Is AI-generated text speech?
It is when a human publishes it. Which is why they're also liable for it.
Readit NewsDeleted Comment
frumplestlatz commented on A new bill in New York would require disclaimers on AI-generated news content niemanlab.org/2026/02/a-n... · Posted by u/giuliomagnifico
frumplestlatz commented on If you've got Nothing to Hide (2015) jacquesmattheij.com/if-yo... · Posted by u/jacquesm
Let's just stipulate everything you said is true. You do realize that the subordination of German corporations validates the quote you're ostensibly arguing against? Given your framing, German fascists would have loved the scale of cooperation that the American fascist executive branch is receiving from corporations, rather than have to do the difficult work of subordinating them.
The German population[1] was not unwilling; your error is not recognizing that it started with cooperation and grew until all of society was subordinated to the totalitarian state.
There was massive alignment across their society. What they “achieved” would not have been possible any other way.
As someone that abhors the destructive ideologies of that era — and has spent a considerable amount of time studying the history — it’s amusing ironic to be repeatedly compared to the predominant fascist ideology (not that you personally have done this) by people echoing the behavior of the predominate destructive left-wing ideology of the day.
From a historical perspective, it’s not the right-wing that I’m worried about now. I worry about the totalizing, agency-eroding, violence normalizing, and norm-enforcing (thought terminating) “ethics” that have taken firm hold of the left’s levers of power over the past 15 years.
[1] except for the German populations that they literally wanted to murder, of course.
Deleted Comment
frumplestlatz commented on If you've got Nothing to Hide (2015) jacquesmattheij.com/if-yo... · Posted by u/jacquesm
Yes, we substantially disagree on a contentious policy question. That does not change historical fact, nor does it make claims like “dwarfs anything the Germans could have wished for” anything other than profound historical illiteracy.
Deleted Comment
frumplestlatz commented on If you've got Nothing to Hide (2015) jacquesmattheij.com/if-yo... · Posted by u/jacquesm
That's why I'm asking a question. For me the difference between then and now is then, 2015 it was still a thing that I saw hanging in the future, the OPM hack is what prompted me to write this. But if I had not written this then I would probably be writing it today on account of the ICE article currently on the front page.
All of those big tech companies have willingly given in to Trump and his band of goons and are cooperating at a scale that dwarfs anything the Germans could have ever wished for. The article shows the damage that one single field in one single file could do. Now multiply that by a couple of 1000.
The potential for an epic disaster is definitely there and even HN is apparently not immune to having its share of bootlickers and bootwearers.
> All of those big tech companies have willingly given in to Trump and his band of goons and are cooperating at a scale that dwarfs anything the Germans could have ever wished for.
This is dangerously ahistorical and an offensive trivialization of the scale of human suffering inflicted by the Nazi regime. Fascism as practiced by the NSDAP involved the total integration of the state, the legal system, industry, media, and civil society into a single coercive apparatus in service of a genocidal war. German corporations were not “cooperating”; they were subordinated, aligned, and legally compelled within a one-party totalitarian state.
Dead Comment
Dead Comment
Dead Comment