Readit News logoReadit News
ddq commented on A dive into open chat protocols   wiki.alopex.li/ADiveIntoO... · Posted by u/Bogdanp
palata · 23 days ago
The problem I see with chat protocols is that it's all about network effect.

How do you get people to leave WhatsApp for something better? - You don't. They just stay on WhatsApp.

One problem being that if you want better security (Signal), you lose a little bit in UX. If you want better UX (Telegram), you completely lose the security aspect. So WhatsApp seems like a local optimum: relatively secure, and you can find your friends there.

Then we can discuss all we want about the merits of Discord/Slack/Matrix/Zulip, but the truth remains this: if you ask someone who mostly uses Discord what they want you to use for your new community, they will say Discord. If they mostly use Zulip, they will say Zulip. People don't want the better solution, they want the least effort.

I have seen multiple open source communities (who spend a fair share of their time complaining about how people don't support open source instead of using the proprietary alternative) choosing their chat system: people were fighting between Slack and Discord, nobody gave a damn about using an open source system. How hypocritical...

ddq · 23 days ago
At this point, I simply want to pick whichever protocol has the highest concentration of my kind of folks. The Discord audience is not it.
ddq commented on The United States withdraws from UNESCO   state.gov/releases/office... · Posted by u/layer8
rexpop · a month ago
Deeply, deeply deranged to suggest that Israel—a $600B economy—is "wagging the dog" of our $30,500B economy.
ddq · a month ago
"Deeply, deeply deranged" is fairly inflammatory language to express your own reductive ignorance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-BDS_laws#Anti-BDS_laws_in...
ddq commented on Houdini of FL: autistic savant in prison for taking tools he inherited   en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mar... · Posted by u/felineflock
thegrim33 · a month ago
He was in solitary confinement that long as a result of his repeated escapes. Not for the initial charge. Whether you agree with the way it turned out or not, the way you phrased it is completely incorrect and misleading and just rage baiting.
ddq · a month ago
On the contrary, that detail makes it even more enraging. A real life Jean Valjean.
ddq commented on How bad are childhood literacy rates?   vox.com/culture/419070/ch... · Posted by u/pseudolus
smogcutter · a month ago
For my sins, I teach middle school. There’s plenty of different angles on this, but I’d like to highlight a recent one that may not immediately occur to people here without young children: COVID retirements hit the elementary schools particularly hard.

Teaching high school on zoom is one thing, now imagine teaching 3rd. So the veteran elementary teachers retired or quit, and there’s no adequate pipeline to replace them, especially in underserved communities.

Coming through the system now is a cohort of children whose k-5 teachers have been a rotating cast of subs and ineffective new hires, and it shows.

ddq · a month ago
This to me is the most urgent moral issue of the day: our active stunting of our children's development. Our collective misguided and counterproductive approach to pedagogy does not cultivate a learning mindset but rather stifles children's enormous natural aptitude for exploratory play. We are doing it wrong and we know it. The curriculum we use isn't worth paying minimum wage to teach.

It could be different. It must be. We have role models to imitate, better methods to follow, resources and tools galore. What is needed now is organization toward common purpose. How does the internet bystander locate effective organizations to disrupt the march of folly? This is a situation where the pilot has gone mad and we must seize control of the aircraft but are too paralyzed by social forces to act.

ddq commented on Supreme Court's ruling practically wipes out free speech for sex writing online   ellsberg.substack.com/p/f... · Posted by u/macawfish
lelanthran · a month ago
> The grandparent post didn't say "transgender treatments" they said "transgender issues."

You don't think that transgender treatments is a transgender issue? If you think it is then my response is perfectly on-topic.

> Do you believe that the mere concept of questioning your gender identity or expression is something that should be kept from the minds of minors?

Depending on your jurisdiction, there are messages you can't target to kids. Why should there be a special exemption for this?

Besides, my belief on this is irrelevant; the only transgender issue that has gotten pushback en-masse from the clear majority of people world wide has been transgender treatments on minors.

IOW, this (treatment for persons unable to give informed consent) is a very unpopular position.

ddq · a month ago
[flagged]

Dead Comment

ddq commented on Grok: Searching X for "From:Elonmusk (Israel or Palestine or Hamas or Gaza)"   simonwillison.net/2025/Ju... · Posted by u/simonw
Y_Y · a month ago
> Grok's personal opinion

Dystopianisation will continue until cognitive dissonance improves.

ddq · a month ago
In the '70s they called it "heightening the contradiction".
ddq commented on Jack Welch, the Man Who Broke Capitalism (2022)   forbes.com/sites/kylewest... · Posted by u/throw0101b
kamaal · 2 months ago
>>I suppose some Americans would have preferred a situation where China stayed Communist or collapsed.

The definition of Communism per the west, is something that always fails by default. The way Chinese define communism is doing whatever it takes to win.

When you remove all the abstract words behind this game, a simple philosophy is if you do the right things you win. You can call it capitalism, communism or whatever you want.

ddq · 2 months ago
Market Daoism?
ddq commented on Jack Welch, the Man Who Broke Capitalism (2022)   forbes.com/sites/kylewest... · Posted by u/throw0101b
thmsths · 2 months ago
I feel like that makes sense actually. One core tenet of the "free market" is the need for competition, otherwise complacency and rent seeking happen and things get bad. If that apply for corporations, why not economic systems too?
ddq · 2 months ago
The market of markets must be free, or the idea of a free market is a myth. Which it is. Capitalism cannot simply be removed, it must be outcompeted by a superior usurper.
ddq commented on Sam Altman Slams Meta’s AI Talent Poaching: 'Missionaries Will Beat Mercenaries'   wired.com/story/sam-altma... · Posted by u/spenvo
tom_m · 2 months ago
And illegally too. Anthropic didn't pay for those books they used.

It's too late at this point. The damage is done. These companies trained on illegally obtained data and they will never be held accountable for that. The training is done and they got what they needed. So even if they can't train on it in the future, it doesn't matter. They already have those base models.

ddq · 2 months ago
Then punitive measures are in order. Add it to the pile of illegal, immoral, and unethical behavior of the feudal tech oligarchs already long overdue for justice. The harm they have done and are doing to humanity should not remain unpunished.

u/ddq

KarmaCake day190July 18, 2013View Original