Readit News logoReadit News
Tanjreeve commented on The time bomb in the tax code that's fueling mass tech layoffs   qz.com/tech-layoffs-tax-c... · Posted by u/booleanbetrayal
simoncion · 3 months ago
> Most programmers do approximately zero work that is R&D.

So, what you're saying is one or more of the following:

1) The work of most programmers should not be considered R&D, and shouldn't be covered by tax schemes intended for R&D.

2) Most "software IP" in the industry is not the result of R&D.

3) You've rarely been involved in the sale of non-R&D "software IP". (Do recall that your original statement was "As anyone that has ever sold software IP knows, most of the value is vested in the person that wrote the code, not the code itself.")

Tanjreeve · 3 months ago
The first two statements would upset a lot of people but I think you'd find theyre arguably true. Most software products are various flavours of configuration. Unless you're genuinely leveraging some novel algorithm/hardware etc it's very hard to argue it's R&D if it's just branding on a collected bag of software various OSS/commercial companies developed. Claiming all software is R&D because you leverage OSS and put a known algorithm on top of some components would be like a supermarket claiming to be a research company because they have a different mix of products + customer experience to their rivals.

I think the third statement is a bit personal so will leave that alone.

Tanjreeve commented on Yes-rs: A fast, memory-safe rewrite of the classic Unix yes command   github.com/jedisct1/yes-r... · Posted by u/ericdiao
rebolek · 3 months ago
Right, corporations should be able to prosecute people who ruin their training data with jokes and nonsense!
Tanjreeve · 3 months ago
It's the only logical next step after multi billion dollar corporations need to be provided with other peoples stuff for free to make their business models viable in the name of the free market.
Tanjreeve commented on AI is "destroying" the entry-level jobs that Generation Z needs   fortune.com/2025/05/25/ai... · Posted by u/01-_-
Tanjreeve · 3 months ago
The only actual hard data cited in this article is the opposite conclusion to the headline.

>Still, language-learning app Duolingo and fintech app Klarna have recently walked back aggressive stances on replacing humans with AI.

>Some studies have also shown AI isn’t panning out as much as hoped, so far. An IBM survey found that 3 in 4 AI initiatives fail to deliver their promised ROI. And a National Bureau of Economic Research study of workers in AI-exposed industries found that the technology had next to no impact on earnings or hours worked.

The data in favour of the articles conclusion is "some linkedin influencer said so" and

>But Indeed’s findings show that “for about two-thirds of all jobs, 50% or more of those skills are things that today’s generative AI can do reasonably well, or very well.”

And if you read THAT article that's linking it's some MBAs speculating again at a conference. Which isn't inherently a bad thing not everything in the world can or should be quantified in a clear statistical conclusion. But appropriating the language and implying it and then the source is "some ceo dudebro said so" should be treated with at least some dubiousness at this point when a lot more of job market trends can be explained far less nebulously by a generalised slowdown in hiring and economic shocks. If I'm being less generous I can say this is yet another example of the linkedin media complex trying to rewrite reality again.

Tanjreeve commented on In S3 simplicity is table stakes   allthingsdistributed.com/... · Posted by u/riv991
myflash13 · 5 months ago
I have a feeling that economies of scale have a point of diminishing returns. At what point does it become more costly and complicated to store your data on S3 versus just maintaining a server with RAID disks somewhere?

S3 is an engineering marvel, but it's an insanely complicated backend architecture just to store some files.

Tanjreeve · 5 months ago
Probably never. The complexity is borne by Amazon. Even before any of the development begins if you want a RAID setup with some sort of decent availability you've already multiplied your server costs by the number of replicas you'd need. It's a Sisyphean task that also has little value for most people.

Much like twitter it's conceptually simple but it's a hard problem to solve at any scale beyond a toy.

Tanjreeve commented on DeepGEMM: clean and efficient FP8 GEMM kernels with fine-grained scaling   github.com/deepseek-ai/De... · Posted by u/mfiguiere
niemandhier · 6 months ago
I keep wondering why there even are undocumented instruction.

