Readit News logoReadit News
kmacdough commented on DeepSeek-v3.2: Pushing the frontier of open large language models [pdf]   huggingface.co/deepseek-a... · Posted by u/pretext
tedivm · 20 days ago
If you're trying to build AI based applications you can and should compare the costs between vendor based solutions and hosting open models with your own hardware.

On the hardware side you can run some benchmarks on the hardware (or use other people's benchmarks) and get an idea of the tokens/second you can get from the machine. Normalize this for your usage pattern (and do your best to implement batch processing where you are able to, which will save you money on both methods) and you have a basic idea of how much it would cost per token.

Then you compare that to the cost of something like GPT5, which is a bit simpler because the cost per (million) token is something you can grab off of a website.

You'd be surprised how much money running something like DeepSeek (or if you prefer a more established company, Qwen3) will save you over the cloud systems.

That's just one factor though. Another is what hardware you can actually run things on. DeepSeek and Qwen will function on cheap GPUs that other models will simply choke on.

kmacdough · 19 days ago
Furthermore, paid models are heavily subsidized by bullish investors playing for monopoly. So that tips the scales further towards Deepseek.
kmacdough commented on 250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland   energy-storage.news/250mw... · Posted by u/doener
bryanlarsen · 24 days ago
> Where are you planning on getting the elevation delta from?

Elevation delta is not hard to find in Norway! A typical pumped storage facility uses 100m of delta; I imagine Norwegian ones would use more.

> but this is a field where capex + opex/KWH is everything.

And pumped storage is significantly cheaper for seasonal storage than any proposed alternatives.

The original post is efficient for heat storage, but converting low grade heat to electricity is not efficient.

kmacdough · 24 days ago
> A typical pumped storage facility uses 100m of delta

Most projects seek 200-600m. This map doesn't even consider pumped hydro <200m: https://maps.nrel.gov/psh

> And pumped storage is significantly cheaper for seasonal storage than any proposed alternatives.

Based on what? Cost is particularly variable for pumped hydro. It can be one of the cheaper options when stars align. But you need 1) a suitable geography that minimizes the cost of damming or digging a resivoir with sufficient head 2) available for development without too much backlash 3) Near enough grid resources to minimize infrastructure and line losses. I'm surely leaving pieces out.

It can be cheap, but it has far more hoops to jump than alternatives like batteries, hot sand and other "storage-in-a-building" designs which can be built where needed and using fairly standard industrial construction.

kmacdough commented on Keep Android Open   keepandroidopen.org/... · Posted by u/LorenDB
state_less · 2 months ago
Back in '99 Linux didn't run Excel/Word/Powerpoint or most games, but I ran it anyway. What others call showstoppers are for me inconveniences.

I have a motorolla edge 2024 that I'll load whatever open source phone OS will work well enough to place calls and browse the web. I'll keep another phone for the rare times some corporate/government overlord requires it. Many folks who refuse to use smartphones, similarly own a smartphone they rarely use for systems that require them.

My recommendation is to put as little time and energy into closed, locked down platforms as you can. Feel free to complain, but don't forget you can make choices.

kmacdough · 2 months ago
The problem is as aforementioned players pressure users and government, they can make certain aspects of the economy entirely inaccessible to unapproved platforms. Netflix and co can simply refuse to support streaming on devices which aren't hardware locked. Banks can refuse to do business. Sure banks have in person locations, but they've become fewer and more backed up.

One certain thresholds are reached, little can be done even for the committed outcast.

kmacdough commented on A worker fell into a nuclear reactor pool   nrc.gov/reading-rm/doc-co... · Posted by u/nvahalik
hshdhdhehd · 2 months ago
> Non Emergency

I guess in a nuclear reactor there is a lingual shift and the word emergency cant be used for just any old 911 call.

Like how Australians apparently call a jellyfish bite "uncomfortable"

kmacdough · 2 months ago
There's no significant immediate threat to life or well-being. It's simply not an emergency. We're all constantly exposed to some ionizing radiation. It's a question of how much.

