Readit News logoReadit News
immad commented on Why am I no longer qualified to be a Brex customer?   brex.com/support/why-am-i... · Posted by u/tvjames
eins1234 · 3 years ago
That's totally understandable, for the small business segment.

I was just saying that for a VC-backed tech startup, the lack of rewards is a huge turn-off, compared to some of the other options for spending available to us.

immad · 3 years ago
Agreed. We would need a credit card to target that spend.

Appreciate the feedback.

immad commented on Why am I no longer qualified to be a Brex customer?   brex.com/support/why-am-i... · Posted by u/tvjames
eins1234 · 3 years ago
Nice to see you taking feedback seriously.
immad · 3 years ago
Okay. We don’t have a credit card right now, only debit.

For small businesses doing high reward credit cards is not a sustainable business. Which is why Brex is shutting them down.

immad commented on Why am I no longer qualified to be a Brex customer?   brex.com/support/why-am-i... · Posted by u/tvjames
eins1234 · 3 years ago
While it's great to maintain good enough unit economics to not have to pull stunts like this one, it's not necessarily always a plus from a customer perspective.

Comparing Mercury and Brex/Ramp specifically, Mercury is notably missing rewards on transactions, while Ramp has unlimited 1.5% cashback, and Brex has a bunch of multipliers ranging from 7x to 1x points.

If I have access to all of the options above, it would be financially irresponsible for me to spend through Mercury.

Would like to see Mercury get more competitive here even at the cost of less cushy unit economics.

EDIT: Some of the replies here seem to think Brex is shutting down entirely? Please read the actual article and the founder response above. They're only shutting down operations for small businesses, presumably because that's the only segment that doesn't have sustainable unit economics. % rewards on spend from interchange revenue has been around for decades. The model works, given the right set of customers and credit risk profiles.

immad · 3 years ago
This comment is so ironic. Love it.
immad commented on Why am I no longer qualified to be a Brex customer?   brex.com/support/why-am-i... · Posted by u/tvjames
felipemnoa · 3 years ago
I believe they are doing things right now that do not scale so that they can get reviews like yours. It is a strategy to create loyal customers at the beginning.

I'm not sure but I think PG has talked about this strategy.

immad · 3 years ago
Support is <5% of our revenue.

If the product mostly does what it should then support costs shouldn’t be crazy.

(Assuming that’s the part that you think is unscalable for us)

immad commented on Why am I no longer qualified to be a Brex customer?   brex.com/support/why-am-i... · Posted by u/tvjames
immad · 3 years ago
CEO of Mercury here.

If you are looking for an alternative, we are 100% committed to businesses of all sizes:

A) the smallest businesses can be the next big startup

B) We maintain strong unit economics at all sizes.

We setup a landing page to get these customers onboarded quickly: https://mercury.com/partner/brex

immad commented on Azlo Is Closing Down    · Posted by u/brainsrgdropout
chrisgoman · 5 years ago
Mercury is not approving all applicants for some unknown reason and they can NOT tell me why
immad · 5 years ago
(I am the ceo of Mercury)

Sometimes a bank compliance team can not legally say why a bank applicant is not approved. In those situations we can also not tell an applicant that, that is the case.

Though that is pretty rare, if you email me your company name/email I can take a look to see if I can provide more insight. We generally try to accept everyone we can legally accept if they are not in a prohibited industry etc.

immad commented on Simple Bank Is Closing   oregonlive.com/silicon-fo... · Posted by u/roberto8647
texasbigdata · 5 years ago
He specifically said Netsuite and not Quickbooks but to be fair thank you for responding and clarifying with detail.
immad · 5 years ago
The parent mentioned QBX statement, which is a Quickbooks format. Its a fairly standard format used across different accounting software.
immad commented on Simple Bank Is Closing   oregonlive.com/silicon-fo... · Posted by u/roberto8647
tylermenezes · 5 years ago
Exporting -- unless I'm missing something, it's only possible to export a CSV for transactions matching a filter. For better or worse, QBO etc formats are the standard for importing a statement to reconcile and there's extra friction each month to import a CSV.

Misleading -- Tea Room (for us) does almost nothing which was advertised:

- Treasury was marketed to be available to everyone who isn't taxed as a sole proprietor. We're a non-profit, and found out after moving all our money that we weren't eligible. I asked support to clarify this, and it looks like they've removed /all/ information about eligibility from the site which is a small improvement I guess.

- There don't seem to be any startup deals for Tea Room members. There isn't anything on the page on the site for Tea Room.

- We haven't gotten any tea. (I don't actually care about that, but come on, it's in the name.)

We moved to Mercury because Treasury would have been immensely useful to us. In all other ways BofA is /fine/ and we would not have moved if it were advertised honestly. I think it's deceptive because none of this was obvious to us before we planned out a migration and wired the $270k over to get access.

immad · 5 years ago
Thanks for the details Tyler.

Exporting - From my understanding the CSV format matches the QB specification. Are you saying that it matching the filters is an issue or that the format is incorrect.

Treasury for nonprofits - We only just launched Treasury (in December) and nonprofits are a relatively small part of our business so this hadn't come up during our alpha. I am going to investigate why our clearing house does not support nonpfotis, and make sure the restrictions is clearly stated.

Tea Room Deals/Perks - We recently launched this https://mercury.com/perks. Did you see this already and it doesn't match what you want or did you miss it?

Tea - We were revamping the tea packaging so it might be on pause right now. But we do really ship some pretty nice tea normally :).

The other thing that you get with tea room is free domestic + international wires.

Anyway, I can see why your experience was disappointing. I really appreciate the feedback and hopefully we can improve to deliver something better in the future.

immad commented on Simple Bank Is Closing   oregonlive.com/silicon-fo... · Posted by u/roberto8647
texasbigdata · 5 years ago
Does it export in all formats likes he’s claiming it doesn’t? Can you point to documentation? Usually, and not always, when someone makes a shadiness it’s directionally hinting at someone.
immad · 5 years ago
We have a QB export compatible file. It's an export button on the top of our transactions page and has date, description, amount, status, bank description, reference and notes as column.

I don't think we have specific documentation of that feature, but I am happy to demo it. Our api documentation is here: mercury.com/api.

I am sure there is something specific Tyler was talking about. Would love to learn what it is so we can fix it.

u/immad

KarmaCake day4336February 23, 2007
About
startup: Mercury.com - banking stack for Startups

twitter: twitter.com/immad

Previous YC09 startup: http://www.heyzap.com (acquired)

YC Badge: 0x81827d911cfa2e5e03833e1a0c29becf0c896b23

View Original