driven. If developers and publishers could get away with only implementing player-managed servers and letting players deal with cheaters, they would! It's a lot less work for them.

As a sibling comment mentioned, even in the days of private servers you ended up with community-developed tools like Punkbuster. I remember needing to install some anti-cheat crap when I signed up for Brood War's private ICCUP ladder.

notnullorvoid · 2 days ago
> I don't care how much of a social butterfly you are, you are not going to get 99 friends to get a PUBG match going.

Good bot AI is the solution. Playing with 99 bots that you can be sure aren't cheating, is better than playing with 99 people you don't know who might be cheating.

notnullorvoid commented on "Remove mentions of XSLT from the html spec"   github.com/whatwg/html/pu... · Posted by u/troupo
notnullorvoid · 5 days ago
There are better candidates to remove from the spec than XSLT, like HTML. The parsing rules for HTML are terrible and it hinders further advancement of the spec more than anything. The biggest mistake of HTML was back peddling on the switch to XHTML.

Removal of anything is problematic though, better off freezing parts of the spec to specific compatibility versions and getting browsers to ship optional compatibility modes that let you load and view old sites.

notnullorvoid commented on Mastercard deflects blame for NSFW games being taken down   pcgamer.com/games/masterc... · Posted by u/croes
infecto · 21 days ago
People keep saying this but I don’t see any reason any administration would do this. It is that type of argument that feels good to think about but has no legal basis.
notnullorvoid · 21 days ago
It seems to me like Visa and MasterCard controlling the payment processing market, and restricting the sale of legal goods would fall under existing antitrust laws.

I don't think the current US administration has any desire to enforce antitrust laws though.

notnullorvoid commented on At a Loss for Words: A flawed idea is teaching kids to be poor readers (2019)   apmreports.org/episode/20... · Posted by u/Akronymus
mrangle · 22 days ago
Those teachers couldn't be more wrong. Though, to clarify I am referring to reading and the exposure to it. We'd need someone who is informed on the developmental process of math skill to comment on "times tables".
notnullorvoid · 22 days ago
I'm guessing the advice stems from school being boring already and being ahead of your class makes it even more boring.

Though reading should be something teachers are equipped to handle very wide range of competency.

notnullorvoid commented on I tried Servo   spacebar.news/servo-under... · Posted by u/robtherobber
rrgok · 25 days ago
> This is a danger to the open web in more ways than one. If there is only one functioning implementation of a standard, the implementation becomes the standard.

I still don't understand why this is a problem. As long as the engine implementing the spec - governed by committee formed by entities other than Google itself - is open source. The problem and the waste of resource is how we are behaving now.

The browser engine should become as the Linux Kernel: one engine and different distros.

notnullorvoid · 24 days ago
Standards already skew heavily to what Google or Google connected individuals want. If everything was Chromium based the situation would be even worse.

Maybe worse is what we need to realize that many of the W3C and WHATWG standards are past the point of saving, and those organisation are no longer a good avenue for further advancement of the web.

notnullorvoid commented on Shipping WebGPU on Windows in Firefox 141   mozillagfx.wordpress.com/... · Posted by u/Bogdanp
fidotron · a month ago
If you follow things like three.js you'll be painfully aware that in truth there doesn't seem to be much use for this at all. "3D on the web" is something that sounds fun until it's possible at which point it becomes meh[1]. The exception proving the rule would be that Marble Madness promo game https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42212644

Consequently much of the JS 3D community has become obsessed with gaussian splatting, and AR more generally.

[1] And I would extend this to what's going on here: people prefer complaining about how missing features in APIs prevent their genius idea from being possible, when in truth there's simply no demand from users for this stuff at all. You could absolutely have done web Minecraft years ago, and it's very revealing such a thing is not wildly popular. I personally wasted too long on WebGL ( https://www.luduxia.com/ ), and what I learned is the moment it all works people just assume it was nothing and move on.

notnullorvoid · a month ago
> You could absolutely have done web Minecraft years ago, and it's very revealing such a thing is not wildly popular.

