Readit News logoReadit News
carussell commented on Void Linux project leader has disappeared   voidlinux.eu/news/2018/05... · Posted by u/MindTooth
znpy · 8 years ago
At the time of writing that comment, no one in this thread had asked those question. Also, on the page linked, the author was not asking those question.

That led me to conclude that nobody asked those things.

carussell · 8 years ago
After the leader of a substantial project disappears, in the ~20 minutes of incidental contact you have with the issue after having only just been introduced to it having not stumbled over a particular discussion out of sheer dumb fucking luck, you conclude that means the discussion never occurred. Do you really think that's a sound conclusion?

Let me put it this way, do you really think that, in the three months since this person disappeared, out of the dozens of people who have a far closer relationship to him than you do and a far greater personal stake in his wellbeing, that you are really the first person to consider whether something might have happened—to the point that you're comfortable to grandstand with a public indictment about how "sad" their behavior is?

You are the worst kind of person. Fuck you.

carussell commented on Introducing .app, a more secure home for apps on the web   blog.google/topics/develo... · Posted by u/magicalblob
tomc1985 · 8 years ago
Three arbitrary letters in a list of TLDs and they call it "innovation"...
carussell · 8 years ago
Did you fabricate a quote? (And if so, why?) Neither "innovation" nor any derivatives of "innovate" appear in this post.
carussell commented on Void Linux project leader has disappeared   voidlinux.eu/news/2018/05... · Posted by u/MindTooth
znpy · 8 years ago
The sad things imho is that no one asked:

- Is he/she fine?

- Did something happen?

- Can we help?

carussell · 8 years ago
That's a strong claim. What led you to conclude that nobody asked any of those things?
carussell commented on Void Linux project leader has disappeared   voidlinux.eu/news/2018/05... · Posted by u/MindTooth
tannhaeuser · 8 years ago
IANAL, but apart from a private entity having such power being problematic (to say the least) who's going to put stuff on GitHub if it can be gamed to take away your control?

Edit: GH could also be in for liability claims should the original owner re-appear (at least in general, if not this particular case), and would need to check identity of the involved parties and whatnot, which is going to be very costly.

carussell · 8 years ago
What's with all the legal bluster in your comments here? Not only do the liabilities you're trying to conjure up not exist, but this is not even the first occurrence of something like this happening with GitHub. They have a documented policy for freeing up inactive names. (Spoiler alert: it's allowed, and they've done it.)
carussell commented on How to speed up the Rust compiler in 2018   blog.mozilla.org/nnetherc... · Posted by u/nnethercote
noelwelsh · 8 years ago
Right, but compilation performance is not a race in which you have to be first, but a minimum threshold that you must meet. Compilation just has to be fast enough that it doesn't annoy developers most of the time. Once you achieve that they'll mostly stop complaining. I believe Clang et al are fast enough.

(This is true for performance and optimisation is general: fast enough is good enough.)

carussell · 8 years ago
> I believe Clang et al are fast enough.

This is a genuine case of survivorship bias in action.

I guarantee you that there are people not using Clang or writing, let's say, C++ because of slow compile times. You just never hear about how much they hate using them, because those people no longer are using them.

carussell commented on The Impoliteness of Overriding Methods (2012)   journal.stuffwithstuff.co... · Posted by u/tosh
mst · 8 years ago
Attempting to google variants on the them of "CLOS daemon methods" isn't bringing up anything recognisable as what you're describing - happen to know how to find a link?

(I love it when my attempt to RTFM is defeated by my being too stupid to find the FM in the first place ;)

carussell · 8 years ago
From Yegge's "The Pinocchio Problem":

> Great systems also have advice. There's no universally accepted name for this feature. Sometimes it's called hooks, or filters, or aspect-oriented programming. As far as I know, Lisp had it first, and it's called advice in Lisp. Advice is a mini-framework that provides before, around, and after hooks by which you can programmatically modify the behavior of some action or function call in the system. Not all advice systems are created equal. The more scope that is given to an advice system — that is, the more reach it has in the system it's advising — the more powerful the parent system will be.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advice_(programming)

carussell commented on Unlearning toxic behaviors in a code review culture   medium.freecodecamp.org/u... · Posted by u/ingve
ryanobjc · 8 years ago
The problem with the question form "why didnt you just do ___ here?" is it's loaded with the assumption that the other party should have known to do this other thing instead.

A better approach is to use the less loaded "have you considered doing X here?".

If you find yourself needing to demand others not take offense at your questions, you might wish to try a different approach.

carussell · 8 years ago
A "Have you considered..." question asks for a "yes" or "no".

A "Why[...]" question asks for why.

Assuming that "Why didn't you just do X?" isn't really just a disingenuous way to say, "you're an idiot; do it this way instead", then you should ask for what you want and ask the why question, not the yes-or-no question. In the case that it is a disingenuous question, then that's something that's covered adequately by #5. Suggesting the avoidance of sarcasm is already broadly applicable enough to cover using questions when you really mean to make a statement. (Which is not specific to code reviews—it's as obnoxious in real life.)

Deleted Comment

Deleted Comment

Deleted Comment

u/carussell

KarmaCake day2674September 22, 2009
About
I don't HN anymore.
View Original