Readit News logoReadit News
crawfordcomeaux commented on Ancient Patagonian hunter-gatherers took care of their injured and disabled   phys.org/news/2025-10-anc... · Posted by u/pseudolus
crawfordcomeaux · 2 months ago
We need only look at the cultures of the Aka, Bayaka, and Mbuti tribes, who all split off from the same tribe 150k years ago & still share many of the same cultural norms oriented around counterdominance, matrifocal care, and singing as a means of protection & decision-making.

Their cultures can show us what it took to survive and thrive in a jungle with numerous large predators. These tribes carry wisdom we can apply in our daily lives.

crawfordcomeaux commented on Ancient Patagonian hunter-gatherers took care of their injured and disabled   phys.org/news/2025-10-anc... · Posted by u/pseudolus
n4r9 · 2 months ago
Surely emotions and morale are worth considering as well. Even if someone is unproductive and stupid, but friendly and well-liked, then their death would impact everyone's productivity for some time.
crawfordcomeaux · 2 months ago
Exactly. Every being has intrinsic value. A pure productivity perspective is rooted in dehumanization and a reductive take on what it means to live/survive/thrive.
crawfordcomeaux commented on Ancient Patagonian hunter-gatherers took care of their injured and disabled   phys.org/news/2025-10-anc... · Posted by u/pseudolus
mothballed · 2 months ago
Not taking care of a formerly productive injured person who might recover would be profoundly stupid, if you have the food for it and some expectation they might be productive again or a superior ability to direct those who might be productive.
crawfordcomeaux · 2 months ago
Not taking care of a wise injured person who might recover & help guide others, teach children, care for children, help heal, reveal spiritual teachings, and otherwise be human would be profoundly stupid. Judging who to care for based solely on productivity or ability to direct others would also be profoundly stupid....this strategy sounds like middle-management.
crawfordcomeaux commented on Larry Ellison on AI-powered surveillance [video] (2024)   streamable.com/2xtyyd... · Posted by u/CharlesW
crawfordcomeaux · 3 months ago
To follow on:

If your hatred for this doesn't lead you to commit your skills to building systems of liberation, you're likely part of the tech soldier caste and not yet the liberatory praxis movement.

crawfordcomeaux commented on The link between trauma, drug use, and our search to feel better   lithub.com/the-link-betwe... · Posted by u/PaulHoule
kennyadam · 3 months ago
So you know of any personal blogs or articles or other writings from therapists who feel this way and left the profession? It sounds fascinating, but I wouldn't know where to start.
crawfordcomeaux · 3 months ago
Anything and everything by Ismatu Gwendolyn, who stopped charging for all work, therapy included.

https://threadings.io

https://www.youtube.com/@ismatu.gwendolyn

crawfordcomeaux commented on The link between trauma, drug use, and our search to feel better   lithub.com/the-link-betwe... · Posted by u/PaulHoule
reenorap · 3 months ago
"As capitalism has invented ever more ways to be miserable, so too has it invented ever more specific ways to ease that misery."

What? Is the author saying that misery didn't exist in socialism or communism?

crawfordcomeaux · 3 months ago
No. That's your bias injecting that interpretation.
crawfordcomeaux commented on The link between trauma, drug use, and our search to feel better   lithub.com/the-link-betwe... · Posted by u/PaulHoule
dyauspitr · 3 months ago
If this is a guy and he says things like a platonic snuggling with a lesbian made him feel good, then it’s an automatic disqualification. I can’t look up to this person. Being staunchly leftist, as a man, I hate this and the exact opposite of what I want a man to represent. You can ask any follow up questions you want but the baseline assumption is someone that acts like this is an automatic, baseline, fundamental opposite of a role model.

We desperately need a centrist party that is contemporarily “sexist” to pull men back from the brink. Honestly, thought most feminists are going to recoil from this paradigm, this is way better than the alternative where we essentially lose the men (of all races) to the far right void.

crawfordcomeaux · 3 months ago
"Man" is a dualistic made-up term devoid of connection with reality. Enjoy your fantasies. The world is nondual, not Boolean.
crawfordcomeaux commented on The link between trauma, drug use, and our search to feel better   lithub.com/the-link-betwe... · Posted by u/PaulHoule
Aurornis · 3 months ago
The social media definition of trauma has diverged from the clinician definition. The social media version of “trauma” is used to define anything stressful.

