Readit News logoReadit News
mitchitized commented on Open SWE: An open-source asynchronous coding agent   blog.langchain.com/introd... · Posted by u/palashshah
cowpig · 24 days ago
I was excited by the announcement but then

> Runs in an isolated sandbox Every task runs in a secure, isolated Daytona sandbox.

Oh, so fake open source? Daytona is an AGPL-licensed codebase that doesn't actually open-source the control plane, and the first instruction in the README is to sign up for their service.

> From the "open-swe" README:

Open SWE can be used in multiple ways:

* From the UI. You can create, manage and execute Open SWE tasks from the web application. See the 'From the UI' page in the docs for more information.

* From GitHub. You can start Open SWE tasks directly from GitHub issues simply by adding a label open-swe, or open-swe-auto (adding -auto will cause Open SWE to automatically accept the plan, requiring no intervention from you). For enhanced performance on complex tasks, use open-swe-max or open-swe-max-auto labels which utilize Claude Opus 4.1 for both planning and programming. See the 'From GitHub' page in the docs for more information.

* * *

The "from the UI" links to their hosted web interface. If I cannot run it myself it's fake open-source

mitchitized · 24 days ago
Hol up

How can it be AGPL and not provide full source? AGPL is like the most aggressive of the GPL license variants. If they somehow circumvented the intent behind this license that is a problem.

mitchitized commented on My experience with Claude Code after two weeks of adventures   sankalp.bearblog.dev/my-c... · Posted by u/dejavucoder
ianberdin · a month ago
Reading all these glowing reviews of Claude Code, I still get the feeling that either everyone’s been paid off or it’s just the die-hard fans of terminal windows and editors like Emacs and Vim. Using the terminal is right up their alley—it’s in their DNA.

Every time I read comments saying Claude Code is far better than Cursor, I fire it up, pay for a subscription, and run it on a large, complex TypeScript codebase. First, the whole process takes a hell of a lot of time. Second, the learning curve is steep: you have to work through the terminal and type commands.

And the outcome is exactly the same as with the Claude that’s built into Cursor—only slower, less clear, and the generated code is harder to review afterward. I don’t know… At this point my only impression is that all those influencers in the comments are either sponsored, or they’ve already shelled out their $200 and are now defending their choice. Or they simply haven’t used Cursor enough to figure out how to get the most out of it.

I still can’t see any real advantage to Claude Code, other than supposedly higher limits. I don’t get it. I’ve already paid for Claude Code, and I’m also paying for Cursor Pro, which is another $200, but I’m more productive with Cursor so far.

I’ve been programming for 18 years, write a ton of code every single day, and I can say Cursor gives me more. I switch between Gemini 2.5 Pro—when I need to handle tasks with a big, long context—and Claude 4.0 for routine stuff.

So no one has convinced me yet, and I haven’t seen any other benefit. Maybe later… I don’t know.

mitchitized · a month ago
Each use case, which for many is a project-by-project thing, likely determines the right tool for the job.

For new projects, I find Claude Code extremely helpful, as I start out with a business document, a top-level requirements document, and go from there. In the end (and with not a lot of work or time spent) I have a README, implementation plan, high-level architecture, milestones, and oftentimes a swagger spec, pipeline setup and a test harness.

IMHO pointing CC at a folder of a big typescript project is going to waste a ton of compute and tokens, for minimal value. That is not a good use of this tool. I also have a pretty strong opinion that a large, complex typescript codebase is a bad idea for humans too.

Point CC at a python or go repo and it is a whole 'nother experience. Also, starting out is where CC really shines as stated above.

For a big complex typescript repo I would want very specific, targeted help as opposed to agentic big-picture stuff. But that also minimizes the very reason I'd be reaching for help in the first place.

mitchitized commented on Artisanal handcrafted Git repositories   drew.silcock.dev/blog/art... · Posted by u/drewsberry
mitchitized · 2 months ago
I closed the tab as soon as I saw `ignorecase = true`.

Absolutely NOT going there again.

* points at numerous scars and trauma

mitchitized commented on AI is turning Apple into a "loser"   axios.com/2025/07/10/ai-a... · Posted by u/elsewhen
mitchitized · 2 months ago
Definitely not seeing the horrendous collapse of the once mighty Apple.

That said, they have always been behind the curve with AI, and recent product releases/updates have been, uh, suboptimal. Latest Logic Pro is a disaster (e.g. unstable/crashing, removed key shortcuts killing productivity) and don't get me started on the dumbing-down of iOS.