In this case, not much. It's still an exposure event and absolutely worth giving medical attention to assess continued exposure levels from ingested contamination and generally be overly cautious. But that doesn't mean it's ultimately going to be a significant factor in this workers risk for radiation induced disease. It's certainly better than living in the vicinity of coal mining and processing plants.

kmacdough commented on Twake Drive – An open-source alternative to Google Drive   github.com/linagora/twake... · Posted by u/javatuts
safety1st · 2 months ago
Is that a weakness of the tool's organizational model?

I don't want to be part of a community around my cloud storage. I want it to work and I want to think about it as little as possible.

I use Syncthing and it does a pretty great job at this, no one ever insisted I need to join a Syncthing community, yet it keeps on working.

I don't pay a dime for Syncthing but I'm vaguely aware that they're linked to a company called Kastelo which provides enterprise support for Syncthing deployments. Probably a lot of Syncthing development is paid for that way.

Incidentally I founded an open source consulting company that's totally unrelated to cloud storage. We have enterprise as well as smaller contracts. We develop some addons in-house and the bigger enterprise contracts tend to subsidize most of the work that goes into them. We haven't asked anyone to be part of a community and I don't think we need to.

Communities are nice, but if you want your software to last I think a good business model and a good marketing strategy are a better bet. Bonus, you can quit your day job.

kmacdough · 2 months ago
For a business headed open source project, it's still about the community. In this case, the business tends to take a defining and often controlling role in the community. This has plusses and minuses. On the plus side, if a business has a vested financial interest in the project, there is financial incentive for continuity. On the minus, when the company's financial interest no longer aligns with the community, many of us retain scars from rug pulling and switcheroos.

So understanding the long term stability of a community is more than just checking whether there is a company backing the project. It is important to analyze the nature and diversity of interest. I think it's just as important that there exists a larger community that the business depends on for extra feature + bugfixing work which is capable of forking. When this is possible, it is much less likely to be necessary.

kmacdough commented on Space Elevator   neal.fun/space-elevator/... · Posted by u/kaonwarb
bentt · 2 months ago
Seems like even before we do an elevator, we should get _something_ tethered to the ground to be in space. Like... anything! That'd be a huge accomplishment.
kmacdough · 2 months ago
No engineer actually thinks a space elevator is possible. It would be a silly waste of resources.
kmacdough commented on Space Elevator   neal.fun/space-elevator/... · Posted by u/kaonwarb
lolive · 2 months ago
Why not scroll up to 36000 kms, so we can reach the end of the cable? #iFeelCheated !
kmacdough · 2 months ago
Because space elevators aren't actually possible so it doesn't really matter.
kmacdough commented on Space Elevator   neal.fun/space-elevator/... · Posted by u/kaonwarb
retube · 2 months ago
Was hoping would go to geostationary orbit as an actual space elevator would :)
kmacdough · 2 months ago
Would be boring and space elevators are just for fun. They aren't a real idea.
kmacdough commented on Space Elevator   neal.fun/space-elevator/... · Posted by u/kaonwarb
GMoromisato · 2 months ago
I love this page and I donated, but I was (naively) expecting it to get to geosynchronous altitude, which is the actual top of a space elevator.

Of course, that would require a page 420 times longer, and I don't know if a browser would even support it.

kmacdough · 2 months ago
I mean the idea isn't actually real or practical. It's a thought experiment that makes for some fun calculus. No one's actually going to try and build one.
kmacdough commented on Space Elevator   neal.fun/space-elevator/... · Posted by u/kaonwarb
kmacdough · 2 months ago
Super fun!

I do always have to object to comments like "space elevators are possible," "scientists have studied" and "would save money".

It's a fun thought experiment, nothing more (for now). You can do some calculus to estimate the necessary strength-to-weight ratio based on centripetal and gravitational forces. Single carbon fibers seem to meet this optimistic criteria.

But there are many forces left out. Many practicalitites left unconsidered. Why? Because there is no scientific community that believes it's vaguely achievable with near-future technology. It's simply not worth investing the outrageous resources required to do a vaguely useful viability analysis.

u/kmacdough

KarmaCake day409October 15, 2018View Original