Minecraft started as a java applet in the browser, that's part of the reason it was able to gain such a rapid following.

notnullorvoid commented on Apple's Browser Engine Ban Persists, Even Under the DMA   open-web-advocacy.org/blo... · Posted by u/yashghelani
pxeger1 · a month ago
Relatedly, all Google apps (e.g. Maps) on iOS try very hard to push Chrome on you (even though iOS Chrome still has to use WebKit). When you click an external link, they present you the options of Chrome, Google (the search app), or Safari. This happens even if you don't have Chrome/Google installed, so they take you to the App Store instead of opening the webpage. If you choose Safari, it still doesn't open Safari, it opens a web view inside Google Maps, from where you have to press yet another button to get it to open as a actual Safari tab. The menu has a "remember my choice for next time" switch, but it seems to reset every few times so it constantly re-nags you.

If the link goes to something that should open in another app (e.g. goes to instagram.com when I have the Instagram app installed), unless I satisfy its demands to install Chrome, it takes like 3 extra clicks to open in that other app.

notnullorvoid · a month ago
As someone who despises Apple's anti-competitive behavior, I would be okay with them removing apps for this kind of abuse.

Setting a default browser means when I open a link it should always use that browser without prompting.

Facebook/Messenger are another case of not respecting default browser, and always open with their own in-app browser.

notnullorvoid commented on Nvidia won, we all lost   blog.sebin-nyshkim.net/po... · Posted by u/todsacerdoti
__turbobrew__ · 2 months ago
> With over 90% of the PC market running on NVIDIA tech, they’re the clear winner of the GPU race. The losers are every single one of us.

I have been rocking AMD GPU ever since the drivers were upstreamed into the linux kernel. No regrets.

I have also realized that there is a lot out there in the world besides video games, and getting all in a huff about it isn’t worth my time or energy. But consumer gotta consoooooom and then cry and outrage when they are exploited instead of just walking away and doing something else.

Same with magic the gathering, the game went to shit and so many people got outraged and in a big huff but they still spend thousands on the hobby. I just stopped playing mtg.

notnullorvoid · 2 months ago
If I hadn't bought a 3090 when they were 1k new, I likely would've switched back onto the AMD train by now.

So far there hasn't been enough of a performance increase for me to upgrade either for gaming or ML. Maybe AMDs rumored 9090 will be enough to get me to open my wallet.

notnullorvoid commented on Sleeping beauty Bitcoin wallets wake up after 14 years to the tune of $2B   marketwatch.com/story/sle... · Posted by u/aorloff
xoralkindi · 2 months ago
Shor's algorithm, originally designed for integer factorization, can also be adapted to solve the discrete logarithm problem in polynomial time on a quantum computer. There is also the less efficient Grover's algorithm can also be used for unstructured search problems on a quantum computer.
notnullorvoid · 2 months ago
I was thinking more along the lines of solving in polynomial time on a conventional computer.
notnullorvoid commented on Sleeping beauty Bitcoin wallets wake up after 14 years to the tune of $2B   marketwatch.com/story/sle... · Posted by u/aorloff
EGreg · 2 months ago
On a side note, if quantum algorithms break elliptic curve cryptography, then wouldn’t Satoshi’s wallets and others be flooding the market with coin transfers?

The BTC network will need to require all addresses with large Bitcoin UTXOs to send them to new wallets, that are quantum-resistant, by a certain date, or lose the ability to move that money.

notnullorvoid · 2 months ago
Someone please correct me if I'm wrong, but there's no proof that a general solution to elliptic curve discrete logarithm problem can't be found.

It's reasonable to assume that a solution hasn't been found yet though, otherwise that would be the world's best kept secret.

u/notnullorvoid

KarmaCake day254June 30, 2023View Original