Readit News logoReadit News
canoebuilder commented on OpenAI whistleblower found dead in San Francisco apartment   mercurynews.com/2024/12/1... · Posted by u/mmorearty
ALittleLight · a year ago
"Stealing data" seems pretty strong. Web scraping is legal. If you put text on the public Internet other people can read it or do statistical processing on it.

What do you mean he was "stealing data"? Was he hacking into somewhere?

canoebuilder · a year ago
In a lot of ways, the statistical processing is a novel form of information retrieval. So the issue is somewhat like if 20 years ago Google was indexing the web, then decided to just rehost all the indexed content on their own servers and monetize the views instead linking to the original source of the content.
canoebuilder commented on Nikon Z 28-400mm f/4-8 VR: The Best All-Purpose Lens I've Ever Used   petapixel.com/2024/05/19/... · Posted by u/PaulHoule
SassyBird · 2 years ago
I think all the bickering about “snobs” and whatever the opposite is comes from people doing very different photography and for some reason transferring their choices onto others and vice versa. E.g. I mostly photograph wildlife, often in dark forests, so this (28-400) lens is too slow for me. There are also prime lens purists, but in wildlife they mostly stick to birds, because good luck photographing e.g. small mammals like squirrels with that (I do follow one photographer who manages to do it, but it’s beyond my abilities). Your choices will be different still if you photograph mostly still scenes, maybe portraits etc, where your shutter speed lives in a dimension I generally don’t venture into. There is also the question of taste about how much depth of field you like, what apertures you like, how tightly you like to crop, whether you skew more towards low-key, high-key or balanced exposure etc.

I wish people were more cognisant of the diversity of photography different people do and not make universal judgements about gear or techniques in general.

canoebuilder · 2 years ago
>I do follow one photographer who manages to do it

Link?

Also to your photos, if you post them, and care to share.

canoebuilder commented on Rare things become common at scale (2014)   longform.asmartbear.com/s... · Posted by u/Brajeshwar
MrDarcy · 2 years ago
Elon Musk fired Twitter employees. Have you not noticed how the site has deteriorated technically? I personally know people who have suffered abuse on Twitter, reported the abuse, and had no action taken because Elon fired the trust and safety org.
canoebuilder · 2 years ago
If reading something is hurting your feelings, you can stop reading it.

Twitter even provides mute, block, and whatnot functionality to prevent specified things from even showing up in your line of sight to begin with. And if the app is really bothering you, you can always set it down and go outside, take a walk, meet somebody new, do something that will put a smile on your face on your deathbed.

Lumping in mean comments online, with actual abuse is approaching risible. Words have meanings, we shouldn’t dilute or distort them.

By Twitter “not taking action,” sounds like your friend is upset that he or she can no longer co-opt the proprietors of the site into enacting punitive measures on people who draw his or her ire.

Maybe some mean things were said or whatever, but at the end of the day it’s just text on a screen isn’t it? And there’s a lot more to life than text on a screen, isn’t there?

It’s also weird how you mention the technical functioning of the site, then bring up the “Trust & Safety Org” when the legacy of “Trust & Safety” is a small cabal with extremist views arbitrarily deciding what information to censor and suppress based on their own viewpoints, whims, and influence from government agencies.

That has nothing to do with the technical functioning of the site which is a matter of reproducible, specifiable, determinate functions implemented in computer code to produce a useful product. The kind of thing that really turns the mind of an autist on.

P.S. Not to be too blasé about your friend, mean words can be an issue, especially an ongoing pattern, but anonymous strangers online seems like less of an issue than irl, and was this really an issue where block or mute wasn’t sufficient? How so?

canoebuilder commented on New iPad Pro with M4 chip and Apple Pencil Pro   apple.com/newsroom/2024/0... · Posted by u/praseodym
vadersb · 2 years ago
I was a long-time iPad fan for more than a decade, currently using 5 year old iPad Pro 10.5 which works flawlessly but its battery is quite degraded already.

With these new iPads introduced I no longer have a viable upgrade path: iPad pro is a no-go for me because of OLED screen (which I strongly oppose, PWM, irregular subpixels, etc.) and newly introduced iPad Air doesn't have 120Hz display (or ProMotion in Apple terms). So, there are no new iPads with LCD display and ProMotion.

