Readit News logoReadit News
librasteve commented on Sprinkling self-doubt on ChatGPT   justin.searls.co/posts/sp... · Posted by u/ingve
natrius · 5 days ago
You know, it doesn't really seem like a mistake for people to anthropomorphize the thinking machines.
librasteve · 5 days ago
i think that we need to subset our definition of “thinking” on lines like

  - contextualising 
  - packaging / assembling
  - parsing
  - recognizing / labeling
  - comparing / contrasting 
  - analyzing / subsetting
  - checking
  - reasoning 
  - introspecting
in my view both human and LLMs perform most of these aspects of thinking in a similar way … I suspect that a large fraction of the human brain performs LLM like language manipulation

for sure, today’s LLMs lack the last two on the list, and there is probably a rational debate to be had whether these can just emerge in the substrate provided by the LLM-like setting or whether the brain provides some hardwired additions to loop around focus selection and perceive-model-decide-act that will need to be grafted on to LLMs to achieve AGI

librasteve commented on Our Response to Mississippi's Age Assurance Law   bsky.social/about/blog/08... · Posted by u/Kye
some_furry · 5 days ago
Hierarchies are in and of themselves stupid.

If you think they exist naturally, you're only looking at one of thousands of independent variables. If you average them out, we all tend towards mediocrity.

When someone appeals to hierarchies (e.g., "there's always a bigger fish"), they're just admitting to using a painfully one-dimensional worldview.

librasteve · 5 days ago
strictly speaking a tree requires at least two dimensions
librasteve commented on Mark Zuckerberg freezes AI hiring amid bubble fears   telegraph.co.uk/business/... · Posted by u/pera
UncleMeat · 7 days ago
I think that meta is bad for the world and that zuck has made a lot of huge mistakes but calling him a one hit wonder doesn't sit right with me.

Facebook made the transition to mobile faster than other competitors and successfully kept G+ from becoming competition.

The instagram purchase felt insane at the time ($1b to share photos) but facebook was able to convert it into a moneymaking juggernaut in time for the flattened growth of their flagship application.

Zuck hired Sheryl Sandburg and successfully turned a website with a ton of users into an ad-revenue machine. Plenty of other companies struggled to convert large user bases into dollars.

This obviously wasn't all based on him. He had other people around him working on this stuff and it isn't right to attribute all company success to the CEO. The metaverse play was obviously a legendary bust. But "he just got lucky" feels more like Myspace Tom than Zuckerberg in my mind.

librasteve · 7 days ago
Whatsapp was also an inspired move
librasteve commented on An Update on Pytype   github.com/google/pytype... · Posted by u/mxmlnkn
zem · 7 days ago
because there is a ton of existing python code that people find a lot of value in, and that no one wants to abandon. the return on investment for making python better is insanely higher than that on porting hundreds of millions of lines of code to another language.
librasteve · 7 days ago
that’s why raku has modules like

  Inline::Python 
  Inline::Perl5
and strong FFI (Foreign Function Interface) chops

certainly I see the economic sense in continuing with Python, but for some folks there’s a limit to how much lipstick you want on your pig

librasteve commented on Why we still build with Ruby   getlago.com/blog/why-we-s... · Posted by u/FinnLobsien
myaccountonhn · 8 days ago
I've been toying with Perl+CGI-scripts lately and find its super productive with the benefit that I can do serverless without the lock-in.

I don't think the software engineering field is particularly rational and mostly follows trends or what looks good or familiar. We have a proclivity to assume that anything old is legacy. Most developer have never studied any CS history and are quite young, so they're bound to reinvent the wheel as well.

I think its fine to use older technology if its the right fit for the problem, and since the tech is battle-tested, you can read up as to why it went out-of-fashion, and as a result can minimize the risks with using it. It's "predictably disappointing".

librasteve · 7 days ago
if you like perl+CGI, then i suggest you take a look at https://harcstack.org
librasteve commented on An Update on Pytype   github.com/google/pytype... · Posted by u/mxmlnkn
zem · 8 days ago
ex-pytype dev here - we knew this was coming and it's definitely the right thing to do, but it's still a little sad to see the end of an era. in particular, pytype's ability to do flow-based analysis across function boundaries (type checking calls to unannotated functions by symbolically executing the function body with the types of the call arguments) has not been implemented by any of the other checkers (again for good reasons; it's a performance hit and the world is moving towards annotations over pure inference anyway, but I still think it's a nice feature to have and makes for more powerful checking).

as an aside, while I agree that bytecode-based analysis has its drawbacks, I think it's a tool worth having in the overall python toolbox. I spun off pycnite from pytype in the hope that anyone else who wanted to experiment with it would have an easier time getting started - https://github.com/google/pycnite

I have recently jumped onto the "write python tooling in rust" bandwagon and might look into a rust reimplementation of pycnite at some point, because I still feel that bytecode analysis lets you reuse a lot of work the compiler has already done for you.

librasteve · 7 days ago
why not just go with a language that has gradual typing built in - eg raku
librasteve commented on Show HN: Edka – Kubernetes clusters on your own Hetzner account   edka.io... · Posted by u/camil
librasteve · 12 days ago
It’s a little off topic, but to mention Raku now has support for the Hetzner API https://raku.land/zef:wayland/WWW::CloudHosting::Hetzner

That way we can use Raku as a scripting language for deployment.

librasteve commented on Facial recognition vans to be rolled out across police forces in England   news.sky.com/story/facial... · Posted by u/amarcheschi
pixelpoet · 14 days ago
IMO it shouldn't even get that far, to questions of how much we should be allowed to ask of others in the name of basic decency; there's been a massive shift from people being self-regulating and trying to be considerate to others, to the conversation changing to something like, "how dare you even speak to me while I'm blasting tiktok loudly, I'm going to look up the letter of the law and see what the maximum disruption I can legally get away with is, fuck you!"

Basically sometime around the 00s-10s, seemingly everyone decided to become a massive dickface with zero concept of social cohesion, and it's just me me me me me me, and fuck everyone else.

Society needs a reset, pretty much everyone has just become vile, angry and inconsiderate / extreme main-character syndrome.

librasteve · 13 days ago
this
librasteve commented on The "high-level CPU" challenge (2008)   yosefk.com/blog/the-high-... · Posted by u/signa11
IainIreland · 16 days ago
This isn't about languages; it's about hardware. Should hardware be "higher-level" to support higher level languages? The author says no (and I am inclined to agree with him).
librasteve · 16 days ago
this

u/librasteve

KarmaCake day383July 15, 2023View Original