Readit News logoReadit News
TheGRS commented on AWS CEO says replacing junior devs with AI is 'one of the dumbest ideas'   finalroundai.com/blog/aws... · Posted by u/birdculture
alexgotoi · a day ago
The thing people miss in these “replace juniors with AI” takes is that juniors were never mainly about cheap hands on keyboards. They’re the only people in the org who are still allowed to ask “dumb” questions without losing face, and those questions are often the only signal you get that your abstractions are nonsense.

What AI does is remove a bunch of the humiliating, boring parts of being junior: hunting for the right API by cargo-culting Stack Overflow, grinding through boilerplate, getting stuck for hours on a missing import. If a half-decent model can collapse that search space for them, you get to spend more of their ramp time on “here’s how our system actually fits together” instead of “here’s how for-loops work in our house style”.

If you take that setup and then decide “cool, now we don’t need juniors at all”, you’re basically saying you want a company with no memory and no farm system – just an ever-shrinking ring of seniors arguing about strategy while no one actually grows into them.

Always love to include a good AI x work thread in my https://hackernewsai.com/ newsletter.

TheGRS · a day ago
I don't agree that this is the central value juniors provide. Its a nice tertiary value, but not why one hires them. I think the value is the later part of farming for new talent and just growing your team.

I still think the central issue is the economy. There are more seniors available to fill roles, so filling out junior roles is less desirable. And perhaps "replacing juniors with AI" is just the industry's way of clumsily saving face.

TheGRS commented on Homeschooling hits record numbers   reason.com/2025/11/19/hom... · Posted by u/bilsbie
OneLeggedCat · a month ago
In the rural areas that I've lived in, it's mostly about a strong desire to supplant science and history with religious ideas and principles.
TheGRS · a month ago
That has been the case for a long time, and I guess something about the current generation of parents has gotten them to act more on it. My dad came from a very religious family and they all did private religious schools for their early grade school years. Then they went to public for high school years.

If I had to guess, its maybe something about the demise of church life that has gotten religious parents to just pull back entirely. It wasn't that uncommon for public schools to make nods toward Christian ideals/lifestyles before like the 90s, but now that stuff just doesn't happen anymore.

TheGRS commented on The treasury is expanding the Patriot Act to attack Bitcoin self custody   tftc.io/treasury-iexpandi... · Posted by u/bilsbie
1oooqooq · 3 months ago
your father wasn't a tech guy. he was a cop.
TheGRS · 3 months ago
I'd disagree, they're not mutually exclusive.
TheGRS commented on The treasury is expanding the Patriot Act to attack Bitcoin self custody   tftc.io/treasury-iexpandi... · Posted by u/bilsbie
codethief · 3 months ago
> Whereas I believe a right to privacy in your tools and communication is essential, he believes they infringe on the government's ability to catch criminals.

Honestly, if I had spent 30 years of my life trying to catch criminals, I would probably believe the same. Just like dermatologists telling everyone to put on sunscreen at all times (because they see skin cancer cases on the daily), criminal prosecutors often live in a bubble, where crime happens all the time and everywhere, and you can never have enough sophisticated tools to catch the perpetrators. They completely forget that normal life away from crime exists, too.

TheGRS · 3 months ago
Anyone in law enforcement for long enough, and I'd probably say something like 5-10 years on the beat, is enough to make many apathetic to rights and dignities. A sad reality unfortunately. Its the same vein of salespeople who get so caught-up in the hustle they that see everyone and every relationship as a potential transaction. And if I'm being introspective, my own flaw of seeing most systems/laws/social contracts as problems that can be solved with tinkering (they can't).
TheGRS commented on The treasury is expanding the Patriot Act to attack Bitcoin self custody   tftc.io/treasury-iexpandi... · Posted by u/bilsbie
dataflow · 3 months ago
I think the crucial bit you're missing is that the fundamental disagreement boils down to whether a properly-signed-and-executed warrant ought to be sufficient for the government to get its hands on evidence or otherwise do what it needs to do to deliver justice.

To you, he seems to believe Yes, and to him, I think you seem to believe No. Historically, the answer has been Yes, and crypto has fundamentally changed that. I think crystallizing exactly why you believe the right answer is No is essential, otherwise you're just not going to convince people on that side -- in their mind, I think, you're demanding more rights than you historically had, and at the cost of protecting the rest of the population.

TheGRS · 3 months ago
I'd go a little further to say that he believes the government has the authority to do what it needs to do to catch criminals/terrorists/bad guys. He's much more concerned over whether a method is technically legal than whether or not the government should do said method. Whether its a properly signed warrant is kind of immaterial when there are various ways to get around that requirement legally and with precedent.
TheGRS commented on The treasury is expanding the Patriot Act to attack Bitcoin self custody   tftc.io/treasury-iexpandi... · Posted by u/bilsbie
TheGRS · 3 months ago
I have deep disagreements with my father on this subject. He worked as a federal agent for 30 years, mostly in digital forensics. He does not believe in the right to privacy in any of the same ways I do. Whereas I believe a right to privacy in your tools and communication is essential, he believes they infringe on the government's ability to catch criminals. Classic justification of "if you're not a bad guy, what do you have to hide?"

I just thought this was worth sharing, my dad was a tech guy (though not much of a programmer), the folks on HackerNews and related sites mostly have a privacy-first worldview. But not everyone shares this view, especially those who work in or around law enforcement. Civilians who believe in the right to privacy must stand their ground in the face of this.

TheGRS commented on Tao on “blue team” vs. “red team” LLMs   mathstodon.xyz/@tao/11491... · Posted by u/qsort
TheGRS · 5 months ago
After using agentic models and workflows recently, I think these agents belong in both roles. Even more than that, they should be involved in the management tasks too. The developer becomes more of an overseer. You're overseeing the planning of a task - writing prompts, distilling the scope of the task down. You're overseeing writing the tests. And you're overseeing writing out the code. Its a ton of reviewing, but I've always felt more in control as a red team type myself making sure things don't break.
TheGRS commented on Meta announces Oakley smart glasses   theverge.com/news/690133/... · Posted by u/jmsflknr
smilespray · 6 months ago
Who's worse? Palantir?
TheGRS · 6 months ago
The worst offender of giving my secrets away is still myself sadly.
TheGRS commented on Meta announces Oakley smart glasses   theverge.com/news/690133/... · Posted by u/jmsflknr
deadbabe · 6 months ago
I have perfect vision I have no interest in wearing fake glasses all day.

And mobile phones aren’t going anywhere because mobile computing has peaked: there are no use cases that require a device with a different form factor, it’s just a matter of lifestyle preference.

If we’re abandoning screen based devices, I’d rather have a small 2000s style flip phone with all the latest tech and LLM features built in, than something like glasses, which clash too much with fashion choices. Bonus if the battery life is insane.

TheGRS · 6 months ago
I haven't seen a lot of progress on it, but I would definitely jump on whatever device lets me not have this chunky block in my pocket all the time. The concept I saw years ago was like a slap bracelet that you could remove from your wrist and unwrap into a tablet form-factor.
TheGRS commented on Congestion pricing in Manhattan is a predictable success   economist.com/united-stat... · Posted by u/edward
newyankee · 6 months ago
Another predictable success would be converting entirety of NYC into a driverless car zone, but we are probably not ready for the repercussions as a society
TheGRS · 6 months ago
Entirety seems a little extreme. Maybe gradually they could get there as society and technology changes. But yes changing large areas to pedestrian-only seems totally doable to me in NYC.

u/TheGRS

KarmaCake day1427February 24, 2015View Original