Readit News logoReadit News
benstrumental commented on MTIA v1: Meta’s first-generation AI inference accelerator   ai.facebook.com/blog/meta... · Posted by u/thinxer
bhouston · 3 years ago
Comparing MTIA v1 vs Google Cloud TPU v4:

MTIA v1's specs: The accelerator is fabricated in TSMC 7nm process and runs at 800 MHz, providing 102.4 TOPS at INT8 precision and 51.2 TFLOPS at FP16 precision. It has a thermal design power (TDP) of 25 W. Up to 128 GB of ram LPDDR5.

Googles Cloud TPU v4: 275 teraflops (bf16 or int8), 90/170/192 W. 32 GiB of HBM2 RAM, 1200 GBps. From here: https://cloud.google.com/tpu/docs/system-architecture-tpu-vm...

So it seems that the Google Cloud TPU v4 has an advantage in terms of compute per chip and ram speed, but the Meta one is much more efficient (2x to 4x, it is hard to tell) and has more ram but it is slower ram?

benstrumental · 3 years ago
FWIW, you're comparing a training-specialized chip to an inference-specialized chip. It'd be more apples to apples to compare to TPU v4 lite, but I can't find that chip's details anywhere beyond some mentions in the TPU v4 paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01433
benstrumental commented on Google Photorealistic 3D Tiles and Unreal Engine   nilsbakker.nl/portfolio/3... · Posted by u/stijnbakker
benstrumental · 3 years ago
Very cool! Here's a tutorial from Sebastian Lague on implementing something similar in Unity, which may have served as inspiration for this project:

https://youtu.be/sLqXFF8mlEU

benstrumental commented on Ask HN: Those making $0/month or less on side projects – Show and tell    · Posted by u/code_Whisperer
seangransee · 3 years ago
Oh, absolutely. The initial launch was a disaster because I had no way of dealing with trolls. I've learned a lot since then, and built a bunch of tools that moderators can use to clean up the damage caused by trolls.
benstrumental · 3 years ago
Can you share more about what you learned about moderation?
benstrumental commented on Productivity Blocker   productivityblocker.com... · Posted by u/JohnHendrix
benstrumental · 3 years ago
I want to believe this but I can't find a source, can you share where you've read this?
benstrumental commented on France experiencing worst drought on record   bbc.co.uk/newsround/62456... · Posted by u/ksec
bmitc · 4 years ago
The bad thing is is that it’s too late. From this point forward it’s about adapting where we can.

This is the downside of climate change deniers and the inability of humans to recognize existential threats. Climate change and global warming was never about it just getting hot and that’s it. It is about extreme weather popping up more and more frequently.

In my location, we had a weird winter. The snowfall was above average but it only snowed on like three or four separate days. This summer has seen a heat wave and serious drought. When it rains, again only one like three days all summer, it’s for like 10 minutes. We actually just had a major storm, and it rained violently for about 5-10 minutes. That does little to get the ground soaked again. Even the ferns are dying, which are typically robust.

benstrumental · 4 years ago
> The bad thing is is that it’s too late.

Too late for what exactly? Majority of climate scientists agree the situation is dire, but there are many actions that can be taken to reduce the short-term and long-term impact, via both adaptation and reducing carbon emissions.

benstrumental commented on Ask HN: What's the next big thing that few people are talking about?    · Posted by u/ScottStevenson
philwelch · 4 years ago
I can’t think of any sentiment that I commonly hear that’s as ghoulish as that. As if the moral value of a human life is somehow less than her lifetime net carbon emissions. My only solace is the hope that people who believe that sort of thing will go extinct and be replaced by people whose values are closer to mine.
benstrumental · 4 years ago
We're up against massive loss of biodiversity, loss of habitable space on the planet, and an enormous amount of human suffering and loss of human life due to the current and future effects of climate change. A smaller population will not solve these problems alone, but it will buy us more time to solve them.

FWIW, I'm not trying to promote anything extreme like population control policies, just pointing out that the current trend of population leveling off is generally a good thing.

benstrumental commented on Ask HN: What's the next big thing that few people are talking about?    · Posted by u/ScottStevenson
philwelch · 4 years ago
If we have to introduce population control it will be to increase the population. All developed countries are below replacement.
benstrumental · 4 years ago
Until per capita carbon emissions are below zero, falling population is a good thing.
benstrumental commented on Unity is laying off hundreds of employees   protocol.com/bulletins/un... · Posted by u/pjmlp
jpgvm · 4 years ago
This happens all to often though. Small company comes out swinging to upset the status-quo, essentially poking the bear.

From there it either plays out one of two ways depending on how competent the management of the incumbent is.

1. They underestimate and continually disregard the startup. This generally leads to AMD vs Intel situation. Don't do this.

2. Understand the threat they pose and systematically match all of their advantages, smothering them with investment they can't afford to keep up with. This is essentially what Epic did here and generally what you should always do if you have a dominant market position and can afford it.

Unity is left in a bad situation because accessibility to their engine was it's key draw. A few years ago people also felt it was an easier engine to develop games on but that viewpoint has been shifting back to UE4 as of late because of the difficulty studios have had "actually shipping" Unity based titles, let along long-term maintenance issues. In terms of pure quality Unreal has generally (but not always) been on top and definitely in terms of capability and performance.

Doesn't help that Epic has an enormous cash-cow in the form of Fortnite while Unity has next to no income outside of it's in-game advertising business. They also bet heavily on VR and that hasn't panned out to be as profitable as people thought it would be with the majority of revenue in the VR/AR space being heavily skewed into the enterprise, government and military verticals which aren't where Unity performs well.

benstrumental · 4 years ago
I feel like this happened to Gitlab / GitHub as well. Gitlab was gaining a ton of popularity and momentum with their free private repositories and built-in CI testing infrastructure. Then GitHub swooped in and offered all the same things, taking the wind out of Gitlab's sails.
benstrumental commented on Vectorized and performance-portable Quicksort   opensource.googleblog.com... · Posted by u/slackerIII
janwas · 4 years ago
CPU vendors have recently introduced SVE (Arm) and RVV (RISC-V) and we support those in Highway and thus also vqsort.

It's definitely interesting to discuss std::sort benefitting from such optimizations, but "very easy" seems rather optimistic.

benstrumental · 4 years ago
Do you expect these optimizations making their way into std::sort eventually?

u/benstrumental

KarmaCake day265November 6, 2015View Original