Readit News logoReadit News
Shebanator commented on "Remove mentions of XSLT from the html spec"   github.com/whatwg/html/pu... · Posted by u/troupo
kg · 22 days ago
Former Mozilla and Google (Chrome team specifically) dev here. The way I see what you're saying is: Representatives from Chrome/Blink, Safari/Webkit, and Firefox/Gecko are all supportive of removing XSLT from the web platform, regardless of whether it's still being used. It's okay because someone from Mozilla brought it up.

Out of those three projects, two are notoriously under-resourced, and one is notorious for constantly ramming through new features at a pace the other two projects can't or won't keep up with.

Why wouldn't the overworked/underresourced Safari and Firefox people want an excuse to have less work to do?

This appeal to authority doesn't hold water for me because the important question is not 'do people with specific priorities think this is a good idea' but instead 'will this idea negatively impact the web platform and its billions of users'. Out of those billions of users it's quite possible a sizable number of them rely on XSLT, and in my reading around this issue I haven't seen concrete data supporting that nobody uses XSLT. If nobody really used it there wouldn't be a need for that polyfill.

Fundamentally the question that should be asked here is: Billions of people use the web every day, which means they're relying on technologies like HTML, CSS, XML, XSLT, etc. Are we okay with breaking something that 0.1% of users rely on? If we are, okay, but who's going to tell that 0.1% of a billion people that they don't matter?

The argument I've seen made is that Google doesn't have the resources (somehow) to maintain XSLT support. One of the googlers argued that new emerging web APIs are more popular, and thus more deserving of resources. So what we've created is a zero-sum game where any new feature added to the platform requires the removal of an existing feature. Where does that game end? Will we eventually remove ARIA and/or screen reader support because it's not used by enough people?

I think all three browser vendors have a duty to their users to support them to the best of their ability, and Google has the financial and human resources to support users of XSLT and is choosing not to.

Shebanator · 22 days ago
So the Safari developers are overworked/under-resourced, but Google somehow should have infinite resources to maintain things forever? Apple is a much bigger company than Google these days, so why shouldn't they also have these infinite resources? Oh, right, its because fundamentally they don't value their web browser as much as they should. But you give them a pass.
Shebanator commented on I've been using Claude Code for a couple of days   twitter.com/Steve_Yegge/s... · Posted by u/tosh
ramblerman · 6 months ago
lol - I thought the same, but the charitable take after looking at the user's profile is that he is a journalist, and not tech savvy.

So I understand his request as more along the lines of, can you explain this in a way that I understand it. For which summarization is the wrong phrasing.

ie.. It seems trivial on hacker news, but that post would be pure giberish for most of our parents.

Shebanator · 6 months ago
That's steve yegge (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Yegge) you are talking about. Kids these days, sheesh, they think lisp is a speech impediment.... /s

Deleted Comment

Shebanator commented on VPN by Google One security assessment   research.nccgroup.com/202... · Posted by u/campuscodi
eternalban · 3 years ago
You can't judge Apple's views based on this matter in the short term. Apple has strategic investments in China and can't just tell CPC to go pound sand.

However, if Apple still is critically dependent on China in say 5 years, then it would be fair to look at the corporate response to Chinese demands and reach conclusions. If they truly care about privacy and the rest of it, they should be well into their transition plans to other locations about now. And industry expert would be able to tell if the effort, e.g. to use India instead, failed due to an insincere effort on the part of Apple (for PR), or the unpleasant fact that China is not a commodity resource pool, yet.

Shebanator · 3 years ago
People always make this argument, for at least the last 10 years. Since Apple has not yet shown any real action towards reducing their dependency on China, why would it be any different 5 years from now?
Shebanator commented on Did GoogleAI just snooker one of Silicon Valley’s sharpest minds?   garymarcus.substack.com/p... · Posted by u/TeacherTortoise
neaden · 3 years ago
I completely forgot about Google Duplex. It looks like it is still around but very limited in terms of what phones you can use, what cities it can be used in, and what businesses in those cities will accept it. Doesn't appear any progress has really been made in the past few years. I think this is a great point of how companies create something with AI that is initially really cool, but isn't quite there to actually be very usable and gets forgotten when they roll out the next big thing.
Shebanator · 3 years ago
The Hold for Me and Direct My Call features for Pixel's Phone app both use Duplex models running locally on your device, and those features are quite popular. I think that counts as significant progress by any measure, so your point doesn't hold in this case.
Shebanator commented on Patreon Lays off 17% of Staff   blog.patreon.com/a-note-f... · Posted by u/jcalabro
sprkwd · 3 years ago
Doing this on Instagram seems… off. Can’t put my finger in it.
Shebanator · 3 years ago
AFAICT, he told the team separately, and is just using IG to announce publicly. I don't see how that is any worse than the usual dry press release.
Shebanator commented on Design the next iPhone   neal.fun/design-the-next-... · Posted by u/mkeeter
sdflhasjd · 3 years ago
Slap the lighting port in the middle of the screen, so you can't use it while charging.
Shebanator · 3 years ago
The thing I thought was hilarious is that they put in a zillion funny gadgets, but you can't get a USB-C port instead of that godawful Lightning port.
Shebanator commented on Andrej Karpathy leaves Tesla   twitter.com/karpathy/stat... · Posted by u/danols
carbadtraingood · 3 years ago
The cars are real but they are... Mediocre. The first year of ownership is an amazing honeymoon period, assuming you got one with decent build quality. But the parts are cheap, and they break quickly. I've had one for 5+ years and it's gradually become something I prefer driving less and less.
Shebanator · 3 years ago
Your personal experience is not something that can be so easily generalized. I've had my Model 3 for 4+ years, and the only real problems I've had are non-mechanical (nails embedded in tires, getting keyed in SF, etc.). See - we cancel out....
Shebanator commented on The ACLU Has Lost Its Way   theatlantic.com/ideas/arc... · Posted by u/tysone
fieryscribe · 3 years ago
I'm not sure why you're implying that FIRE "despises" speech; perhaps you see them as conservative. That said, here's are some recent situations in which FIRE has taken the side of what would be under the general progressive/liberal umbrella:

* https://www.thefire.org/cases/new-york-university-administra...

* https://www.thefire.org/cases/catholic-university-of-america...

* https://www.thefire.org/cases/suny-brockport-event-featuring...

There are more, for sure, but hopefully this points you in the right direction.

Shebanator · 3 years ago
You should re-read the comment you are replying to. You misunderstood.
Shebanator commented on Some Apple engineers rewarded up to $180k in stock bonuses as incentive to stay   macrumors.com/2021/12/28/... · Posted by u/purplesnowflake
thewebcount · 4 years ago
Keep in mind that it’s $30k the first year. If you get the same bonus the next year, it’s now $60k ($30k from the first grant + $30k from the second). At 4 years you’re now making $120k per year above your salary. On top of that, Apple stock has been doing pretty well for something like 15-20 years now. If you don’t immediately sell, that first $30k you got is now worth significantly more, though there are no guarantees that will continue into the future. But it certainly can work out very nicely. If you start over at a new company, you lose that extra $120k per year for the next 4 years until you’re vested at the new company.
Shebanator · 4 years ago
This is apparently a new and unprecedented bonus from Apple, over and above "normal" stock compensation. I'd be surprised if they repeat this every year.

u/Shebanator

KarmaCake day745March 24, 2011View Original