Readit News logoReadit News
necklesspen commented on OpenClaw is changing my life   reorx.com/blog/openclaw-i... · Posted by u/novoreorx
necklesspen · a month ago
The same author had good things to say about the R1, a device you generally won't see many glowing reviews about. (https://reorx.com/blog/rabbit-r1-the-upgraded-replacement-fo...)

Maybe it's unfair to judge an author's current opinion by their past opinion - but since the piece is ultimately an opinion based on their own experience I'm going to take it along a giant pile of salt that the author's standards for the output of AI tools are vastly different than mine.

necklesspen commented on Open-source Zig book   zigbook.net... · Posted by u/rudedogg
PaulRobinson · 4 months ago
This looks like more data towards the "LLMs were involved" side of the argument, but as my other comment pointed out, that might not be an issue.

We're used to errata and fixing up stuff produced by humans, so if we can fix this resource, it might actually be valuable and more useful than anything that existed before it. Maybe.

One of my things with AI is that if we assume it is there to replace humans, we are always going to find it disappointing. If we use it as a tool to augment, we might find it very useful.

A colleague used to describe it (long before GenAI, when we were talking about technology automation more generally) as following: "we're not trying to build a super intelligent killer robot to replace Deidre in accounts. Deidre knows things. We just want to give her better tools".

So, it seems like this needs some editing, but it still has value if we want it to have value. I'd rather this was fixed than thrown away (I'm biased, I want to learn systems programming in zig and want a good resource to do so), and yes the author should have been more upfront about it, and asked for reviewers, but we have it now. What to do?

necklesspen · 4 months ago
There's a difference between the author being more upfront about it and straight-up lying on multiple locations that zero AI is involved. It's stated on the landing page, documentation and GitHub - and there might be more locations I havent' seen.

Personally, I would want no involvement in a project where the maintainer is this manipulative and I would find it a tragedy if any people contributed to their project.

necklesspen commented on A secret to never forgetting numbers   ninjasandrobots.com/the-n... · Posted by u/nate
deathanatos · 4 months ago
This makes me think of two things:

1. the NATO alphabet. (Alfa, bravo, charlie, delta…) It's surprisingly easy to memorize: it will only take you a few sittings of practice. And it's useful, for when you need to turn letters into words. And then people cutely wonder if you're ex-military.

2. I tie a small ribbon to my luggage. It could be anything: string, tinsel. If you're familiar with wine glass charms, same idea. It makes the bag identifiable from distance, so long as the charm is in line of sight. It does not, remarkably, stop strangers from grabbing the wrong bag, but it does get funny if they insist they recognize their bag when you ask them "you tied sparkly pink ribbon to your bag?"

necklesspen · 4 months ago
On a side note, the NATO alphabet is quite normalised in the Netherlands - most telephone operators will default to it when providing you information and likewise there is an expectation on you to use it when providing spelling sensitive information such as emails.
necklesspen commented on What is “good taste” in software engineering?   seangoedecke.com/taste/... · Posted by u/olayiwoladekoya
whstl · 6 months ago
I don't agree with the statement that clothes can be "by themselves independently are meaningless". Garments carry cultural, historical and symbolic weight even before they're combined. And fashion is hardly mainly about combining outfits.

And fashion is a lot about tradeoffs too. Not just in the production, but also in the day to day wearing and mix-and-matching part.

necklesspen · 6 months ago
Meaningless in the context of an outfit - not necessarily whether the garment itself may have meaning to someone. You may surely be in possession of a couple of random trinkets of great historic significance but if you just mesh them all together into one outfit you might simply end up with a mess on your hands. A garment may well be the centerpiece of an outfit - but it is ultimately always the combination that is important.

Im sure you've seen examples of this yourself - you can absolutely sport a Ray Ban in good taste and you've almost surely seen someone believe themselves to be fashionable because they are wearing a Ray Ban.

Also, I'm not suggesting fashion as a whole is about combing outfits - merely that being able to combine varying pieces of clothing into a cohesive whole is an expression of good taste.

necklesspen commented on What is “good taste” in software engineering?   seangoedecke.com/taste/... · Posted by u/olayiwoladekoya
necklesspen · 6 months ago
When used in the domain of fashion "good taste" describes someone who has a unique way of selecting clothes that just mesh well together - clothes that by themselves independently are meaningless, no matter their make or quality, but when combined together create a powerful effect - much greater than the sum of their parts.

I was hoping the article would go in that direction - what subjective combination is a software engineer deciding on that you can argue is truly a matter of taste and not just a technical decision about a trade-off.

I would say this this article itself may be an example of bad taste. It meanders across a couple of disparate topics in software engineering, independently each section is competently written but as a whole they really don't sell the "look" the article was aiming for.

(I don't mean to discourage future writing by the author - I think it's a potentially excellent choice of topic. I'm just giving my two cents here on the execution.)

necklesspen commented on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites   bbc.co.uk/news/live/ckg3r... · Posted by u/mattcollins
riffraff · 9 months ago
Can you think of a regime that was bombed by foreigners and quickly fell?

I cannot. Ground occupation, yes. But afaict bombing just reinforces the regime.

necklesspen · 9 months ago
It didn't literally cause a regime change but the NATO bombing of Yugoslavia was essentially the last nail in the coffin for the Milosevic regime.

The key element is where the will of the people points - Milosevic was already unpopular and the bombing further united the people against him.

The few Iranians I know are against the regime, but I don't know how the wider picture looks.

u/necklesspen

KarmaCake day119June 25, 2018View Original