Readit News logoReadit News
mintone commented on Sora 2   openai.com/index/sora-2/... · Posted by u/skilled
echelon · 3 months ago
I'm a software engineer and hobbyist actor/director. My friends are in the film industry and are in IATSE and SAG-AFTRA. I've made photons-on-glass films for decades, and I frequently film stuff with my friends for festivals.

I love this AI video technology.

Here are some of the films my friends and I have been making with AI. These are not "prompted", but instead use a lot of hand animation, rotoscoping, and human voice acting in addition to AI assistance:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H4NFXGMuwpY

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAAiiKteM-U

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7x7IZkHiGD8

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tii9uF0nAx4

Here are films from other industry folks. One of them writes for a TV show you probably watch:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FAQWRBCt_5E

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t_SgA6ymPuc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OCZC6XmEmK0

I see several incredibly good things happening with this tech:

- More people being able to visually articulate themselves, including "lay" people who typically do not use editing software.

- Creative talent at the bottom rungs being able to reach high with their ambition and pitch grand ideas. With enough effort, they don't even need studio capital anymore. (Think about the tens of thousands of students that go to film school that never get to direct their dream film. That was a lot of us!)

- Smaller studios can start to compete with big studios. A ten person studio in France can now make a well-crafted animation that has more heart and soul than recent by-the-formula Pixar films. It's going to start looking like indie games. Silksong and Undertale and Stardew Valley, but for movies, shows, and shorts. Makoto Shinkai did this once by himself with "Voices of a Distant Star", but it hasn't been oft repeated. Now that is becoming possible.

You can't just "prompt" this stuff. It takes work. (Each of the shorts above took days of effort - something you probably wouldn't know unless you're in the trenches trying to use the tech!)

For people that know how to do a little VFX and editing, and that know the basic rules of storytelling, these tools are remarkable assets that compliment an existing skill set. But every shot, every location, every scene is still work. And you have to weave that all into a compelling story with good hooks and visuals. It's multi-layered and complex. Not unlike code.

And another code analogy: think of these models like Claude Code for the creative. An exoskeleton, but not the core driving engineer or vision that draws it all together. You can't prompt a code base, and similarly, you can't prompt a movie. At least not anytime soon.

mintone · 3 months ago
I wrote this a year or so ago: https://www.technicalchops.com/articles/ai-goes-to-hollywood...

"The studios and creators who thrive in this new landscape will be those who can effectively harness AI’s capabilities while maintaining the human creativity and vision that ultimately drives the art of cinema."

It is in many ways thrilling to see this come to life, and I couldn't agree with you more.

mintone commented on Apple's Liquid Glass: When Aesthetics Beat Function   maxvanijsselmuiden.nl/liq... · Posted by u/maxvij
mintone · 5 months ago
The lede is buried at the end of this article.

> Later iOS 26 beta releases show Apple reducing transparency and adding blur effects for better readability.

This is a beta release. It is a work in progress. When iOS 7’s betas came out the reaction was similarly negative. I would suggest we wait and see what the system evolves into; by the time we get to iOS 27 I am quite sure that Apple will have found the right balance.

mintone commented on     · Posted by u/mintone
mintone · 6 months ago
A fascinating situation is facing polymarket - Zelenskyy was pictured wearing a suit (as described by the media) at the NATO summit on June 25th but this market is still unresolved. It appears there’s lots of argument here and that this market is set to be test of the platform.
mintone commented on Tell HN: iPhone mirroring on iOS/macOS breaks screenshot protection on all apps    · Posted by u/mintone
joshstrange · a year ago
This is always a very interesting topic for me. On one hand, I would like apps to be able to enforce rules like “no screenshots” or at a minimum “screenshot detection”. On the other hand, I want my phone to do what I ask you to do and not be forced to follow arbitrary rules.

Example: I don’t want someone to screenshot my Snapchat message but I don’t want my bank to prevent me from screenshotting the app because of “security” (aka security theater).

I don’t know how you make those two concepts work together.

One random thought that I just had is that when an app uses DRM it just show a black screen when you screenshot. I wonder if could implement that for things like Snapchat to get the same protections.

mintone · a year ago
When I tested, you can also screenshot disney+, netflix etc. so DRM is also broken by it!
mintone commented on Tell HN: iPhone mirroring on iOS/macOS breaks screenshot protection on all apps    · Posted by u/mintone
impish9208 · a year ago
Hi, which app did you see this on? WhatsApp is a big one that comes to mind.
mintone · a year ago
WhatsApp was the one I tested it on

u/mintone

KarmaCake day395March 10, 2014
About
Writes occasionally at technicalchops.com
View Original