Readit News logoReadit News
Yeroc commented on Donating the Model Context Protocol and establishing the Agentic AI Foundation   anthropic.com/news/donati... · Posted by u/meetpateltech
theturtletalks · 13 days ago
Easy. Just tell the LLM to use the Linear CLI or hit their API directly. I’m only half-joking. Older models were terrible at doing that reliably, which is exactly why we created MCP.

Our SaaS has a built-in AI assistant that only performs actions for the user through our GraphQL API. We wrapped the API in simple MCP tools that give the model clean introspection and let us inject the user’s authenticated session cookie directly. The LLM never deals with login, tokens, or permissions. It can just act with the full rights of the logged-in user.

MCP still has value today, especially with models that can easily call tools but can’t stick to prompt. From what I’ve seen in Claude’s roadmap, the future may shift toward loading “skills” that describe exactly how to call a GraphQL API (in my case), then letting the model write the code itself. That sounds good on paper, but an LLM generating and running API code on the fly is less consistent and more error-prone than calling pre-built tools.

Yeroc · 13 days ago
Easy if you ignore the security aspects. You want to hand over your tokens to your LLM so it can script up a tool that can access it? The value I see in MCP is that you can give an LLM access to services via socket without giving it access to the tokens/credentials required to access said service. It provides at least one level of security that way.
Yeroc commented on Google Antigravity   antigravity.google/... · Posted by u/Fysi
cube2222 · a month ago
See my setup detailed in another sibling comment of yours, jj is just a small part of it, and you can probably get that with git too.

I’m already at full mental capacity planning and reviewing the work of two agents (one foreground which almost never asks for approval, and one background which never asks for approval).

I don’t really need the ability to juggle more of them, and noticing their messages is not a bottleneck for me, while I’m happy with the customizability and adaptability of my raw’er workflow.

Maybe if they’re as slow as codex…

Yeroc · a month ago
Fair enough. I use git worktrees (with a script that creates the git branch, worktree and opens a new vs code workspace). You're right, managing more than about two active sessions at once is probably the limit though I'm somewhat hopeful that better tooling similar to the Agent Manager window here would allow me to scale a bit past that especially if some of those sessions are more design explorations.
Yeroc commented on Google Antigravity   antigravity.google/... · Posted by u/Fysi
20k · a month ago
I have absolutely 0 idea why any developer would rely on any IDE produced by google. It'll be canned within 5 years max, with 3-4 seeming like a reasonable estimate of the lifespan of the product

I've been using my current IDE for 17 years, and plan to continue using it for at least another 15

Yeroc · a month ago
It won't matter. The core ideas of an Agent Manager view will be copied and improved by others in many project in the future.
Yeroc commented on Google Antigravity   antigravity.google/... · Posted by u/Fysi
msci100 · a month ago
So this is Google's version of Windsurf's Wave 10 before the whole team got poached? https://windsurf.com/blog/windsurf-wave-10-browser

Trying to understand how this is anything net new in the space.

Yeroc · a month ago
I haven't used Windsurf (been using Claude Code and similar). Does it provide an Agent Manager window/view? This to me looks more useful to me than the browser integration piece.
Yeroc commented on Google Antigravity   antigravity.google/... · Posted by u/Fysi
cube2222 · a month ago
I'll be honest - this doesn't look half-bad.

It really seems like it's just standardizing into a first-class UI what a lot of people have already been doing.

I don't think I'm the target for this - I already use Claude Code with jj workspaces and a mostly design-doc first workflow, and I don't see why I would switch to this, but I think this could be quite useful for people who don't want to dive in so deep and combine raw tooling themselves.

Yeroc · a month ago
The Agent Manager view providing a unified view of all active agents and allowing you to immediately respond to any approval requests or followup questions looks very useful regardless of which VCS you're using under the covers. Am I missing something here that jj does?
Yeroc commented on Google Antigravity   antigravity.google/... · Posted by u/Fysi
catigula · a month ago
Which is a bit odd given that Claude code extension in VSCode is by far the best agent integration into a codebase that I know of.
Yeroc · a month ago
The Claude Code extension on VS Code does very little (too little in my opinion). The integration level with agentic functionality provided by Antigravity goes much deeper in my 20 minutes or so of playing with it. The biggest value pieces I see is: Agent Manager window which provides a unified view of all my agents running across all my workspaces (!) where I can quickly approve or respond to followup questions and quickly brings me to the code in context for each agent, additionally, I can select a piece of code and comment on it inline and that comment gets sent to the correct, active agent. These two things alone are items which I have been looking for... Too bad I only have approval to use Claude Code at work. This looks promising.
Yeroc commented on Oracle has adopted BOOLEAN in 23ai and PostgreSQL had it forever   hexacluster.ai/blog/postg... · Posted by u/avi_vallarapu
animitronix · 2 months ago
I'm other news, Oracle is hot garbage and always will be.
Yeroc · 2 months ago
My experience has been the opposite. Oracle (the database) is actually a really solid product for the most part. Oracle (the company) is a different story. My eyes were really opened to some of the technical shortcomings in Postgres when we migrated from Oracle to Postgres a few years ago at $DAYJOB. Things like: a) global temp tables (there's an open source extension we had to use to fake this out), b) RLS (exists in PG but most functions that you might need to build on top perform badly), c) crashes in PG take out the whole database and a host of other smaller items. I'm not saying it wasn't worth it, but I wouldn't pretend Postgres is the best database either.
Yeroc commented on Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres   topicpartition.io/blog/po... · Posted by u/enether
fud101 · 2 months ago
When someone says just use Postgres, are they using the same instance for their data as well for the queue?
Yeroc · 2 months ago
You would typically want to use the same database instance for your queue as long as you can get away with it because then transaction handling is trivial. As soon as you move the queue somewhere else you need to carefully think about how you'll deal with transactionality.
Yeroc commented on I've been loving Claude Code on the web   ben.page/claude-code-web... · Posted by u/speckx
submeta · 2 months ago
You can instruct Claude Code to commit in your name. Tell it in the CLAUDE.md file. Or add via `# Commit as xyz` and it will memorize.
Yeroc · 2 months ago
Also add `"includeCoAuthoredBy": false` to your `settings.json` file (you may also need to reinforce this in your commit prompt YMMV).
Yeroc commented on Traffic Light Protocol   first.org/tlp/... · Posted by u/eXpl0it3r
jagged-chisel · 2 months ago
Emergency vehicles have devices that announce their presence to get traffic lights to change in their favor. “Kids being late to class” is not on the order of importance to create a complex scheme to change traffic lights based on strobe lights from a bus.

Sounds like urban legend.

Yeroc · 2 months ago
We definitely have this system in place in some cities in Canada, primarily for express bus routes.

u/Yeroc

KarmaCake day491February 26, 2009View Original