Readit News logoReadit News
klunger commented on CO2 Battery   energydome.com/co2-batter... · Posted by u/xnx
pragma_x · a month ago
My hunch is that they're doing this for three reasons.

1. Decompressing the gas can be used to do work, like turning a turbine or something. It's not particularly efficient, as you mention, but it can store some energy for a while. Also the tech to do this is practically off-the-shelf right now, and doesn't rely on a ton of R&D to ramp up. Well, maybe the large storage tanks do, but that should be all. So it _does_ function and nobody else is doing it this way so perhaps all that's seen as a competitive edge of sorts.

2. The storage tech has viable side-products, so the bottom-line could be diversified as to not be completely reliant on electricity generation. The compressed gas itself can be sold. Processed a little further, it can be sold as dry ice. Or maybe the facility can be dual-purposed for refrigeration of goods.

3. IMO, they're using CO2 as a working fluid is an attempt to sound carbon-sequestration-adjacent. Basically, doubling-down on environmentally-sound keywords to attract investment. Yes, I'm saying they're greenwashing what should otherwise be a sand battery or something else that moves _heat_ around more efficiently.

klunger · a month ago
Yes, it is not clear why they have chosen CO2 beyond PR. There are other gas mixtures that would likely have better yields.
klunger commented on CO2 Battery   energydome.com/co2-batter... · Posted by u/xnx
klunger · a month ago
At first, I thought this was an elaborate joke because fossil fuels are effectively "CO2 batteries."

Instead, it's compressed gas. Which is fine and possibly the best solution in certain contexts. But, it isn't exactly revolutionary or necessarily preferable to Li-ion most of the time.

klunger commented on Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US   es.wired.com/articulos/eu... · Posted by u/mpweiher
kgdiem · 4 months ago
How do you think that Norway’s wealth tax could impact its ability to draw talent from any other country? Knowing that, should you develop anything (drug, material, etc) and want to spin it out to a startup, you will be taxed on the unrealized valuation would weigh very heavily on me were I a researcher.

Full disclosure, I know that this isn’t everyone’s goal, but this is HN after all!

klunger · 3 months ago
Well, with this ERC fund, we are trying to attract high quality research scientists. While there are many of these who also have entrepreneurial ambitions, it is a venn diagram, not a circle.

However, your critique of the wealth tax on unrealized gains is a big problem more generally. I have some interaction with the startup ecosystem these days here. Anecdotally, I have seen several founders choose to incorporate elsewhere in Europe or the US because of it. Unfortunately, it's incredibly hard to quantify how many do not stay here because of it.

This aspect of the tax has had significant opposition for years, but nothing ever seems to come from it.

Opposition to tax on realized gains/assets is less vocal. Someone else here characterized that part as similar to property taxes in the US and I think that is fairly accurate.

Details on what is taxed how much, if you are interesed: https://www.skatteetaten.no/en/person/taxes/get-the-taxes-ri...

ETA: we are looking for evolutionary biologists. Not many entrepreneurial personalities here, more like a lot of bird watchers (I say this lovingly). Over in the groups with translation potential is a different story of course.

klunger commented on Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US   es.wired.com/articulos/eu... · Posted by u/mpweiher
alternatex · 4 months ago
Is it 500 million for research or 500 million for luring US researchers to Europe? They are vastly different things so we need to be on the same page for this to be a productive discussion.
klunger · 4 months ago
It 500 mil to lure US researchers. They say "from every country" because they have to, but we know why it was made and who will get most of it.
klunger commented on Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US   es.wired.com/articulos/eu... · Posted by u/mpweiher
geremiiah · 4 months ago
EU is offering what was on the table anyway. EU academia was always more accessible and less competitive than US academia, for obvious reasons. Downside of that is you get to work in environments with a sparser density of talent and accomplishments.
klunger · 4 months ago
No, it is a new fund that is only for scientists coming from outside Europe. https://erc.europa.eu/news-events/news/choose-europe-science...
klunger commented on Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US   es.wired.com/articulos/eu... · Posted by u/mpweiher
rednafi · 4 months ago
Europe really needs to fix the funding issue and language fragmentation. Otherwise there's no "luring people in." Every time someone brings this up, a bunch of people are like, "Have you ever worked in the EU? They all speak English at work." Yes, I have, and also on three other continents. Europe hasn’t adopted English at work that much, and no one I know is excited about dealing with racism, picking up the local language while doing high-octane white-collar jobs or research.

Europe keeps a ton of jobs gated behind language requirements. Sure, you'll get the most desperate people who need a visa this way, but Europe isn’t attracting top of the crop like the US this way.

Also, the red tape is brutal and everything requires six layers of bureaucracy. Even Amazon orders and customer service suck, but that's beside the point. It's way easier to get into a great US university and get funding for research. It's also easier to get a job afterward. The sheer number of opportunities, combined with the lack of a language barrier and less bureaucracy, makes the US better than all the other alternatives despite the poor transportation, weak social safety net, and terrible healthcare.

klunger · 4 months ago
This reads like a bitter ex-employee. I guess you were in Germany?

There are plenty of European countries that do use English as the working language for technical fields, if there is not enough domestic talent.

What you say about the US research ecosystem may have been true until January 2025 but it is unfortuantely no longer the case. At the same time, the EU is finally getting its act together in both defense AND research funding. So I would forecast a sunnier future in Europe for scientists than the the US, at least for the next generation.

klunger commented on Europe launches program to lure scientists away from the US   es.wired.com/articulos/eu... · Posted by u/mpweiher
klunger · 4 months ago
My department (at a Norwegian university) is working on a headhunting plan. The way the ERC grants are structured, the applicant needs a sponsoring institute. So, we are identifying researchers who are working on relevant topics, if we think it will be a good fit (and/or if we have successfully collaborated with them in the past).

Some of the details are still being ironed out. The beauracracy is real! Even so, I guess the first emails will go out late next week.

klunger commented on Teen on Musk's DOGE Team Graduated from 'The Com'   krebsonsecurity.com/2025/... · Posted by u/klunger
dang · 7 months ago
It was posted 38 hours ago (about 12 hours before yours). (you can tell the order by comparing the item IDs btw)

The timestamps get relativized by HN's re-upping system, described at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26998308 and links back from there. About the timestamps, there are past explanations here: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que.... Sorry for the confusion—I know it's weird but the alternative turns out to be even more confusing and we've never figured out how to square that circle.

You can always see the original timestamps by looking at any page other than /news or /item. For example, here: https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=krebsonsecurity.com.

Not finding the post on search is a separate issue - that's because the threads had been flagkilled, and killed posts (anything marked [dead]) doesn't show up on HN Search.

klunger · 7 months ago
Ok. Thank you for the explanation :)

I assume the other one made it through the organized flagging campaign because you intervened. So, thanks for that too.

klunger commented on Teen on Musk's DOGE Team Graduated from 'The Com'   krebsonsecurity.com/2025/... · Posted by u/klunger
dang · 7 months ago
Related ongoing thread:

Teen on Musk's DOGE team graduated from 'The Com' - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42981756

klunger · 7 months ago
I am glad the article finally made it through who/whatever is trying to keep it down.

But, c'mon Dan. I posted this 23 hours ago. That post is 2 hours old. How did it get flagged as a dupe? I searched before posting and could not find it anywhere.

Relatedly: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42990030

u/klunger

KarmaCake day2017April 20, 2014
About
American emigrant living in Norway

Parent, engineer

Current thing: Bioinformatics

View Original