Readit News logoReadit News
gr3ml1n commented on Imgur pulls out of UK as data watchdog threatens fine   express.co.uk/news/uk/211... · Posted by u/ANewbury
layer8 · 3 months ago
You are sending data into the UK, hence you have to abide by their laws regarding said data.
gr3ml1n · 3 months ago
or what?
gr3ml1n commented on Imgur pulls out of UK as data watchdog threatens fine   express.co.uk/news/uk/211... · Posted by u/ANewbury
flumpcakes · 3 months ago
Why does it have to be immediately enforceable? Now Imgur have thrown the baby out with the bath water and cannot serve the UK and it leaves a big market for another company to come along and capitalise on that.

American companies are too use to being able to bully their way in America. Some countries do have better consumer protection laws.

gr3ml1n · 3 months ago
It's not a particularly big market, and given the regulatory hurdles: it's simply not worth doing business with the UK for most companies anymore.
gr3ml1n commented on Imgur pulls out of UK as data watchdog threatens fine   express.co.uk/news/uk/211... · Posted by u/ANewbury
flumpcakes · 3 months ago
If it affects UK citizens, living in the UK, then there's jurisdiction. Either the entities comply, remove their services to the UK, or they risk sanctions/being arrested when abroad/etc.

Why should a US company harm UK citizens just because they're in the US?

If you want to serve a market in another country you have to follow their rules.

In this case, Imgur have been misusing UK children's information. Considering the laws are pretty similar, I suspect they're misusing EU children's information too.

gr3ml1n · 3 months ago
> they risk sanctions/being arrested when abroad/etc.

That's the OP's question. Bluntly: if I'm here, and they're bloviating over there, what can they actually do about it?

gr3ml1n commented on Imgur pulls out of UK as data watchdog threatens fine   express.co.uk/news/uk/211... · Posted by u/ANewbury
ljm · 3 months ago
So a service like CloudFlare is the Great firewall of the world and CloudFlare can shut you down if you go against their interests as a supranational gatekeeper.

Smart thinking Batman.

gr3ml1n · 3 months ago
Not really. It's more like Cloudflare is providing an ipset in your iptables config. It's not Cloudflare's decision: they're just making it easier for you to do it.
gr3ml1n commented on GPT-5   openai.com/gpt-5/... · Posted by u/rd
logicchains · 4 months ago
>The idea is a sufficiently advanced AI could simulate.. everything

This is a demonstrably false assumption. Foundational results in chaos theory show that many processes require exponentially more compute to simulate for a linearly longer time period. For such processes, even if every atom in the observable universe was turned into a computer, they could only be simulated for a few seconds or minutes more, due to the nature of exponential growth. This is an incontrovertible mathematical law of the universe, the same way that it's fundamentally impossible to sort an arbitrary array in O(1) time.

gr3ml1n · 4 months ago
The counter-argument to this from the AI crowd would be that it's fundamentally impossible for _us_, with our goopy brains, to understand how to do it. Something that is factorial-orders-of-magnitude smarter and faster than us could figure it out.

Yes, it's a very hand-wavey argument.

gr3ml1n commented on GPT-5   openai.com/gpt-5/... · Posted by u/rd
zonotope · 4 months ago
How will it be able to devise this perfect model if it can't dissect the animal, analyze the genes, or perform experiments?
gr3ml1n · 4 months ago
Well, first, it would be so far beyond anything we can comprehend as intelligence that even asking that question is considered silly. An ant isn't asking us how we measure the acidity of the atmosphere. It would simply do it via some mechanism we can't implement or understand ourselves.

But, again with the caveats above: if we assume an AI that is infinitely more intelligent than us and capable of recursive self-improvement to where it's compute was made more powerful by factorial orders of magnitude, it could simply brute force (with a bit of derivation) everything it would need from the data currently available.

