Readit News logoReadit News

Dead Comment

Dead Comment

Dead Comment

Dead Comment

Dead Comment

mcpackieh commented on I Vote on Plagiarism Cases at Harvard College. Gay's Getting Off Easy   thecrimson.com/article/20... · Posted by u/mcenedella
mcpackieh · 2 years ago
> What is striking about the allegations of plagiarism against President Gay is that the improprieties are routine and pervasive.

> She is accused of plagiarism in her dissertation and at least two of her 11 journal articles. Two sentences from the acknowledgement section of her dissertation even seem to have been copied from another work.

Presuming the allegations are true, I find it interesting that it went unaddressed for so long. The matter was seemingly systematically ignored for almost 30 years until she pissed off the wrong people by allowing students to protest against Israel. Then people went digging for something to use against her and found this plagarism. From the NYTimes:

> After weeks of tumult at Harvard over the university’s response to the Israel-Hamas war and the leadership of its president, Claudine Gay, there was no shortage of interest in a faculty forum with Dr. Gay this week.

> In a town hall held over Zoom on Tuesday with several hundred members of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Dr. Gay focused on how to bridge the deep divides that had emerged on campus as a result of the war, according to two people who attended and asked for confidentiality because of the sensitivity of the situation.

> Faculty members who spoke up in the meeting were largely positive, and there were no questions about Dr. Gay’s academic record after public allegations of plagiarism. The matter wasn’t even raised, one professor said.

> But by Thursday, new questions surrounding Dr. Gay’s scholarship had shifted to the forefront, after the university said late Wednesday that it had identified two more instances of what it called “duplicative language without appropriate attribution,” from her 1997 doctoral dissertation.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/21/us/harvard-claudine-gay-p...

mcpackieh commented on FUSE-T is a kext-less implementation of FUSE for macOS that uses NFSv4   github.com/macos-fuse-t/f... · Posted by u/nimish
inkyoto · 2 years ago
> […] Apple’s war on kexts

Hardly a war, a rather rational decision it is – they are progressively moving kernel modules, drivers, file systems and network components into the user space.

It is a foundational design principle of GNU Hurd where everything, apart from the microkernel server, runs in the user space. Minix 3 followed the same principle, and many other microkernel designs as well.

It makes sense from the resilience point of view where a defective kernel module / driver can no longer crash the entire system.

It also makes sense from the security perspective on – the kernel itself is cryptographically sealed off and can't be tampered with.

Previously, the overhead of extra context switches was too high on the old CPU's and hardware, but today's computing devices are fast and the hardware is more optimised, so moving stuff into the user space is viable and incurs a much smaller performance penalty.

mcpackieh · 2 years ago
"War on __" doesn't imply an irrational war on __
mcpackieh commented on Women from privileged backgrounds pursue prestigious professions over lucrative   phys.org/news/2023-12-wom... · Posted by u/PaulHoule
_3u10 · 2 years ago
The best example is soldiers vs. mercenaries. Soldiers are highly regarded by society because society tells them they did an honorable thing because society didn't have to compensate them very well, and especially didn't have to compensate them enough to not go fight for some other society that treats them better.

Mercenaries on the other hand are not highly regarded because they are well compensated, and don't really care about the honor of fighting for some society that wants to pay them dirt.

Status is far cheaper to confer than money, so we make sure those willing to work for status are well compensated.

It is not titles that honor men, but men that honor titles.

mcpackieh · 2 years ago
I'm not sure I buy that. I think the reputation of soldiers varies greatly with the public perception of the wars they fought. Soldiers are highly regarded when they're seen to be fighting some great evil, but at other times soldiers are considered to be fools or even among the lowest strata of society (particularly before the modern era.)

WW2 veterans receive near universal praise, but in the Vietnam era there were widespread (probably heavily exaggerated if not fabricated) reports of soldiers being spat on because a whole lot of people didn't think America's military adventurism was really in defense of America. Of course those who felt that the war was necessary in the fight against communism to defend the American way of life had a more positive view of the same soldiers. In more recent wars with all volunteer soldiers I think the reputation of soldiers is just as polarized although usually the negative side doesn't go further than cool sniffs and sneers; the spitting was probably all apocryphal in the first place. Certainly you won't see me going around thanking Iraq vets for their service; they signed up for a stupid war and I'm not going to thank them for making that mistake. I won't look down on a soldier who got drafted, but those soldiers who signed up for the travel, job experience, college education, etc are essentially mercenaries anyway.

mcpackieh commented on Reckless DMCA Deindexing Pushes NASA's Artemis Towards Black Hole   torrentfreak.com/reckless... · Posted by u/CoBE10
Buttons840 · 2 years ago
> DMCA takedown notices sent by a company calling itself DMCA Piracy Prevention Inc. claim to protect the rights of an OnlyFans/Instagram model working under the name ‘Artemis’.
mcpackieh · 2 years ago
We need to have severe penalties for negligent DMCA takedowns, not just willfully malicious ones. Including disbarment and possibly imprisonment for any lawyers involved. Taking down pages about NASA rocketry because they shared a name with a social media model was probably an accident, but it's an inexcusable accident that never should have happened. These kind of accidents wouldn't happen so often if the people issuing takedowns were forced to have skin in the game.
mcpackieh commented on Women from privileged backgrounds pursue prestigious professions over lucrative   phys.org/news/2023-12-wom... · Posted by u/PaulHoule
SamoyedFurFluff · 2 years ago
> In comparison, women from these backgrounds were much more likely to go into teaching, or a creative profession—jobs which are well respected but substantially less financially rewarding.

…who respects teachers or creative profession careers? Genuinely asking. Teachers are ragged on all the time (“those who can’t do, teach”) and creative professions are often mocked as well in my high paying circles.

mcpackieh · 2 years ago
It's well respected in the sense that when you're at a dinner party and tell people that you're a school teacher everybody says "Oh how nice! that's such an important job. You must love working with the kids, right? So rewarding to be able to make a difference"

Contrast when you tell somebody you're a lawyer or lobbyist, some people will be impressed but other people will get a bit uncomfortable and try to change the subject or start telling "lawyer jokes".

What did the lawyer name his daughter? Sue!

u/mcpackieh

KarmaCake day4231June 18, 2023View Original