Readit News logoReadit News
joshefin commented on How to Measure CO2 with a Low-Cost Sensor and a Raspberry Pi   joshefin.xyz/measure-co2-... · Posted by u/joshefin
693471 · 6 years ago
You are not going to get an accurate CO2 sensor for $27. You're being misled into buying cheap Chinese crap.

An accurate CO2 sensor is much more expensive. I would not trust the readings of the sensor in this blog. It's going to be off by over 100ppm, especially if there's a lack of good airflow.

https://www.atlas-scientific.com/product_pages/probes/ezo-co...

joshefin · 6 years ago
Senseair is a Swedish company and definitely not "cheap Chinese crap". Do you know about any research that confirms your statements about the accuracy?

I believe that some of the more expensive sensors are more accurate, but this cheap one may be a good enough solution in some cases (e.g. indoor air monitoring for DIY projects).

joshefin commented on How to Measure Indoor Air Quality with a Raspberry Pi, RuuviTags and PMS7003   joshefin.xyz/air-quality-... · Posted by u/joshefin
throwaway9d0291 · 6 years ago
For CO2, which I've researched the most out of the various things that interest me, I'd want a Senseair K30 or S8 Commercial, an Amphenol Telaire T6613 or T6713, or a CozIR-A or CozIR-LP sensor.

For low cost, I'd go with the Senseair S8 Residential. It's not fantastically accurate but it's still a "real" sensor and you can get it for $20 from China.

For other aspects of air quality, I haven't finished researching the options yet.

joshefin · 6 years ago
Thanks for sharing. I wanted to get Winsen MH-Z19B, but Senseair S8 (residential) looks like a better, more reliable option, for a DIY project. One comparison: https://www.letscontrolit.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=3736&sta...
joshefin commented on How to Measure Indoor Air Quality with a Raspberry Pi, RuuviTags and PMS7003   joshefin.xyz/air-quality-... · Posted by u/joshefin
jbeales · 6 years ago
Looks like it's using Prism.js: https://prismjs.com
joshefin · 6 years ago
Yes, Prism is great. Most of the blogs cramp the code in width, I let it spread it's wings full width.
joshefin commented on How to Measure Indoor Air Quality with a Raspberry Pi, RuuviTags and PMS7003   joshefin.xyz/air-quality-... · Posted by u/joshefin
Havoc · 6 years ago
I've got a rasp + air sensor.

Quickly turned it off. It has a tiny fan that goes bzzzz. No thanks - my peace & quiet trumps my need to know air particle count

joshefin · 6 years ago
The fan inside the PMS7003 sensor is very quiet.
joshefin commented on How to Measure Indoor Air Quality with a Raspberry Pi, RuuviTags and PMS7003   joshefin.xyz/air-quality-... · Posted by u/joshefin
tareqak · 6 years ago
Does anyone know how accurate this set up would be be in comparison with the NetAtmo Indoor Air Quality monitor [0]?

[0] https://www.netatmo.com/en-us/aircare/homecoach

joshefin · 6 years ago
Netatmo only measures CO2 and depending on your location it would be more useful to know about particulate matter in the air.
joshefin commented on How to Measure Indoor Air Quality with a Raspberry Pi, RuuviTags and PMS7003   joshefin.xyz/air-quality-... · Posted by u/joshefin
r3bl · 6 years ago
I have never touched their air purifier, but I did three other gadgets (TV box, some indoor camera, some light bulbs).

If privacy is your concern, I wouldn't recommend them. If stability is your concern, I wouldn't recommend them.

The light bulb works with an app only (probably to remove the need for a separate hub), the camera could be rooted to work offline-only (which is why I bought it, but I gave up after a couple of shots and it's currently sitting in my drawer), and the TV box is by far the noisiest device in my local network. It's like 60% of all DNS requests blocked by my Pi-hole.

Their devices are also the most unstable devices I own, to the point where I'm considering just throwing them in the trash and re-investing in another camera and a TV box. I've already replaced the bulb I've purchased with a Philips Hue system. Quite more expensive, but truly works locally.

joshefin · 6 years ago
I have the same experience - Xiaomi makes good and cheap hardware, but the software and reliability are bad. And if you want to keep your data private, skip them.
joshefin commented on How to Measure Indoor Air Quality with a Raspberry Pi, RuuviTags and PMS7003   joshefin.xyz/air-quality-... · Posted by u/joshefin
ShakataGaNai · 6 years ago
I love the idea, but why in the name of the Flying Spaghetti Monster, would you use Java on an RPi? There are at least half a dozen python libs for the PMS7003.
joshefin · 6 years ago
I can just confirm what others are saying here - Java is great for the development of robust and reliable software. If you need even lower memory usage, you can compile the Java app with a GraalVM to a native image.
joshefin commented on How to Measure Indoor Air Quality with a Raspberry Pi, RuuviTags and PMS7003   joshefin.xyz/air-quality-... · Posted by u/joshefin
sippeangelo · 6 years ago
What's the RuuviTag for? I can't see it mentioned in the article.
joshefin · 6 years ago
RuuviTag is a sensor capable of measuring the temperature, relative air humidity, and atmospheric pressure and sending the data over Bluetooth. I wrote about it in a linked article - https://joshefin.xyz/temperature-humidity-pressure-with-ruuv...
joshefin commented on How to Measure Indoor Air Quality with a Raspberry Pi, RuuviTags and PMS7003   joshefin.xyz/air-quality-... · Posted by u/joshefin
cagenut · 6 years ago
whats the next step up then? the unit you'd buy for an outdoor sensor.
joshefin · 6 years ago
Sorry, I can't recommend any. If you just want to know if the air is polluted or not, and humidity does not go over 70%, any low-cost sensor would be good.

u/joshefin

KarmaCake day151August 7, 2019
About
I tell computers what to do. joshefin.xyz
View Original