Readit News logoReadit News
adi_kurian commented on TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues   cnn.com/2026/01/26/tech/t... · Posted by u/kotaKat
superkuh · 13 days ago
This is untrue. Take it from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK519704/table/ch3.t39/ "Impact of the DSM-IV to DSM-5 Changes on the National Survey on Drug Use and Health [Internet]." In 5 they actually moved it to the 'Substance-Related and Addictive Disorders' because it was grandfathered into it's own class and really fit nowhere else in the reorganization. It shouldn't be there either but it was too late.

You've prescribed some outcomes: I am not saying you have not personally observed these things. I am saying they are not due to addiction and that using comparisons to addictive drugs and addiction implies that people have no volition when reading things or watching things on screens instead of, say, watching them in their environment directly. That's a very dangerous claim. If you think that it's okay to claim screens can make you do things and need to be regulated like addictive drugs, we are definitely not having the same conversation. You're advocating that text and video need to be regulated by government use of force and that's really dangerous and wrong.

I agree that the corporations pushing these propaganda machines are a huge problem. But it's not one involving addiction.

adi_kurian · 12 days ago
The DSM-5 work group chair said the move was based on brain imaging showing gambling activates reward systems like drugs do [1]. That's not grandfathering, that's reclassification based on neuroscience. Your source is a comparison table of criteria, not a rationale for the reclassification.

The WHO recognized gaming disorder in 2019. The field is expanding. But even if it never formally recognizes social media addiction—call it whatever you want.

I'm assuming good faith, though you are putting words in my mouth. I said social media is a cheap, shitty, and extremely addictive drug. I'm happy to rephrase that to 'cheap, shitty, and extremely compulsive in ways that damage health, relationships, attention and has immensely negative effects for society as a whole.' I never once mentioned government regulation, you can reread my comments.

My opinion is that people should view it as lame and self regulate. I do not think it is likely to happen.

[1] https://www.icrg.org/blog/the-evolving-definition-of-patholo...

adi_kurian commented on UK Government’s ‘AI Skills Hub’ was delivered by PwC for £4.1M   mahadk.com/posts/ai-skill... · Posted by u/JustSkyfall
adi_kurian · 13 days ago
The only way this is defensible is if they contracted out thousands of hours of custom content. Which from a quick scan they might have. If not, this is, at best, a remarkably poor outcome for the price paid.
adi_kurian commented on TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues   cnn.com/2026/01/26/tech/t... · Posted by u/kotaKat
superkuh · 13 days ago
Gambling disorder was introduced in DSM 3 (1980) before much was known about human neurobiology under 'impulse control disorder not elsewhere classified'. Back then they even thought dopamine was a 'pleasure' chemical. And we now know it's about wanting, not liking. You may be mixing it up when it was reclassified as the DSM 4 (not 5!) did a big reorganization.

Kent Berridges' lab review articles are a great place to start to understand addiction, wanting, and liking and how they are different. But mostly importantly, how addiction works so you can see how chemical addictive substances are vastly different. https://sites.lsa.umich.edu/berridge-lab/selected-review-art...

Edit: and re: "porn disorder/gaming disorder/behavioral impulse disorders to 'screens' in general" and the behavior of the ICD re: china, see the widely cited Nichole Prause' work https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=yySl87AAAAAJ&hl=en

adi_kurian · 13 days ago
I don't follow. DSM-5 (2013) moved gambling into 'Substance-Related and Addictive Disorders.' What specifically are you saying happened in DSM-4?

Thanks for sharing. I'll read Berridge.

The distinction you're drawing is mechanistic. I'm not submitting a paper to a journal. Kids are scrolling until 3am, teen mental health is cratering, boomers are getting radicalized by bot farms, and democracy is being sold for pennies on the dollar. If your response is 'technically not addiction,' we're not having the same conversation.

adi_kurian commented on TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues   cnn.com/2026/01/26/tech/t... · Posted by u/kotaKat
superkuh · 14 days ago
False. Gambling disorder exists, but it is grandfathered in. It wouldn't be accepted today. Porn addiction has no entry in the DSMV or ICD10, it is purely a made up concept advanced by for-profit companies looking to exploit people (and authoritarian governments looking to control). The same kind of groups that used to run camps to "fix" gay people.

If you think a chemical directly manipulating the biochemistry of incentive salience, making you want something regardless of it's valance, is the same as eventually liking something you watch and hear that's actually rewarding, yes, there's not much conversation to be had. Lay interpretations of this field are not very useful.

adi_kurian · 14 days ago
Fair enough, I don't have any formal credentials in this field. Could you clarify a few things:

My understanding is gambling disorder was promoted in the DSM-5 in 2013. When was it grandfathered?

