Readit News logoReadit News

Dead Comment

Dead Comment

nknighthb commented on StableLib – Stable Distribution of Go Packages   stablelib.com/... · Posted by u/joshrotenberg
NateDad · 10 years ago
I have three main concerns - one is that the original package authors get credit... Right now it looks like you're obscuring that by totally replacing the original import path with your own (leaving out the github username).

Second is that I worry that bugs won't get filled against the original repos for people using your version.

Finally, I'd be worried about your version of packages drifting away from the original due to change in one or the other that the other party doesn't agree with. And then as a package author, it reflects badly on my project if your version of my library breaks, even if it's not my fault.

nknighthb · 10 years ago
Your concerns apply equally to software aggregations generally -- e.g. every Linux distribution.

Import paths are not the appropriate method of providing "credit". That's the sort of thing that is handled by copyright notices, documentation, and metadata.

It's generally preferred that if you're using a software distribution, you either test bugs against a "pure" upstream version before reporting them, or report them to the maintainers of the distribution, who can triage and, when appropriate, forward bug reports upstream (possibly with patches).

nknighthb commented on StableLib – Stable Distribution of Go Packages   stablelib.com/... · Posted by u/joshrotenberg
sagichmal · 10 years ago
> Red Hat provides 10+ years on the code they ship. What's so shocking about 3?

Does Red Hat ship (and maintain) arbitrary 3rd party code?

nknighthb · 10 years ago
All Linux distributions consist primarily of third-party code.

I don't know what you mean by "arbitrary", though. It makes no sense in context, and is notably at odds with your earlier use of the word "curated". Nobody ships random code. That wouldn't be curated, nor would it be useful.

nknighthb commented on StableLib – Stable Distribution of Go Packages   stablelib.com/... · Posted by u/joshrotenberg
sagichmal · 10 years ago
I'm confused, is this a curated set of existing Go libraries, or a brand-new set of libraries? If the former, how are they going to guarantee their "3 years of bug fixes"? If the latter, why should I trust them to produce higher-quality code than the community has already?
nknighthb · 10 years ago
> I'm confused, is this a curated set of existing Go libraries, or a brand-new set of libraries?

Toward the bottom of the page they talk about contributing back to open source projects and sponsoring the development of some packages, so it certainly appears to be a curated set of existing Go libraries.

> If the former, how are they going to guarantee their "3 years of bug fixes"?

Red Hat provides 10+ years on the code they ship. What's so shocking about 3?

nknighthb commented on A man who was accidentally released from prison 88 years early   themarshallproject.org/20... · Posted by u/danso
fixxer · 10 years ago
I am responsible for my actions. I own my mistakes rather than blame society. Lots of people come from nothing and don't resort to crime. Your view is one of the worst types of liberal elitism and I honestly am repulsed by it.
nknighthb · 10 years ago
Your view is one of the worst types of conservative inhumanity and I honestly am repulsed by it.
nknighthb commented on A man who was accidentally released from prison 88 years early   themarshallproject.org/20... · Posted by u/danso
fixxer · 10 years ago
I agree with you to an extent. Where was the robber's empathy and humanity when he decided to commit a violent crime?

I'm sticking with "fuck this guy".

If you really want to bear a cross, I can think of a few better candidates for your poster boy of injustice.

nknighthb · 10 years ago
> Where was the robber's empathy and humanity when he decided to commit a violent crime?

Where was ours when we drove him to that crime?

> I can think of a few better candidates for your poster boy of injustice.

Unlike some people, I don't feel it is morally appropriate to pick and choose who gets justice.

nknighthb commented on A man who was accidentally released from prison 88 years early   themarshallproject.org/20... · Posted by u/danso
jessaustin · 10 years ago
The Colorado governor may pardon any Colorado conviction other than those for treason or impeachment. The entire point of this thread is that the governors are culpable for the injustice of the system. Their opinions don't absolve them of that.
nknighthb · 10 years ago
The comment I responded to said "And mass pardons of federal prison could hint the governors about their power too.". This suggests two mistaken beliefs:

1) That governors as a whole have these powers.

2) That "hints about their power" would prompt them to act in the manner he wishes.

The governors don't need hints about their power in this area, they are well aware of it. They don't fail to exercise it as he wants them to because they need a "hint", they fail to exercise it as he wants them to because they do not agree with him.

I'm not addressing the thread as a whole. I'm addressing this little corner of it. I'm under no obligation to address the thread as a whole in every comment I make, and doing so would be both pointless and tiring.

nknighthb commented on A man who was accidentally released from prison 88 years early   themarshallproject.org/20... · Posted by u/danso
fixxer · 10 years ago
You are criticizing a negative feedback loop while simultaneously endorsing policies that would create equally detrimental feedback loops.

What is true justice?

nknighthb · 10 years ago
Whatever justice is, it cannot be the vengeful, racist, wealth-centered system we have now. Nor can it possibly be found in the the mind of anyone prone to uttering the phrase "fuck this guy".

Whatever justice is, it cannot be forfeiting our own empathy and humanity.

nknighthb commented on A man who was accidentally released from prison 88 years early   themarshallproject.org/20... · Posted by u/danso
venomsnake · 10 years ago
There are enough federal inmates with good reasons for pardon. And mass pardons of federal prison could hint the governors about their power too.
nknighthb · 10 years ago
1) The governors have powers that vary from zilch to equal to the President's. This is determined state-by-state.

2) You are mistaken if you believe all or even a substantial minority of the governors would ever agree with your views in this matter.

u/nknighthb

KarmaCake day4726April 5, 2013View Original