It could iteratively create trillions (or more) of simulations until it finds a model that matches all known observations.

gr3ml1n commented on GPT-5   openai.com/gpt-5/... · Posted by u/rd
stoneyhrm1 · 4 months ago
> revolutionary breakthroughs in essentially all field

This doesn't really make sense outside computers. Since AI would be training itself, it needs to have the right answers, but as of now it doesn't really interact with the physical world. The most it could do is write code, and check things that have no room for interpretation, like speed, latency, percentage of errors, exceptions, etc.

But, what other fields would it do this in? How can it makes strives in biology, it can't dissect animals, it can't figure more out about plants that humans feed into the training data. Regarding math, math is human-defined. Humans said "addition does this", "this symbol means that", etc.

I just don't understand how AI could ever surpass anything human known before we live by the rules defined by us.

gr3ml1n · 4 months ago
It starts to veer into sci-fi and I don't personally believe this is practically possible on any relevant timescale, but:

The idea is a sufficiently advanced AI could simulate.. everything. You don't need to interact with the physical world if you have a perfect model of it.

> But, what other fields would it do this in? How can it makes strives in biology, it can't dissect animals ...

It doesn't need to dissect an animal if it has a perfect model of it that it can simulate. All potential genetic variations, all interactions between biological/chemical processes inside it, etc.

gr3ml1n commented on Monitor your security cameras with locally processed AI   frigate.video/... · Posted by u/zakki
W3zzy · 4 months ago
I'm so happy those uses of camera's are illegal in the EU. Camera's at work can only used for safety. You could have other - less intrusive - systems in place for all tge other issues.
gr3ml1n · 4 months ago
Isn't the entire EU essentially a panopticon of cameras?
gr3ml1n commented on If you're remote, ramble   stephango.com/ramblings... · Posted by u/lawgimenez
majke · 4 months ago
Let me share a personal story. Back in 2014 when I was working at Cloudflare on DDoS mitigation I collaborated a lot with a collage - James (Jog). I asked him loads of questions, from "how to login to a server", via "what is anycast" to "tell me how you mitigated this one, give me precise instructions you've run".

I quickly realised that these conversations had value outside the two of us - pretty much everyone else onboarded had similar questions. Some subjects were about pure onboarding friction, some were about workflows most folks didn't know existed, some were about theoretical concepts.

So I moved the questions to a public (within company) channel, and called it "Marek's Bitching" - because this is what it was. Pretty much me complaining and moaning and asking annoying questions. I invited more London folks (Zygis), and before I knew half of the company joined it.

It had tremendous value. It captured all the things that didn't have real place in the other places in the company, from technical novelties, through discussions that were escaping structure - we suspected intel firmware bugs, but that was outside of any specific team at the time.

Then the channel was renamed to something more palatable - "Marek's technical corner" and it had a clear place in the technical company culture for more than a decade.

So yes, it's important to have a place to ramble, and it's important to have "your own channel" where folks have less friction and stigma to ask stupid questions and complain. Personal channels might be overkill, but a per-team or per-location "rambling/bitching" channel is a good idea.

gr3ml1n · 4 months ago
Fwiw, Marek's technical corner still exists and still gets some activity.
gr3ml1n commented on Adipose tissue retains an epigenetic memory of obesity after weight loss   nature.com/articles/s4158... · Posted by u/paulpauper
Aurornis · 8 months ago
Yeah, it's well known that steroids shut you down. The problem with the broscience is that the PCT is talked about like it reverses everything like an antidote, but long-term bodybuilders often end up on TRT because eventually they can't get back to baseline.
gr3ml1n · 8 months ago
That isn't true. Dedicated bodybuilders, starting more commonly ~5 years ago, decided that PCT wasn't worth it. Instead of typical 16-20 week cycles followed by 4-6 weeks of PCT, they adjust the dose between supraphysiological and (generally) top-of-normal, i.e.: blast and cruise.

It's not because they couldn't recover, it's because they don't want to or see the point.

u/gr3ml1n

KarmaCake day198September 23, 2024
About
@gremlin_sh on x
View Original