Readit News logoReadit News
doc_manhat_3 commented on Things that helped me get out of the AI 10x engineer imposter syndrome   colton.dev/blog/curing-yo... · Posted by u/coltonv
simonw · 6 months ago
I found myself agreeing with quite a lot of this article.

I'm a pretty huge proponent for AI-assisted development, but I've never found those 10x claims convincing. I've estimated that LLMs make me 2-5x more productive on the parts of my job which involve typing code into a computer, which is itself a small portion of that I do as a software engineer.

That's not too far from this article's assumptions. From the article:

> I wouldn't be surprised to learn AI helps many engineers do certain tasks 20-50% faster, but the nature of software bottlenecks mean this doesn't translate to a 20% productivity increase and certainly not a 10x increase.

I think that's an under-estimation - I suspect engineers that really know how to use this stuff effectively will get more than a 0.2x increase - but I do think all of the other stuff involved in building software makes the 10x thing unrealistic in most cases.

doc_manhat_3 · 6 months ago
I think even claims of 2-5x are highly suspect. It would imply that if your team is using AI then all else equal they accomplish 2-5 times as much in a quarter. I don't know about you but I'm certainly not seeing this and most people on my team use AI.

[And to those saying we're using it wrong... well I can't argue with something that's not falsifiable]

doc_manhat_3 commented on Things that helped me get out of the AI 10x engineer imposter syndrome   colton.dev/blog/curing-yo... · Posted by u/coltonv
siva7 · 6 months ago
I beg to differ. My diffs are 10x bigger than before though i don't have any more time to review them.
doc_manhat_3 · 6 months ago
This is the point that the author is making. 10x bigger diff is probably not leading to 10x productivity.

[In fact you can sometimes find that 10x bigger diff leads to decreased productivity down the line...]

u/doc_manhat_3

KarmaCake day10August 5, 2025View Original