Readit NewsAs a kid I read some Asimov books where he laid out the "3 laws of robotics", first law being a robot must not harm a human. And in the same story a character gave the example of a malicious human instructing Robot A prepare a toxic solution "for science", dismissing Robot A, then having Eobot B unsuspectingly serve the "drink" to a victim. Presto, a robot killing a human. The parallel to malicious use of LLMs has been haunting me for ages.
But here's the kicker, Iirc, Asimov wasn't even really talking about robots. His point was how hard it is to align humans, for even perfectly morally upright humans to avoid being used to harm others.
Edit: let me clarify: there is a camera on every intersection which automatically gives a ticket to everyone who blocks for >5sec. That works.
That is an unreasonable assumption. In case of LLMs it seems wasteful to transform a point from latent space into a random token and lose information. In fact, I think in near future it will be the norm for MLLMs to "think" and "reason" without outputting a single "word".
> Whether AI reasoning is “real” reasoning or just a mirage can be an interesting question, but it is primarily a philosophical question. It depends on having a clear definition of what “real” reasoning is, exactly.
It is not a "philosophical" (by which the author probably meant "practically inconsequential") question. If the whole reasoning business is just rationalization of pre-computed answers or simply a means to do some computations because every token provides only a fixed amount of computation to update the model's state, then it doesn't make much sense to focus on improving the quality of chain-of-thought output from human POV.
It will be outputting something, as this is the only way it can get more compute - output a token, then all context + the next token is fed through the LLM again. It might not be presented to the user, but that's a different story.
Deleted Comment
All in all, nothing to worry about, just do it.
This is still great but not a 100% solution.