Readit News logoReadit News
TheWas7ed commented on Building SQLite with a small swarm   kiankyars.github.io/machi... · Posted by u/kyars
khazhoux · a month ago
I'm a heavy Cursor user (not yet on Claude) and I see a big disconnect between my own experience and posts like this.

* After a long vibe-coding session, I have to spend an inordinate amount of time cleaning up what Cursor generated. Any given page of code will be just fine on its own, but the overall design (unless I'm extremely specific in what I tell Cursor to do) will invariably be a mess of scattered control, grafted-on logic, and just overall poor design. This is despite me using Plan mode extensively, and instructing it to not create duplicate code, etc.

* I keep seeing metrics of 10s and 100s of thousands of LOC (sometimes even millions), without the authors ever recognizing that a gigantic LOC is probably indicative of terrible heisenbuggy code. I'd find it much more convincing if this post said it generated a 3K SQLite implementation, and not 19K.

Wondering if I'm just lagging in my prompting skills or what. To be clear, I'm very bullish on AI coding, but I do feel people are getting just a bit ahead of themselves in how they report success.

TheWas7ed · a month ago
This has been my experience also, but i've been using everything (Claude code, open code, copilot, etc...) It's impressive when I ask it to do something I don't know how like some python apps, but when it's in my stack I have to constantly stop it mid processing and ask it to fix something. I'm still validanting the plan and rewriting a lot of the code because the quality just is not there yet.

And for the most part I use either opus or sonnet, but for planning sometimes I switch to chatgpt since I think claude is too blunt and does not ask enough questions. I also have local setups with OLlama and have tried for personal projects some kimi models. The results are the same for all, but again claude models are slighly better.

TheWas7ed commented on Management as AI superpower: Thriving in a world of agentic AI   oneusefulthing.org/p/mana... · Posted by u/swolpers
edmundsauto · a month ago
> Being able to whip your army of AI employees 3% better than your competitor doesn’t (usually) give any lasting advantage.

What do you mean by “better”? The advantage is speed. Shipping a feature in 1 week instead of 1 month is a tremendous advantage

TheWas7ed · a month ago
How is it an advantage is everyone has access to the same tool? Maybe 1 week is just the new baseline.

u/TheWas7ed

KarmaCake day1January 2, 2025View Original