Readit News logoReadit News
brockwhittaker commented on Is technical analysis just stock market astrology?   alicegg.tech//2023/07/25/... · Posted by u/zer0tonin
vasco · 2 years ago
If a meteorite hits earth, aliens are discovered, quantum computing breaks encryption, someone launches a nuclear bomb, etc, any of those will affect the stock market by a lot. Technical analysis can't predict a meteorite or any of those other things, therefore it cannot work.

It "might work if nothing significant happens" but that is just a weasel way of saying it doesn't work.

Now if you're saying you decided to invest in something and you're trying to get an entrypoint and you spot a moment of large deviation from the mean and you use that to influence your operational buying mechanics like how you space out your buys or time them, that I can definitely see. But online you always see these two very different things mixed together.

brockwhittaker · 2 years ago
You're conflating micro and macro price movements. Sure, you can't predict black swan events with technical analysis, but it wouldn't be out of the question to predict short term fluctuations based on a mixture of market psychology and herd thinking.

I don't employ any technical analysis in trading, nor am I a strong advocate, but technical analysis is more about reactionary psychology than about predicting the future. In the most micro sense, the market is dictated by single individuals buying and selling stock, and in the broadest sense, it's a statistical result of millions, or billions of unknowns. Those are two totally different games.

brockwhittaker commented on The collapse of SVB exposes the largest crack in the economy   brooock.com/a/svb-collaps... · Posted by u/brockwhittaker
projektfu · 3 years ago
I noticed that he conflated the safety of a T-note* with the asset price. US Treasuries are AAA-rated super safe guaranteed returns because they're not expected to default or miss a coupon payment, and they'll be redeemed for the full value when they mature. That doesn't mean they don't have market prices that fluctuate.

*T-bills are up to 52 weeks maturity.

brockwhittaker · 3 years ago
Thanks for the note! I'll change the wording in my article WRT bills/notes. :)

With regards to safety, I noted that I think there are two types of safety to note here:

1. Default risk. 2. Asset price volatility.

Ultimately if someone is willing and able to hold to expiry, they aren't subject to #2, but this clearly wasn't the case with SVB and may also be the case with other institutions. I think it lacks nuance to not consider the middle states between the purchase of a bond and the full return of the bond upon expiry.

brockwhittaker commented on Reddit Is Down    · Posted by u/tpmx
brockwhittaker · 3 years ago
Looks like tons of sites are down due to a Fastly outage.
brockwhittaker commented on What makes a champagne vintage great? Ask a deep learning model   wired.com/story/what-make... · Posted by u/lxm
samwillis · 3 years ago
I’m personally convinced the most you should spend on a bottle of Champaign is £10-15 on a bottle of Cremant De Bordeaux rather than Champaign. There will always be occasions when a bottle of Champaign is called for, but you likely have one that someone gave you as gift for that.

Most Cremant is as good as or better than Champaign at 2-3x the price.

We are particularly fond of this one: https://www.ocado.com/products/m-s-cremant-de-bordeaux-blanc...

brockwhittaker · 3 years ago
I haven’t heard much from Bordeaux on crémants, but i can vouch for burgundy and loire for crémants that perform as well as many champagnes, for under $25.
brockwhittaker commented on What makes a champagne vintage great? Ask a deep learning model   wired.com/story/what-make... · Posted by u/lxm
jl6 · 3 years ago
Columbo: How can you tell a good wine from an average wine?

Frenchman: By, uh... the price.

— Columbo S03E02, Any Old Port in a Storm

brockwhittaker · 3 years ago
This is also true historically to some effect. The bordeaux classification of 1855 (which remains in effect) was in large part done on price.
brockwhittaker commented on High property taxes are good   brooock.com/a/property-ta... · Posted by u/brockwhittaker
EddieDante · 3 years ago
brockwhittaker · 3 years ago
yep! i just spun down that service and didn’t bother to use it again, i wanted something simpler.
brockwhittaker commented on High property taxes are good   brooock.com/a/property-ta... · Posted by u/brockwhittaker
EddieDante · 3 years ago
What's the deal with Brock Whittaker's website at brooock.com, anyway? It only seems to have one page: <http://brooock.com/a/property-taxes-are-good>. There's no home page, no list of other posts. Kinda disappointing, really, since I was curious to see what else this guy had to say.
brockwhittaker · 3 years ago
sorry I just made this site this morning to post this article. it's just a simple node-http server! I don't write much :)
brockwhittaker commented on High property taxes are good   brooock.com/a/property-ta... · Posted by u/brockwhittaker
firloop · 3 years ago
This article doesn't provide any reasons why a property owner should want lower property taxes; why would you want to constrain prices and prevent speculation?

I don't own any property myself and am sympathetic to the idea of raising property tax, but many arguments for LVT/raising property taxes don't paint a convincing argument for why property owners should vote against their self interests.

brockwhittaker · 3 years ago
This is totally my personal bias, but I'm unsure that speculation has a positive value in the housing market, and I think governments should largely try to ensure that as many people as possible can afford homes, rather than ensuring that people can profit off the sales of their homes.

In the United States, people have long seen real estate as a path to wealth (unlike Japan, for example), so it's difficult to reason that people's primary homes shouldn't be their escape hatch into retirement (e.g. the dream of someone buying a house in 1980s Palo Alto and selling it in 2022).

brockwhittaker commented on High property taxes are good   brooock.com/a/property-ta... · Posted by u/brockwhittaker
googlryas · 3 years ago
I actually like the concept of a city income tax - you don't get to use all the resources for free just because you take a bus in from across a river.
brockwhittaker · 3 years ago
I'm not sure that's how it works—at least in the case of NYC. The ~4% tax only applies to those with residence within the city's limits. If you live in Westchester however and work in Manhattan, you escape the 4% income tax (but instead pay higher property taxes).

https://tax.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/571/~/i-don...

u/brockwhittaker

KarmaCake day521July 27, 2015View Original