Readit News logoReadit News
batchfy commented on Next.js: The "Versatile" React Framework That Can't Handle Dynamic Routes   github.com/vercel/next.js... · Posted by u/batchfy
antisol · 3 months ago
Interesting, thanks for sharing.

...but did you notice how the entire scenario presented in this article is predicated on the person who made their suggestion actually getting a response?

"I'm sorry, but hotdogs don't really fit our sushi menu, and while you may not care for unagi, we picked it for a reason. But thanks for the suggestions!"

Totally reasonable response. Polite. Reasonable explanation. 10/10 response. Totally unreasonable to then start insisting that hot dogs be added.

The example scenario isn't "person asks the waiter for a hot dog; waiter just keeps walking past them, blanking them as if they don't even exist".

I would be curious to know why OP chose to post this today, 3 weeks after they said they were working on it. That's an interesting detail.

batchfy · 3 months ago
The reason is that I don't think it's a technical issue — in other words, it's the managers, not the engineers, who decide the priority here. Therefore, the right place to try to expedite this is somewhere more influential, like HN or Twitter, not GitHub.

I can anticipate that this won't be resolved for at least 3 months. Just be aware this issue has been around for over 2 years, and the last time someone promised to fix it was 6 months ago. Let's see.

batchfy commented on Next.js: The "Versatile" React Framework That Can't Handle Dynamic Routes   github.com/vercel/next.js... · Posted by u/batchfy
batchfy · 3 months ago
Next.js claims to be a versatile React framework, yet it doesn’t support something as fundamental as dynamic routing in a single-page app. The issue was raised by one of their own developers—two years ago—and it's still unresolved. I genuinely don’t understand the hype. Everyone seems to be using Next.js, and the internet is flooded with tutorials like it’s the holy grail of React frameworks.

u/batchfy

KarmaCake day5December 4, 2023
About
https://batchfy.com
View Original