Wouldn’t it make sense to provide these to the user? Even if they might not be perfectly reliable.

This stuff must be documented internally, why not just release it?

Security by obscurity does not work: Your competitor reverse engineer everything you do anyways.

Tanjreeve · 6 months ago
Probably same reason as anything you work on might have undocumented stuff. Combo of lack of time and/or not wanting to imply support for unstable/experimental features. If you're only screwing over the team on the next desk or whatever it's a lot easier to change things.
Tanjreeve commented on MongoDB acquires Voyage AI   investors.mongodb.com/new... · Posted by u/marc__1
ecshafer · 6 months ago
I have seen a few rather large, production mongodb deployments. I don't understand how so many people chose it as their basis of their applications. There are a not-negligible amount of mongodb deployments I have seen that basically treat mongodb as a memory dump, where they then scan from some key and hope for the best. I have never seen a mongodb solution where I thought that it was better than if they just chose any sql server.

SQL or rather just some schema based database has a ton of advantages. Besides speed, there is a huge benefit for developers to be able to look at a schema and see how the relationships in the data work. Mongodb usually involves looking at a de facto schema, but with fewer guarantees on types relations or existence, then trawling code for how its used.

Tanjreeve · 6 months ago
If you're scared of SQL/have a massive operations team to throw infrastructure problems over the fence then that would be a positive to push all complexity into the application code as you aren't the one paying that cost.
Tanjreeve commented on MongoDB acquires Voyage AI   investors.mongodb.com/new... · Posted by u/marc__1
redwood · 6 months ago
MongoDB has had ACID transactions for many years. I encourage folks to at least read up on the topic they are claiming to have expertise in
Tanjreeve · 6 months ago
Reputation matters. If someone comes to market with a shoddy product or missing features/slideware then it's a self created problem that people don't check the product release logs every week for the next few years waiting for them rectifying it. And even once there is an announcement people are perfectly entitled to have scepticism that it isn't a smoke and mirrors feature and not spend hours doing their own due diligence. Again self created problem.
Tanjreeve commented on It is no longer safe to move our governments and societies to US clouds   berthub.eu/articles/posts... · Posted by u/Sami_Lehtinen
bbqfog · 6 months ago
MSM are publishing bad things, freedom of speech is important and I don't think we need to "control" anything (child porn is illegal by any measure, it's an abuse issue, not a speech issue). I can't even imagine how you jumped to that conclusion. Just because I don't agree with something, it doesn't mean I'm ok with eliminating it through fascism.
Tanjreeve · 6 months ago
You can't claim to support total free speech and also accept that there is content that is bad for society that needs to be controlled. The moment you accept the latter premise you then need to build enforcement mechanisms and have debates that boil down to political preferences on what constitutes bad. I think it's kind of a navel gazing gesture to just hand wave at "I support the good free speech' and wash your hands of any of the coercion/"fascism" that comes with how the sausage is made.
Tanjreeve commented on It is no longer safe to move our governments and societies to US clouds   berthub.eu/articles/posts... · Posted by u/Sami_Lehtinen
bbqfog · 6 months ago
I think you may have replied to the wrong comment or this is a very drastic non sequitur.
Tanjreeve · 6 months ago
Either one would agree that if the "MSM" were publishing bad things then there's a need to control it. At which point the question is why is a social media website different. Or you'd say that child porn and other bad things being published on websites are fine and there's no need to control things. At which point you'd be pretty wildly out of step with the majority of the population.
Tanjreeve commented on It is no longer safe to move our governments and societies to US clouds   berthub.eu/articles/posts... · Posted by u/Sami_Lehtinen
bbqfog · 6 months ago
There are calls for terrorism and genocide coming daily from the MSM in Europe and the US.
Tanjreeve · 6 months ago
You'd agree that there are limits to free speech then?

u/Tanjreeve

KarmaCake day189October 11, 2021View Original