Readit News logoReadit News
RobertMiller commented on Google will soon ask Australian users to show ID to view some content   reclaimthenet.org/google-... · Posted by u/dannywarner
MiroF · 4 years ago
Are you still not following that this "omission" is something you've entirely made up in your own mind by selectively copying one quote from an entire article?
RobertMiller · 4 years ago
The text you quoted does not seem to convey any displeasure at the law. Think what you like.

> This added step is informed by

Why so passive? Why not "required by"?

> We’ve built our age-verification process in keeping with Google’s Privacy and Security Principles.

Why not omit this apologia?

Also, that statement about the DMCA is on every single search page with DMCA omissions. Do you think Google is going to cite the ID law by name on every page requiring it? I guess we'll find out, but I'm not holding my breath for this.

RobertMiller commented on Google will soon ask Australian users to show ID to view some content   reclaimthenet.org/google-... · Posted by u/dannywarner
MiroF · 4 years ago
You're comparing a quote from an article clearly being written in the context of this Australian law to the actual quote from Google's implementation of DMCa law. There is nothing in your quote indicating they are "protesting" DMCA law.

Here is the full quote.

> Over the coming month, we will also be introducing a new age assurance step on YouTube and Google Play. This added step is informed by the Australian Online Safety (Restricted Access Systems) Declaration, which requires platforms to take reasonable steps to confirm users are adults in order to access content that is potentially inappropriate for viewers under 18.

> This is in line with the actions we took in the European Union in response to the Audiovisual Media Services Directive (AVMSD).

> As part of this process some Australian users may be asked to provide additional proof of age when attempting to watch mature content on YouTube or downloading content on Google Play. If our systems are unable to establish that a viewer is above the age of 18, we will request that they provide a valid ID or credit card to verify their age. We’ve built our age-verification process in keeping with Google’s Privacy and Security Principles.

Pulling out a quote and then saying "they don't mention the law", when they actually do mention the law a few lines above is frankly... a bad objection.

RobertMiller · 4 years ago
They aren't required to disclose any DMCA removals, but choose to anyway, citing the law by name. Pointing out that a law is requiring them to do something is the least anybody can do if they object to that law's requirements. The omission of such a statement is sufficient evidence to conclude they are willing collaborators. A tech corporation like Google does not deserve the benefit of the doubt anyway.
RobertMiller commented on Google will soon ask Australian users to show ID to view some content   reclaimthenet.org/google-... · Posted by u/dannywarner
emteycz · 4 years ago
So why they didn't try to require ID for all the previous years until laws required it?
RobertMiller · 4 years ago
If they want us to believe they're displeased at this requirement, why don't they say so? Google has certainly complained and protested about other laws before.

> In response to multiple complaints we received under the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act, we have removed 15 results from this page. If you wish, you may read the DMCA complaints that caused the removals at LumenDatabase.org:

RobertMiller commented on Google will soon ask Australian users to show ID to view some content   reclaimthenet.org/google-... · Posted by u/dannywarner
nojs · 4 years ago
Ok, so what’s the real reason the government wants this?
RobertMiller · 4 years ago
The "Five Eyes" anglosphere establishment uses Australia as a testbed for authoritarian measures that may later be implemented in the others.
RobertMiller commented on Google will soon ask Australian users to show ID to view some content   reclaimthenet.org/google-... · Posted by u/dannywarner
whimsicalism · 4 years ago
Not sure how you concluded that from this quote
RobertMiller · 4 years ago
A simple "the law requires us to" somewhere in that quote would have gone a long way to convey displeasure at their arm being twisted. But nothing in that quote suggests any arm twisting, and why should google of all corporations be given the benefit of the doubt? They look like eager and willing collaborators.
RobertMiller commented on The British government asked when Microsoft would 'get rid' of algorithms   windowscentral.com/britis... · Posted by u/dane-pgp
RobertMiller · 4 years ago
If I've learned anything from countless gun control debates online, it's that laughing at your opposition for misusing technical terminology is the best way to win a debate.
RobertMiller commented on ‘Give Peace A Chance’, Serbian fans mock US military interventions   euronews.al/en/balkans/20... · Posted by u/ritama2
RobertMiller · 4 years ago
Serbs are still mad NATO interrupted their genocide?
RobertMiller commented on Dogs are good models for human psychiatric disorders, study argues   science.org/content/artic... · Posted by u/whack
psyc · 4 years ago
Couldn’t possibly have anything to do with us observing and communicating with dogs every day for decades.
RobertMiller · 4 years ago
No of course not, animals are soulless automatons without any relatable emotion or reason that humans could ever perceive let alone understand. Anybody who thinks otherwise is just deluded by anthropomorphization and overzealous pattern matching.

An angry dog? No such thing, anger is a human emotion. A happy dog? Again, no such thing. A sad dog? Never existed, sadness is uniquely human.

RobertMiller commented on Fish 3.4.0   fishshell.com/docs/curren... · Posted by u/denisw
lalwanivikas · 4 years ago
My company has default shell as zsh so every tool assumes that. How can I switch to fish in such an environment?
RobertMiller · 4 years ago
You can execute zsh scripts from a fish command line, or any other. Where is the problem?
RobertMiller commented on Fish 3.4.0   fishshell.com/docs/curren... · Posted by u/denisw
brimstedt · 4 years ago
Anyone know of a good comparison between the different shells?
RobertMiller · 4 years ago
There are several feature comparison tables for numerous shells here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_command_shells

u/RobertMiller

KarmaCake day290January 16, 2022View Original