When we start redefining trauma to cover everything down to the basic realities of life like having to pay for rent to live somewhere, the term loses meaning. With a definition this broad, where do we draw the line between stress and trauma? Is there a line between basic inconvenience and trauma, if the person suffering the inconvenience doesn’t handle it well?

The less discussed problem is that some people have a problem of exaggerating everything into catastrophic stressors, thereby turning common experiences into traumas. This itself is a problem that is addressed through therapy, but it’s not as amenable to garnering sympathy on social media. It’s not appealing to read someone whine about having to work a job to eat food in a first world country, because that’s life and it’s a hundred times easier than it was for our ancestors. However, reframe that as a high-brow article about the perils of capitalism and how it inflicts trauma on us and causes PTSD and now it feels like we are the victims who deserve sympathy.

crawfordcomeaux · 3 months ago
The idea that you can draw a line between stress and trauma is an attempt to generalize something experienced on a personal level.

That's not how to handle any complex system with accuracy and effectiveness.

Therapy doesn't address systemic oppression, which does lead to more incidents resulting in PTSD & is a generator of CPTSD (which isn't just for edge cases, but for recurrent stressor that don't allow the body time to recover from past events).

Western therapy is failing. The therapists attending to what's going on are speaking out and some are abandoning their practices because they realize they've been co-opted in systemic harm.

crawfordcomeaux commented on The link between trauma, drug use, and our search to feel better   lithub.com/the-link-betwe... · Posted by u/PaulHoule
Aurornis · 3 months ago
> Do you think another term is more appropriate to describe the experiences underlying CPTSD?

True CPTSD as diagnosed over time by a clinician is the result of complex traumas (complex, specifically, as that’s part of the definition. It’s what the C is for). The term is valid in that context.

In common social media language, even the term CPTSD has become diluted. It was intended to represent complex cases of PTSD which were edge cases, and correspondingly rare.

At some point the social media version of CPTSD emerged as a generic term and nearly everyone who self-diagnosed as having PTSD started upgrading themselves to CPTSD.

The comment above is right that “trauma” has become so generic as to cover everything stressful or saddening in common vernacular. The concept of CPTSD was supposed to be a step above even normal trauma, but now even CPTSD is being brought out as a generic term for any post-trauma response, which was never the definition of CPTSD.

A similar trend is happening on social media with the ADHD influencers now upgrading themselves to “AuDHD” which they say is a special more difficult variant of ADHD combined with Autism. My friends in psychiatry are at their wits end with all of the people coming in and demanding Autism diagnoses or “AuDHD” diagnoses despite not showing Autistic traits at all.

There’s an arms race going on where some people try to amplify experiences into something much more dramatic. These therapy and psychiatry terms start to lose their meaning when they get adopted by social media.

crawfordcomeaux · 3 months ago
Your friends in psychiartry...are they acknowledging the impact of living under oppression as a direct cause of issues & advocating for an end to oppression?

Because that's what many healers outside of western medicine are touting.

People are amplifying because the western medicine approach isn't addressing underlying issues & so people are trying to explain the compounding of their issues in the language of western medicine. The dismissiveness in these comments is a direct driver of this culture.

crawfordcomeaux commented on EPA Seeks to Eliminate Critical PFAS Drinking Water Protections   earthjustice.org/press/20... · Posted by u/enraged_camel
sunsetSamurai · 3 months ago
I live in the USA so I don't have the choice to just leave, at least not now. So I must do what I can to make this country better.
crawfordcomeaux · 3 months ago
I live in the USA. You can put all your skills to work on designing systems of collective liberation to replace the existing systems of oppression this country was founded on & requires to persist. A collapse is coming, so now is the time to prepare so we have something liberatory to fill the predictable power vacuum with. The wealthy are already doing this.

u/crawfordcomeaux

KarmaCake day696May 2, 2011
About
206-432-7671

santajokratesus@gmail.com

http://www.facebook.com/crawford.comeaux

View Original