The WHO recognized gaming disorder in 2019. Are they captured as well?

Where should I look for a non-lay interpretation?

adi_kurian commented on TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues   cnn.com/2026/01/26/tech/t... · Posted by u/kotaKat
superkuh · 15 days ago
As much as I dislike TikTok, I dislike this dangerous mischaracterization even more. If you start propagating the meme that screens are like chemically addictive drugs the governments of the world will feel emboldened to use violence force to 'regulate' them. Screens are not drugs. They do not directly manipulate the biochemistry of incentive salience regardless of valence of perceived stimuli. They just provide enjoyable stimuli. It is VASTLY different. Conflating them is playing in to the hands of the authoritarians.
adi_kurian · 14 days ago
Gambling doesn't directly manipulate biochemistry either. Neither does porn. Both are recognized as addictive. If you think reading Dostoevsky is in the same realm as doom scrolling algorithmically tailored Instagram reels because they're both "enjoyable stimuli," there's not much of a conversation to be had.

This is a thread about government-aligned owners censoring content on a platform the government forced a sale of. The authoritarians already have the thing.

adi_kurian commented on TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues   cnn.com/2026/01/26/tech/t... · Posted by u/kotaKat
drcongo · 15 days ago
Why on earth are grownups using TikTok anyway?
adi_kurian · 15 days ago
Hopefully people will start seeing social media as what it is: a cheap, shitty, and extremely addictive drug. I am confident that in time, the opposite opinion will be viewed as insane.
adi_kurian commented on Show HN: Whosthere: A LAN discovery tool with a modern TUI, written in Go   github.com/ramonvermeulen... · Posted by u/rvermeulen98
adi_kurian · 18 days ago
Looks great. Discovery.app is also useful if you’re mostly dealing with Apple / Bonjour-heavy networks. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/discovery-dns-sd-browser/id138...
adi_kurian commented on Text-based web browsers   cssence.com/2026/text-bas... · Posted by u/pabs3
thereWasAFish · a month ago
> Main developer is blind, so accessibility has priority;

Never thought about it before, but doing development work as a blind person sounds extremely impressive.

Vision is just such a fast and easy way to acquire information. Without it, it seems quite difficult to check your existing code, easily read prior documentation, take notes, and just various other conveniences that one take for granted.

I'm sure there are various tools and methods to ameliorate these problems, but still.

adi_kurian · a month ago
When I think about much of what blind people are able to achieve across domains, it's extremely impressive.
adi_kurian commented on The struggle of resizing windows on macOS Tahoe   noheger.at/blog/2026/01/1... · Posted by u/happosai
seec · a month ago
Agreed. The problem is that native window management is pretty bad in macOS. And the 3rd party tools solving the problem aren't that great on top of being expensive sometimes.

Apple could fix it, but instead they made overlapping windows for iPadOS, which is even dumber considering the smaller display area.

I think it doesn't matter what they do; part of their clientele is fully captive, another part is only there for the status, and the last part is just using it rudimentally, so anything is OK.

adi_kurian · a month ago
I think there are some pretty awesome third party tools. I am incredibly happy with my setup.

BetterTouchTool + Alt Tab + TaskBar is my setup.

All apps used with any frequency mapped to keyboard shortcuts, mostly using right side CMD key. CMD C Chrome, CMD V VS Code, CMD T Terminal, CMD F Figma, CMD S Slack, CMD E Edge, CMD OPT A Activity MTR, CMD OPT CTRL F Firefox and not that many more.

And then for windows, it's left side CMD OPT ENTER maximize, CMD OPT LEFT left screen, etc etc. And then others for quadrants. If I need to multiwindow, it's rarely more than 3 things, and most of the time it's just 2.

Having alt tab mean cmd tab is windows style is huge. Many of these things aren't directly related to window management but I find myself not thinking about it at all, when I used to think about it all the time with Macs.

iOS on iPad has split screen mode now. It's pretty decent. Wouldn't defend it tho.

adi_kurian commented on Attention Is Bayesian Inference   medium.com/@vishalmisra/a... · Posted by u/samwillis
iamjs · a month ago
It's so disappointing that this has become a meme. Lot's of people write with em-dashes. If you want to criticize the _writing_, then do so.
adi_kurian · a month ago
Yep. Love em dashes. It's a stupid tell.

A better tell IMO is an unnatural huge amount of editorialized h2s / h3s. Often they are overly lofty.

u/adi_kurian

KarmaCake day37April 18, 2024View Original