They are for sure headed in the wrong direction, but they are just too big to fall overnight.

mitchitized commented on Bot or human? Creating an invisible Turing test for the internet   research.roundtable.ai/pr... · Posted by u/timshell
ipdashc · 2 months ago
Yeah, I feel like I'm going crazy looking at that first example video. Was Google's CAPTCHA not supposed to analyze exactly that? Yet the mouse is insta-jumping to the input boxes, the input text is being pasted in instantaneously, and somehow it gets past? That seems utterly trivial to detect. Meanwhile us normal users are clicking on pictures of traffic lights all day?
mitchitized · 2 months ago
That is because I do not think Google's aims for captcha are the same as ours.

I can tell you that as soon as you download Chrome and login to any Google account of yours, the captcha tests are suddenly and mysteriously gone.

Use firefox in full-lockdown mode, and you will be clicking fire hydrants and crosswalks for the next several hours.

My crazy conspiracy theory is that Google is just using captcha as an opportunity to force everyone out of privacy mode, further empowering the surveillance capitalism engines. The intent is not to be effective, but inconvenient.

mitchitized commented on Show HN: Memex is a Claude Code alternative built on Rust+Tauri for vibe coding   memex.tech... · Posted by u/davidvgilmore
davidvgilmore · 4 months ago
thanks - yeah, we've heard this feedback loud and clear from the HN community.

We're cooking

mitchitized · 4 months ago
Hey, there's a really cool new tool that you could use to add this feature, I think it was called 'memex' or something like that.

(sorry couldn't resist)

Been playing around with this for a day and found it intuitive and fun to use. A little scary on the "but how much will this cost me if this becomes a frequently-used tool?" question. Can't wait to point this at local models, too!

mitchitized commented on Microsoft subtracts C/C++ extension from VS Code forks   theregister.com/2025/04/2... · Posted by u/Dotnaught
kyrra · 4 months ago
I think your analogies are wrong.

There is a direct cost to Microsoft that these companies are pushing on them. Specifically around bandwidth.

Microsoft does not need to provide access for downloading plugins from their servers to anyone else.

mitchitized · 4 months ago
It is a public website and a public service - it's like saying "hey I got free lemonade here, but you can't have it unless I decide I like you first."

If you're giving something away online for free, then you are giving it away for free. I'll never understand the cognitive dissonance of "conditionally free".

A more important question is where do we draw the line of abuse? If someone links to my website and that's okay with me, but someone else does and I don't like it, do I have the right to conditionally block access to them? And do they have the right to circumvent that to regain access that I freely give to others?

mitchitized commented on Meilisearch – search engine API bringing AI-powered hybrid search   github.com/meilisearch/me... · Posted by u/modinfo
k4rli · 5 months ago
Librechat has it as a dependency. Seems very memory heavy like elasticsearch. 3G+ memory at all times even on a new-ish instance with just one user.
mitchitized · 5 months ago
Fire it up in a docker container and limit the RAM usage that way.

This is a trick I learned years ago with other mmap-based systems.

mitchitized commented on Gumroad’s source is available   github.com/antiwork/gumro... · Posted by u/philipjoubert
mitchitized · 5 months ago
This actually strikes at the heart of the disconnect between open source philosophy and common vernacular.

I've argued for years that "free" does NOT mean "free to use as long as you follow my restrictions". To me the only licenses that meet this criteria are the permissive ones such as MIT, BSD and friends where the only requirement is preservation of the copyright notice. The vast majority have limits of what you can do, or when you have to pay, or some other BS that just complicates everything and IMHO just reeks of "I'm manipulating the FOSS community so I can make a buck" or "I'm pretending to give this software away but actually have a laundry list of rules you have to live by". Basically the opposite of what "free" means!

Similarly, "open source" implies that I can do whatever I want, since it is "open". But most open source licenses - including this one - have restrictions and in many cases pretty strict ones that forbid use for many. This is not open at all.

Either give it away, or lock it up, but PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE stop with the hypocrisy, lying and wordplay so you can make a buck (or satisfy a religious tilt). If you want me to help you with your code then you gotta let me use it how I see fit!

And for the love of all things holy, quit calling restrictive licenses "free". This is a binary state, it is either free or non-free, and "you can only use this if you make less than X" or "only use this with other free software" or "if you make changes you have to share" are NOT FREE.

There. Thanks for reading. Stepping outside to yell at a cloud now. And get off my lawn.

mitchitized commented on Apple shuffles AI executive ranks in bid to turn around Siri   finance.yahoo.com/news/ap... · Posted by u/bbzjk7
mitchitized · 5 months ago
Apple needs to just put Siri down and launch a brand new, ground-up service/feature that completely changes the subject. That is a win for them, and we finally get rid of the most unhelpful "assistant" the world has known since Clippy.

u/mitchitized

KarmaCake day100August 5, 2010View Original