What a sad state both Apple hardware and Apple software are in.

canoebuilder · 2 years ago
Would you mind going into more details about what you see as the OLED downsides? Is it just Apple’s variant, or the broader product category?
canoebuilder commented on Ethereum Foundation removes their canary   github.com/ethereum/ether... · Posted by u/diggan
kspacewalk2 · 2 years ago
I strongly doubt a judge will care to distinguish the two.
canoebuilder · 2 years ago
Why did you do this thing 2 weeks ago?

vs

Why didn’t you do this thing 2 weeks ago that you were under no legal obligation to do?

Seems like a significant and valid distinction even if what they communicate to the intended audience is largely the same.

“Largely the same” because in the second case it would be possible that forgetting, or some other obstacle to resigning occurred.

canoebuilder commented on Sycamore Gap: New life springs from rescued tree   bbc.com/news/science-envi... · Posted by u/sohkamyung
kyleee · 2 years ago
Wayward teens
canoebuilder · 2 years ago
What is your source of info here? Can you be more specific? Who are they?
canoebuilder commented on The extraordinary lives of coast redwoods   noemamag.com/the-extraord... · Posted by u/PaulHoule
smallerfish · 2 years ago
Borneo has a huge area of primary forest, though it has been extensively logged. And of course the Amazon, the Congo, areas of Uganda, and many others.
canoebuilder · 2 years ago
Human habitation and influence on the landscape in the Amazon seems far more extensive in scope and duration than previously thought, based on recent discoveries.

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=Amazon+mounds+archaeology&t=ffip&i...

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=Amazon+australasian+dna&t=ffip&ia=...

The significance of the second link is ancient peoples further north and in other parts of the Americas don’t share this genetic link, indicating a longer timeline of human habitation in the region than previously thought.

canoebuilder commented on Sycamore Gap: New life springs from rescued tree   bbc.com/news/science-envi... · Posted by u/sohkamyung
iam-TJ · 2 years ago
It's a Whydunnit, not a Whodunnit - the people that cut the tree down are known.
canoebuilder · 2 years ago
Who are they?

Dead Comment

canoebuilder commented on OpenAI and journalism   openai.com/blog/openai-an... · Posted by u/zerojames
altruios · 2 years ago
AI is merely exposing how insane copyright law is.

Using public facing data for training is exactly as legal as looking at that data yourself. An AI regurgitating information is exactly as legal as a human doing it. If you are allowed to - in a public square - recite from memory an article you read on the internet... if that is legal: then an AI doing the equivalent must also legal.

This is a truth: because (to reiterate a basic fact) the training data (the text) simply does not exist in the LLM. What does exist is a set of weights and biases that are a representation of that data (a model). To say a model even is reciting data is inaccurate...

With that said - big companies are not your friend - open source development of AI is the only way to go. Transparency is key to healthy development.

canoebuilder · 2 years ago
In considering these things, affordances must be made to the new abilities made possible by the computational tools now at our disposal.

Following your line of reasoning if it is perfectly legal to walk into a coffee shop and sit down and listen to what the people next to me are talking about, commit it to memory, even make notes about it, does it then follow that it should be perfectly legal, reasonable, and acceptable for a govt agency or some other organization to put microphones everywhere to record what everyone is talking about, then feed all this data into various databases and modeling systems?

Reciting something in a park is different than selling a copyrighted print of something in a park when you don’t hold the copyright. Which is much closer to what the NYT is accusing OpenAI of.

The training data not “existing” in the model is interesting, but at some point, a distinction without a difference.

If I hire an autistic savant to go to a library and read all the books, then I set up a book selling service where whenever people want to buy a book I have my savant employee type out the book for them, is it then going to pass muster in a copyright case if I tell the judge “It’s okay actually, because the books don’t actually exist in my employee’s brain, merely neuronal encodings of them.” ?

If I have a copyrighted image on which I don’t hold the copyright. But I want to start selling it to people, is it cool if I just run it through a lossless compression algorithm, thereby generating a new encoding of the information and then sell this new encoding along with the software and command to reverse the compression?

Regarding the open source stuff, there I think you might find more favor to your arguments.

But the stuff we are seeing within commercial enterprises like OpenAI and Midjourney is clearly copyright infringement.

And I don’t see copyright law being insane in these cases.

u/canoebuilder

KarmaCake day345April 12, 2008View Original